Yankees’ 3 best Juan Soto backup plans

As the bidding for superstar outfielder Juan Soto reportedly escalates above $700 million, a few teams still remain in the hunt. Both New York teams, the Yankees and Mets, currently have the biggest offers on the table. The Boston Red Sox, Toronto Blue Jays and Los Angeles Dodgers are behind them but still very much in the race. According to reports from the New York Post’s Jon Heyman, the saga of Soto’s free agency could end within the next day or two.

If that is the case, then there’s a decent chance in which Soto leaves the Bronx. He spent one year with the Yankees, finishing third in the AL MVP race behind teammate Aaron Judge, who captured his second MVP award, and Kansas City Royals shortstop Bobby Witt Jr. He compiled a WAR of 7.9 and showed why he’s one of the best baseball players on the planet. The fact that he is in free agency at age 26, right before the start of his theoretical prime, is something that the entirety of Major League Baseball, is salivating over.

Let’s say Soto leaves Yankee Stadium and joins the Mets, Blue Jays or another one of his pursuers. Where should Yankees owner Hal Steinbrenner and GM Brian Cashman turn to? Their first call should be to Japanese phenom Roki Sasaki, who has the ability to be the best Japanese prospect to come stateside since Shohei Ohtani. In addition to Sasaki, who else should they pursue?

Roki Sasaki should be part of Yankees’ backup plan (and Plan A, too)

Yankees' 3 best Juan Soto backup plans
Mandatory Credit: Sam Navarro-Imagn Images

Much like Ohtani in 2017, Sasaki is subject to international bonus pool rules. So, he can’t sign a mega contract like fellow countryman Yoshinobu Yamamoto did with the Dodgers last winter. Each team is limited in what they can offer him financially. However, the Yankees must find a way to move past the money and show Sasaki all of the good things he can do in New York. If they can convince him to call the Bronx his first major-league home, it will be a major rebound if they lose Soto. In fact, even if Soto does return to Yankee Stadium, Sasaki should still be a focus of Cashman and the brass.

The Japanese starting pitcher will pitch all of 2025 at 23 years old, so he still has a lot of time left in his career. Many scouts believe him to be a “top-end starter,” as he possesses three-plus pitches, including his fastball, splitter and slider. Throughout his time in the Nippon Professional Baseball (NPB) league, Sasaki has routinely confused hitters. Will that early (yet sustained) success transfer to Major League Baseball? That’s something the Yankees should desperately try to find out.

Pete Alonso, Gleyber Torres can help Yankees offense

Related New York Yankees NewsArticle continues below

Let’s say Soto goes to the Mets. What would be the best way that the Bombers could hurt their crosstown rivals? By poaching Alonso, their star first baseman. Alonso has starred at Citi Field for his whole career so far, so it is apparent that he can handle the bright lights of New York. Furthermore, this would address the team’s biggest hole in the lineup: first base.

Veteran Anthony Rizzo might retire after the team declined his option, and he spent most of last season dealing with injuries. His primary replacement, Ben Rice, showed that he might need a bit more development in the minors before trying to take over the position full-time. Alonso is ready to go right now. Adding him would help fill a big portion of what Soto leaves behind, and he would instantly become a leader for the Yankees.

Along with Alonso, they need to bring back Gleyber Torres. The second baseman has spent his entire major league career with the Yankees and loves playing for the team. It is likely that returning to Yankee Stadium full time is at the top of his list. If Soto walks, then Steinbrenner and Cashman should have the money to bring Gleyber back home. Currently, the team doesn’t have a replacement readily available. They have options, but nothing set in stone. A Torres/Yankees reunion would make a lot of sense. That is, if Plan A of bringing Soto back home doesn’t work. For the Bombers’ sake, they hope it does.

Related Posts

🚨 MLB INSIDE RESET: The White Sox’s newly assembled coaching staff is raising quiet but serious questions across the league, as subtle hires, shifted responsibilities, and a clear change in philosophy hint at a deeper organizational reset. What looks like routine restructuring on the surface may actually signal a long term plan that hasn’t been fully explained yet — and insiders believe the real impact will only become clear once the season pressure hits.

The Chicago White Sox have finalized their coaching staff for the 2026 season following sweeping changes made at the end of September.

🚨 MLB INSIDE TRADE RUMBLINGS: The Braves are suddenly being linked to a bold trade for a $6 million NL rival left hander, a move insiders say could quietly solve multiple problems at once and even position him as a long term heir to Chris Sale. What looks like a low risk deal on paper may actually hide a far bigger plan, with Atlanta reportedly intrigued by a dynamic arsenal that hasn’t fully been unlocked yet — and the timing of this rumor is raising serious eyebrows across the league.

The Braves could go after a young star.

🚨 MLB INSIDE STORM BREWING: As hopes of an Alex Bregman return quietly fade, a new projection suggests the Red Sox may be preparing a jaw dropping $186 million swing for Bo Bichette, a move insiders believe could redefine Boston’s future in one bold stroke. What once seemed unrealistic is now gaining traction behind the scenes, and if this prediction turns real, the ripple effect could shock the AL East and completely change how this offseason is remembered.

A former MLB executive now believes that the Boston Red Sox will land coveted free agent infielder Bo Bichette from Toronto.

🚨 MLB INSIDE WHISPERS: Something big is quietly brewing behind closed doors in New York, as new projections hint the Yankees may be lining up an elite shortstop signing that goes far beyond a normal free-agency move. What started as a low-key prediction is now being viewed as a potential power shift, with insiders suggesting this decision could redefine the Yankees’ identity and force the entire American League to adjust sooner than expected.

The New York Yankees haven’t done much during the offseason, but MLB rumors continue to swirl. New York has been […]

Cubs Predicted To Land Marquee Free Agent Starting Pitcher On Six-Year Contract

The Cubs are in the market for a top-of-the-rotation starting pitcher, and David Schoenfield of ESPN predicted them to land Framber Valdez, previously of the Houston Astros.

🚨 INSIDE NFL REVELATION: The Packers reportedly had a stunning opportunity to sign an all time great for just $5 million, yet chose to walk away without even making a free agent offer — a quiet decision that is now raising serious questions inside the fanbase and league circles alike. What seemed insignificant at the time is suddenly being revisited as a potential turning point, with insiders suggesting this missed move could have changed far more than anyone realized.

Green Bay missed an opportunity.