DISCUSS: Mike McCarthy should be Cowboys HC or not ?

If the Dallas Cowboys are going to move on from Mike McCarthy, a wild swap for Pittsburgh Steelers coach Mike Tomlin has been pitched by FOX Sports.
 Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin and Green Bay Packers head coach Mike McCarthy.

The Dallas Cowboys are running out of time to decide Mike McCarthy’s future with the team. Dallas’ exclusive negotiations period with McCarthy on Tuesday, January 14.

If the team doesn’t agree to a new deal, McCarthy will be free to walk. But what would be Jerry Jones? backup plan?

Cowboys legend turned FOX Sports NFL analyst Jimmy Johnson shared his thoughts on how to fix the team’s coaching situation and it involves a swap with the Pittsburgh Steelers and two head coaches that once faced off against each other in a Super Bowl at Cowboys Stadium.

There have been calls for the Steelers to make a change at head coach after Mike Tomlin came up short in the postseason yet again.

So, Bradshaw pitched the Cowboys and Steelers swap head coaches to rejuvenate both franchises.

“Things are stale in Pittsburgh. Things are stale in Dallas,” Johnson said.

“How about a coaching swap? Mike McCarthy is a Pittsburgh guy. Let him go to [the Steelers]. Let Mike Tomlin go to [the Cowboys]. Both franchises would be excited.”

Sure, it’s something to talk about, but it would be a lateral move for both franchises.

Neither head coach has had postseason success in recent memory. Both have had their fair share of achievements in the regular season and won Super Bowls ages ago, but each coach has fallen short of expectations in the postseason.

Green Bay Packers head coach Mike McCarthy greets Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin before Super Bowl XLV. / Matthew Emmons-Imagn Images

And let’s not even mention how Mike Tomlin would deal with Jerry Jones.

Is it something fun to talk about and to make headlines? Sure, and it worked. Is it realistic? Not at all.

Related Posts

49ERS NATION, DROP THE HAMMER! Shanahan has officially found Trent Williams’ terrifying HEIR in this absolute MONSTER 6’7″, 315lb rookie – the throne is being passed RIGHT NOW and San Francisco’s line just became untouchable for the next decade!

SAN FRANCISCO – The throne isn’t just protected. It’s about to be inherited by a freak. In NFL.com’s latest mock draft, 49ers GM John Lynch and head…

BILLS MAFIA, IT’S HAPPENING! The familiar face of defensive mastermind Jim Leonhard is about to LURE Broncos’ elite COMMANDER to Buffalo in a BLOCKBUSTER reunion that could instantly transform their defense into an unstoppable FORCE!

Buffalo, NY – The winds of change are howling through Orchard Park, and Bills fans, buckle up: it’s about to get even more exciting! With the Sean…

49ERS FAITHFUL, SKIP THE PANIC! San Francisco’s stone-cold, ultra-bold chess move in the wildly volatile Maxx Crosby market has just been EXPOSED – waiting until the absolute 11th hour is about to hand them a generational pass-rushing SUPERSTAR for literal PENNIES on the dollar while the rest of the league scrambles and overpays in panic mode!

In the high-stakes world of NFL trades, where blockbuster deals can make or break a franchise’s future, the San Francisco 49ers are playing a masterful game of…

STEELERS FANS, DON’T SLEEP ON THIS: The 49ers’ trade proposal dumping Mac Jones on Pittsburgh in exchange for a 7.5-sack EDGE beast could quietly FIX their QB depth crisis while the Niners steal a rising star pass rusher!

The San Francisco 49ers have an interesting opportunity this offseason. They have Brock Purdy as the starting quarterback and a very valuable Mac Jones as a backup….

STEELERS FANS, HOLD UP: The Vikings WR everyone’s sleeping on could be the sneaky DEPTH WEAPON that quietly transforms Pittsburgh’s offense overnight!

Nov 16, 2025; Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA; Minnesota Vikings wide receiver Jalen Nailor (1) runs for a gain during the fourth quarter against the Chicago Bears at U.S….

🚨 BREAKING THE SAINTS–ALVIN KAMARA TRADE BUZZ IS SPIRALING OUT OF CONTROL, аѕ leаgue іnѕіderѕ, rіvаl ѕcoutѕ, аnd ѕocіаl medіа detectіveѕ fuel а whіrlwіnd of ѕрeculаtіon thаt now hаѕ New Orleаnѕ brаcіng for а рotentіаl blockbuѕter decіѕіon thаt could redefіne the frаnchіѕe’ѕ future. 👇👇

The New Orleаnѕ ѕаіntѕ аre а teаm thаt cаn mаke ѕome ѕerіouѕ noіѕe іn 2026. New Orleаnѕ found the ѕtаrtіng quаrterbаck іt hаѕ been lookіng for іn…