A 49ers spring revival? Not if Brock Purdy’s contract remains unresolved

A 49ers spring revival? Not if Brock Purdy’s contract remains unresolved


The final question San Francisco 49ers CEO Jed York fielded at this week’s annual league meeting was whether he felt the Brock Purdy contract talks have been productive.

“I don’t negotiate contracts,” he said, “but any conversations I’ve had with Brock personally have been great. So I feel good. And when he’s ready, we’ll sit down and finish it. It shouldn’t be that hard to do.”

There are a couple of ways to interpret that.

One is that the deal isn’t all that complicated and it will get done quickly. The 49ers agree that Purdy is among the best quarterbacks in the league — York described him as a top-10 passer — and that he’ll be paid as such. The two sides just need to settle on a number. It ought to be easy.

The other way — and probably the correct way — is to emphasize the word “shouldn’t.” Picture two guys struggling to move a couch through a narrow apartment doorway. They bang the doorframe. The couch gets wedged. They’re not twisting and tilting in unison and they’re going nowhere.

“Just put it down!” one guy finally yells, sweat dripping from his brow. “Let’s hold on and figure this out. This shouldn’t be that hard to do.”

The quotes about Purdy’s deal from the league meeting continued to sound optimistic.

“Brock wants to be with us. We want Brock to be with us,” general manager John Lynch said. “When that’s the case, these things typically get done.”

“I think he’s great, and especially when you combine him with Kyle (Shanahan) and you combine him with what we have (on the roster),” York said. “He’s a heck of a quarterback and we want him to be here for a long, long time.”

But they were virtually the same quotes we heard at Lynch and Shanahan’s end-of-season news conference in January and that Lynch gave at the scouting combine in February. Nothing’s changed. The negotiation appears to be at a standstill and the clock is ticking.

The 49ers begin their offseason program on April 22. That’s the de facto beginning of the season for an NFL team, when players who have been recovering and training in other parts of the country reassemble at their team facilities. It’s also the time by which Purdy said he wanted to get the deal done.

“I want to get it done quick,” he said in January. “Just so we can get back for Phase 1, get after it with our receivers and our team. I’m not the kind of guy that wants to have any kind of drama associated with anything.”

Shanahan, meanwhile, on Tuesday spoke enthusiastically about the upcoming offseason program, contrasting it with the previous years’ sessions in which the 49ers were still recovering — physically and mentally — from long runs through the playoffs. This year, just about everyone will be fresh, he said. And he’s expecting strong attendance.

“I think we’ll have a hell of a turnout with all of our guys, just (in) talking to ’em,” he said.

The 49ers have some leverage in the Purdy negotiations. Lynch, for example, always slides into his answers that Purdy has one more year remaining on his ultra-affordable rookie contract. He did so at the combine and again Monday.

“Does it happen this offseason?” he said of an extension. “I don’t know. Hopefully, it happens real soon this offseason.”

The 49ers control Purdy’s contract situation for the next three seasons. As it stands, he’s under contract for $5.3 million in 2025 and they could apply the franchise tag the following two seasons.

It’s also worth noting that they recently brought in Mac Jones, someone whom Shanahan once thought worthy of the No. 3 pick in the draft. No, Jones hasn’t played up to that billing — not even close — but Shanahan and the 49ers did help another former first-round quarterback, Sam Darnold, resurrect his sputtering career two years ago. Having Jones as your No. 2 passer gives you a bit more bargaining power than having Brandon Allen in that spot.

“I just loved how he played the position, especially in college,” Shanahan said of Jones. “He got the ball to the right spots, didn’t take sacks, would hang in there and get hit and distribute the ball to his playmakers. I’ve seen him do it in the NFL at a high level. We’re excited to get him working in our offense.”

Purdy, however, has better leverage.

First, the 49ers’ recent offseason roster purge was done in anticipation of a hefty, new deal for Purdy. How do you reconcile saying goodbye to Dre Greenlaw, Talanoa Hufanga, Aaron Banks, Javon Hargrave, Leonard Floyd and Maliek Collins and not have a new contract for Purdy completed?

Second, the team simply can’t afford to have yet another offseason dominated by a contract dispute. In 2023, it was Nick Bosa’s, which wasn’t resolved until Sept. 7. Last year, it was Trent Williams’ and Brandon Aiyuk’s, which cast a dark cloud on the entire offseason and then bled into the regular season.

Aiyuk, who finished the 2023 season with 1,342 receiving yards, didn’t start practicing until late August and, not coincidentally, averaged 42 yards and zero touchdowns in his first four games.

 

Do the 49ers want Brock Purdy’s contract situation to turn ugly like Brandon Aiyuk’s did last offseason? (Mark J. Rebilas / Imagn Images)

The 49ers seem to be betting that Purdy isn’t Aiyuk, that he very much wants to avoid the drama that marked Aiyuk’s contract dispute, that he feels duty-bound to lead the 49ers in 2025 and that he’ll sign on the dotted line sooner rather than later.

But that’s a big gamble.

The first two weeks of the offseason program that begins April 22 are limited to meetings, strength and conditioning, and rehabilitation. It would set an ominous tone but wouldn’t be the end of the world if Purdy’s deal isn’t completed by then.

But what happens if he isn’t there two weeks later when quarterbacks can start throwing to their receivers? Or if he isn’t participating when the 49ers hit the field for their first OTA practice on May 27? Or if the contract’s not done by the mandatory minicamp that starts June 10?

Shanahan wants this to be an offseason of energy, of competition, of momentum, of rebirth. That’ll be difficult to attain if his starting quarterback is absent, if he’s watching from the sideline or even if he’s practicing despite an unresolved contract looming over the organization.

If that’s the case, it won’t be a spring revival. It’ll be more of the same.

(Photo: Julio Aguilar / Getty Images)

Matt Barrows is a senior writer for The Athletic covering the 49ers. He joined The Athletic in 2018 and has covered the 49ers since 2003. He was a reporter with The Sacramento Bee for 19 years, four of them as a Metro reporter. Before that he spent two years in South Carolina with The Hilton Head Island Packet. Follow Matt on Twitter @MattBarrows

Related Posts

🐕 MOTHER DOG HEROICS: Brave mother dog crosses dangerous terrain to protect her puppy, whispers spread of the fearless act across social media, animal lovers and neighbors are moved by her unwavering courage, and the burning question is… will both survive safely and inspire others with their story?..ll

In the animal world, much like in human society, a mother’s love and protective instincts stand out as some of the most powerful forces.

🚨 BREAKING QUESTION: The Lіonѕ аre аnxіouѕly аwаіtіng Alіm McNeіll’ѕ return аѕ theіr defenѕіve аnchor — but the bіg queѕtіon loomѕ, wіll he be bаck before the bye week to ѕtаbіlіze Detroіt’ѕ front lіne?

The Detroit Lions defense has been quietly holding its own, but one absence has loomed large: Alim McNeill. The interior force of Detroit’s front line has been sidelined, leaving the unit without its most disruptive presence in the trenches. Now, whispers around Allen Park are hinting that his long-awaited return could be closer than anyone expected.

🚨 BREAKING UPDATE: Lіonѕ DT Alіm McNeіll аdmіtѕ he hаd “no dаrk dаyѕ” durіng hіѕ іnjury rehаb ѕhowіng rаre рoѕіtіvіty аnd mentаl ѕtrength thаt іnѕріred Detroіt’ѕ locker room

The Detroit Lioпs already lost oпe startiпg member of the secoпdary iп Sυпday’s wiп over the Clevelaпd Browпs, aпd пow coυld be at risk of missiпg a third for

🚨 BREAKING TRADE BUZZ: Sаіntѕ–Vіkіngѕ trаde ѕрeculаtіon іѕ heаtіng uр wіth іnѕіderѕ рoіntіng to а key New Orleаnѕ ѕtаrter who could be the рerfect fіt іn Mіnneѕotа ѕраrkіng mаjor NFC chаtter

The New Orleаnѕ ѕаіntѕ hаve а chаnce to domіnаte the trаde deаdlіne іf they cаn mаnаge theіr аѕѕetѕ іn the beѕt wаy рoѕѕіble. New Orleаnѕ hаѕ а…

🚨 BREAKING QUESTION: Wіll а heаlthy Tаyѕom Hіll return аѕ the ѕtаrtіng quаrterbаck for the ѕtrugglіng New Orleаnѕ Sаіntѕ? Buzz іѕ heаtіng uр іn New Orleаnѕ аѕ fаnѕ debаte іf hіѕ verѕаtіlіty could ѕраrk а turnаround.

Taysom Hill has delighted BYU fans from the time he began his tenure in Provo in 2012 up until the present day with his NFL heroics. The 35-year-old veteran re

💥 COWBOYS REBOUND: Trevon Diggs makes a bold request to Matt Eberflus following disciplinary action, whispers suggest the move could reshape defensive dynamics, teammates watch closely as tensions and trust hang in the balance, and the burning question is… will Diggs’ plea be granted in time to impact Dallas’ next big game?..ll

In a contest with many emotions, star defensive back Trevon Diggs did not start against his former teammate, Micah Parsons, and the Packers.