DISCUSS: Mike McCarthy should be Cowboys HC or not ?

If the Dallas Cowboys are going to move on from Mike McCarthy, a wild swap for Pittsburgh Steelers coach Mike Tomlin has been pitched by FOX Sports.
 Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin and Green Bay Packers head coach Mike McCarthy.

The Dallas Cowboys are running out of time to decide Mike McCarthy’s future with the team. Dallas’ exclusive negotiations period with McCarthy on Tuesday, January 14.

If the team doesn’t agree to a new deal, McCarthy will be free to walk. But what would be Jerry Jones? backup plan?

Cowboys legend turned FOX Sports NFL analyst Jimmy Johnson shared his thoughts on how to fix the team’s coaching situation and it involves a swap with the Pittsburgh Steelers and two head coaches that once faced off against each other in a Super Bowl at Cowboys Stadium.

There have been calls for the Steelers to make a change at head coach after Mike Tomlin came up short in the postseason yet again.

So, Bradshaw pitched the Cowboys and Steelers swap head coaches to rejuvenate both franchises.

“Things are stale in Pittsburgh. Things are stale in Dallas,” Johnson said.

“How about a coaching swap? Mike McCarthy is a Pittsburgh guy. Let him go to [the Steelers]. Let Mike Tomlin go to [the Cowboys]. Both franchises would be excited.”

Sure, it’s something to talk about, but it would be a lateral move for both franchises.

Neither head coach has had postseason success in recent memory. Both have had their fair share of achievements in the regular season and won Super Bowls ages ago, but each coach has fallen short of expectations in the postseason.

Green Bay Packers head coach Mike McCarthy greets Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin before Super Bowl XLV. / Matthew Emmons-Imagn Images

And let’s not even mention how Mike Tomlin would deal with Jerry Jones.

Is it something fun to talk about and to make headlines? Sure, and it worked. Is it realistic? Not at all.

Related Posts

🚨BREAKING: A FALL FROM GRACE… AND A DESPERATE PLEA FOR REDEMPTION — а former fіrѕt-round WR іѕ ѕhаkіng the leаgue аfter beggіng the Phіlаdelрhіа Eаgleѕ for one lаѕt ѕhot followіng hіѕ releаѕe from рrіѕon. Thіѕ іѕn’t juѕt а comebаck аttemрt… іt’ѕ а mаn wіllіng to ѕtаrt from ZERO, chаѕіng а ѕecond chаnce іn а leаgue thаt rаrely forgіveѕ. The NFL іѕ wаtchіng cloѕely. 👀🔥👇👇

рhіlаdelрhіа, рennѕylvаnіа – іn а ѕtunnіng аnd heаdlіne-grаbbіng develoрment, the former wіde receіver ѕelected іn the fіrѕt round (ріck 12) of the 2020 NFL Drаft by the…

🚨BREAKING: A Packers All-Pro rookie just turned down a $30 MILLION offer from the Bears — choosing loyalty and a reunion with Jonathan Gannon instead. This isn’t about money… it’s about trust, system, and a vision that clearly means more than the biggest paycheck. When a young star makes this call, the entire NFL takes notice. 👀🔥👇👇

Green Bay, WI — The Green Bay Packers have made a high-quality addition to their interior defensive line after veteran defensive tackle Javon Hargrave decided to turn down a lucrative offer…

🚨BREAKING: DETROIT’S BLUEPRINT IS COMING TO LIFE — the Lions’ full 7-round draft plan is starting to take shape, and insiders believe this class could quietly redefine the franchise’s future. This isn’t just projections… it’s a layered strategy built to add impact, depth, and long-term dominance after the Combine. Something BIG is building in Detroit. 👀🔥👇👇

The Detroit Lions lost their identity in 2025. Detroit’s offense did not look the same without Ben Johnson or Frank Ragnow, which contributed to a 9-8 record. Now the Lions have…

🚨BREAKING: THE COMEBACK IS REAL — Derek Carr is quietly plotting his 2026 return just as NFL free agency hits a boiling point. This isn’t just another name entering the market… it’s a veteran QB with unfinished business stepping back into chaos, ready to flip the narrative in one move. When Carr enters the frenzy, things get VERY interesting. 👀🔥👇👇

Las Vegas, NV – March 2026. Derek Carr is back on the NFL radar after a brief hiatus. The four-time Pro Bowler, Derek Carr, has announced plans…

🚨BREAKING: DEFORREST BUCKNER JUST SENT A MESSAGE THE NFL CAN’T IGNORE — while others chase the biggest bag, he’s willing to take LESS to return to the 49ers and finish what he started. This isn’t business… it’s unfinished legacy, loyalty, and a Super Bowl dream that still burns in San Francisco. In a league driven by money, Buckner just proved some players are built DIFFERENT. 👀🔥👇👇

DeForest Buckner shocked the NFL community when he decided to turn down his biggest contract ever to return to the San Francisco 49ers. Despite the opportunity to…

🚨BREAKING: The Dallas Cowboys are preparing a BLOCKBUSTER move to replace George Pickens with a 1,200-yard game-changing WR — and it signals a major shift in how this offense is about to operate. This isn’t just a swap… it’s a statement that Dallas is ready to evolve, get more explosive, and chase something bigger. 👀🔥👇👇

The Dаllаѕ Cowboyѕ muѕt refurbіѕh theіr defenѕe іn the 2026 NFL Drаft (ѕcheduled арrіl 23–25 іn ріttѕburgh), but there’ѕ lіttle downѕіde to tаkіng іndіаnа Hooѕіerѕ wіde receіver…