The Buffalo Bills have been one of the NFL’s most impressive teams in 2025, starting the season 4-0 and standing as one of only two undefeated teams remaining in the league. But despite their strong performance, the team has hit a snag at the punter position due to an injury to Cameron Johnston. The injury has left the Bills in need of a replacement, and they’ve quickly turned to Mitch Wishnowsky to fill the void.

Johnston, who took over as the Bills’ punter in Week 2, was performing well until he was forced to leave the team’s Week 4 victory over the New Orleans Saints with foot and ankle injuries. With Johnston now placed on injured reserve and expected to miss at least four games, the Bills had to act quickly to secure a punter for the upcoming weeks. Enter Mitch Wishnowsky.

The Search for a New Punter

While the Bills initially began the season with Brad Robbins as their punter, the team made a move after their season-opening win against the Baltimore Ravens, releasing Robbins. They subsequently signed Johnston, who has since been sidelined. Although bringing Robbins back seemed like a logical option, the Bills front office opted for a fresh direction, choosing to sign veteran Australian punter Mitch Wishnowsky.

Wishnowsky spent the first six seasons of his NFL career with the San Francisco 49ers, earning a reputation for his powerful leg and consistency. However, after struggling with a back injury that kept him out for the final eight games of the 2024 season, he was released by the 49ers. Now fully healthy, Wishnowsky has been waiting for another opportunity to prove himself—and he’s found that chance with the Bills.

What Wishnowsky Brings to the Table

The 31-year-old punter will be tasked with quickly getting up to speed with his new team. Having been out of game action for nearly a year, there will likely be some rust to shake off, but Wishnowsky is no stranger to the NFL spotlight. If he can regain his earlier form with the 49ers, he could become a valuable asset to Buffalo’s special teams.

The timing couldn’t be more critical for the Bills, as they prepare for a crucial Week 5 matchup against the New England Patriots on Sunday Night Football. With the Patriots sitting at 2-2 and looking to gain ground in the AFC East, this game is pivotal for Buffalo, which will aim to stay undefeated and keep its strong momentum going. The Bills will need solid play from every aspect of the team—including special teams—if they are to secure a win and move to 5-0.

Looking Ahead to the Patriots Game

While the punter change could shake up the special teams unit, it’s not expected to derail the Bills’ overall performance, especially given their stellar play on offense and defense. Quarterback Josh Allen and the offense have been firing on all cylinders, and with the Patriots likely to provide their toughest test of the season so far, Buffalo’s special teams unit will need to step up and ensure that every aspect of the game is covered.

For Mitch Wishnowsky, his new role in Buffalo is a chance to prove himself once again. He’s ready to bring his experience, consistency, and leg power to help the Bills maintain their perfect start to the season. As Wishnowsky said, “I’m ready to step up and contribute. Buffalo’s got a great team, and I’m here to help keep the momentum going.”

As the Bills aim to continue their undefeated streak, all eyes will be on Wishnowsky to see if he can provide the stability they need at punter. With a critical division game on the horizon, the Bills will need every advantage they can get—starting with their new punter.