Yankees Rookie Starter Dropped From Playoff Roster? One Stat Shows Reason

By

JON VANKIN is a journalist and writer. He is the author of five nonfiction books and nine graphic novels. His writing has appeared in The New York Times Magazine, Salon, the L.A. Weekly and dozens of other publications and he has received numerous awards and honors including three New England Press Association awards.

In connection with his work, Vankin has made numerous media appearances on such networks as CNN, CNBC, FOX, the BBC and the CBC as well as hundreds of radio stations and podcasts.

Vankin in his wide-ranging career has also served as an editor of comic books and newspapers. He is the editor of the NEW YORK TIMES #1 BESTSELLING graphic novel GET JIRO! by the late, great Anthony Bourdain. He co-wrote the hit Off Broadway musical FOREVER DUSTY, and served as a sportswriter and editor at The Daily Yomiuri, the English-language edition of Japan’s largest newspaper, the Yomiuri Shimbun, in Tokyo.

Jon Vankin

Contributing Sports Writer

With the season about to enter its final week, the New York Yankees finally appear assured of a playoff spot. Fangraphs put their odds on Friday at 99.9 percent.

That means manager Aaron Boone is already thinking about how to arrange his pitching staff for a postseason run that he hopes will take the Bronx Bombers to the World Series for the second straight year.

Yankees Rookie Starter Dropped From Playoff Roster? One Stat Shows Reason
MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA – SEPTEMBER 16: Manager Aaron Boone #17 of the New York Yankees calls to the bullpen against the Minnesota Twins in the sixth inning of the game at Target Field on September 16,…Stephen Maturen/Getty Images

There is one pitcher who, despite grinding his way to 31 starts this season, is in serious danger of not making the postseason roster at all: rookie Will Warren.

In the postseason — especially in the best-of-three wild card round where the Yankees will almost certainly open their playoff campaign — teams generally require only three starting pitchers rather than the five-man rotation standard in the regular season.

Ace Max Fried, along with No. 2 starter Carlos Rodon, have the top two spots sewn up. Warren would appear to be the logical candidate for the third, but he has worn down toward the end of the season. A 10-hit, six-run, five-inning outing against the Boston Red Sox in his most recent start may have sealed his fate.

More MLB: Yankees Reliever Lists Gripes About Fenway Park Bullpen

The emergence of last year’s Rookie of the Year Luis Gil, and another rookie this season, Cam Schlitter, appear to bring the competition for the third postseason spot down to those two.

Why not move Warren to the bullpen?

The Yankees ‘pen needs help. In fact, relief pitching has clearly been the Yankees’ weakest point. Relievers have allowed 303 runs, more than any MLB team now in a playoff position.

Their 31 bullpen losses are second only to the New York Mets (34) among teams that enter Friday’s action in wild card or division-leading places.

The bullpen needs help and could easily be the Yankees downfall in a short playoff series. But as one stat highlighted by Yanks Go Yard analyst Colin Keane makes clear, Warren is not the answer.

More MLB: Yankees $80 Million Former MVP’s One Condition For Contract Extension Revealed

“Sadly for Warren (and the Yankees), just because Warren doesn’t fit in the playoff rotation doesn’t mean he’ll be a good fit in the bullpen,” Keane wrote. “In fact, an alarming trend for Warren — his tendency to be terrible in the first inning of starts against good teams — reads like the worst possible resumé for a prospective reliever.”

What do the numbers show about Warren in his first inning of work, against all teams (not just good ones)? The 26-year-old has allowed 22 first-inning runs this season. That is (tied with four other pitchers) the fifth-most in MLB. His first-inning ERA of 6.29 is also fifth-worst.

“Boone and Co. will have a ton of explaining to do if they throw Warren into the middle of a postseason situation and don’t get a desirable result,” Keane concluded.

Boone may choose to go with Warren anyway, knowing that the Yankees bullpen as it currently stands will likely block the path to a repeat World Series run. But if only one of Gil or Schlitter can make the postseason rotation, the other would serve as a safer addition to the relief corp than Warren.

More MLB: Yankees Hit With Dire Warning Of ‘Ominous Truth’ About Playoff Hopes

Related Posts

🚨BOMBSHELL: One crucial question the NY Mets need to answer about Carlos Beltran after his Hall of Fame announcement — will the organization finally recognize his legacy and what he meant to the franchise, or will the past controversies overshadow his well-deserved honor? As Beltran’s induction stirs emotions, fans are eager to see how the Mets respond. Can the team embrace the moment, or will they struggle with the weight of history…ll 👇👇👇

CARLOS BELTRAN TO ENTER COOPERSTOWN WEARING A METS CAP—NOW THE QUESTION: WHEN WILL HIS NUMBER BE RETIRED? BREAKING NEWS: Carlos Beltran, one of the most iconic players…

Report: Timing Is Everything — and the Orioles’ Framber Valdez Pursuit Reflects That. With competition still forming, Baltimore appears uniquely positioned to turn this into a golden opportunity rather than a bidding war.

Seriously, Now Might Be the Time for the Orioles to Just Sign Framber Valdez Already At this point in the offseason, the ongoing “will they or won’t…

Breaking!! What Once Felt Like Patience Now Feels Like Pressure in Baltimore. The Orioles being tied to a $200M, two-time All-Star suggests a calculated win-now shift that could redefine the franchise’s immediate future.

JUST IN: A Bold Win-Now Shift Emerges as the Orioles Are Linked to a $200 Million Two-Time All-Star Following the White Sox Deal The tone surrounding the…

🚨EXCLUSIVE: Nolan McLean drops a truth bomb about Freddy Peralta’s impact on the Mets, revealing how the ace pitcher could elevate their pitching staff to new heights. McLean’s insight has fans buzzing, as Peralta’s potential to shake up the rotation becomes the hot topic in New York. Will this unexpected connection push the Mets to the top, or is it just another pipe dream…ll 👇👇👇

NEW YORK METS ACQUIRE FREDDY PERALTA TO LEAD ROTATION: A GAME-CHANGER FOR 2026 SEASON BREAKING NEWS: The New York Mets made a major move in their pursuit…

BRAVES NEWS: This Wasn’t a Revelation or a Projection — Spencer Strider Simply Confirmed What Braves Fans Already Believe About Spencer Schwellenbach

Spencer Strider’s Words on Spencer Schwellenbach Confirm What Braves Fans Already Know Spencer Strider didn’t break news. He confirmed a feeling. When the Atlanta Braves ace recently…

🚨REPORT: The Mets are among the top favorites to land a $210 million free agent, and the deal could reshape the landscape of the MLB. With their aggressive approach in the market, New York is making a major push to strengthen their roster for the upcoming season. Will this big-money move catapult the Mets into championship contention, or will it fall short of expectations…ll 👇👇👇

NEW YORK METS LINKED TO FRAMBER VALDEZ AS THEY LOOK TO BOLSTER THEIR ROTATION FOR 2026 SEASON BREAKING NEWS: After a disappointing 2025 season, the New York…