DISCUSS: Mike McCarthy should be Cowboys HC or not ?

If the Dallas Cowboys are going to move on from Mike McCarthy, a wild swap for Pittsburgh Steelers coach Mike Tomlin has been pitched by FOX Sports.
 Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin and Green Bay Packers head coach Mike McCarthy.

The Dallas Cowboys are running out of time to decide Mike McCarthy’s future with the team. Dallas’ exclusive negotiations period with McCarthy on Tuesday, January 14.

If the team doesn’t agree to a new deal, McCarthy will be free to walk. But what would be Jerry Jones? backup plan?

Cowboys legend turned FOX Sports NFL analyst Jimmy Johnson shared his thoughts on how to fix the team’s coaching situation and it involves a swap with the Pittsburgh Steelers and two head coaches that once faced off against each other in a Super Bowl at Cowboys Stadium.

There have been calls for the Steelers to make a change at head coach after Mike Tomlin came up short in the postseason yet again.

So, Bradshaw pitched the Cowboys and Steelers swap head coaches to rejuvenate both franchises.

“Things are stale in Pittsburgh. Things are stale in Dallas,” Johnson said.

“How about a coaching swap? Mike McCarthy is a Pittsburgh guy. Let him go to [the Steelers]. Let Mike Tomlin go to [the Cowboys]. Both franchises would be excited.”

Sure, it’s something to talk about, but it would be a lateral move for both franchises.

Neither head coach has had postseason success in recent memory. Both have had their fair share of achievements in the regular season and won Super Bowls ages ago, but each coach has fallen short of expectations in the postseason.

Green Bay Packers head coach Mike McCarthy greets Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin before Super Bowl XLV. / Matthew Emmons-Imagn Images

And let’s not even mention how Mike Tomlin would deal with Jerry Jones.

Is it something fun to talk about and to make headlines? Sure, and it worked. Is it realistic? Not at all.

Related Posts

Just hours after Green Bay Mayor Eric Genrich spoke with confidence, everything suddenly shifted… as Green Bay Packers president Ed Policy announced a shocking delay of the $120 million Don Hutson Center expansion until 2030. What looked like steady progress now feels uncertain — and fans are left wondering what really changed behind the scenes.

Green Bay, Wisconsin – Just three hours after a public statement from Eric Genrich, Ed Policy made a surprising announcement that has shaken the Packers community. The Green…

A deep sense of shock and sorrow now surrounds the Kansas City Chiefs as news emerges of a 6-time Pro Bowl legend’s tragic passing at 65 — and the fact that authorities are now investigating only adds a layer of unease no one was prepared for. This isn’t just loss… it’s a story that feels heavier the more details begin to surface.

The football world is mourning after the reported passing of former NFL star safety Joey Browner at the age of 65. The tragic news has shocked fans across the…

For weeks, the noise kept growing… and now the truth finally hits. The Dallas Cowboys’ hopes of landing Myles Garrett have just been addressed directly by the Cleveland Browns GM — and the message changes everything fans thought they knew. What once felt possible now carries a completely different weight.

It’s the end of March in the NFL and if you’re a fan of any team–certainly a fan of the Dallas Cowboys–you’d like to be able to cling…

🚨BREAKING: MAHOMES JUST SENT A CHILL THROUGH THE LEAGUE — Patrick Mahomes delivered a quiet message to Chiefs Kingdom, but insiders say it hit harder than any headline. This wasn’t noise… it was a cold, calculated signal that something dangerous is brewing in Kansas City. 👀🔥👇👇

KANSAS CITY — The 2025 season did not end the way the Kansas City Chiefs or their fans had hoped. For a franchise that has spent the last several years…

🚨BREAKING: BALTIMORE IS ABOUT TO PAY BIG — Zay Flowers just ignited contract chaos after Lamar Jackson dropped a cryptic “dat deal” hint, and insiders say the extension is already in motion. This isn’t just business… it’s a rising star about to cash in as the WR market explodes. 👀🔥👇👇

While quarterback Lamar Jackson watched several teammates depart this offseason, the Baltimore Ravens appear increasingly determined to keep one of his closest allies in place. Wide receiver…

Age was supposed to slow him down… but instead, it’s making the San Francisco 49ers think even bigger. A 34-year-old still dominating with a 70.7 PFF grade has insiders whispering about a move that could shake the entire roster — and if it happens, it won’t just be bold… it’ll be a statement no one saw coming.

The San Francisco 49ers remain firmly in win-now mode heading into the 2026 NFL season, and they are showing no signs of slowing down in their pursuit…