Rob Thomson finally admits harsh reality about Nick Castellanos’ place with Phillies

Philadelphia Phillies outfielder Nick Castellanos

Philadelphia Phillies fans and media love scrutinizing the daily lineups that manager Rob Thomson puts together for 162 games every season. One of the most recent obsessions has been with the corner outfield spots and specifically right field. More specifically, we’ve all become captivated by the building drama around Nick Castellanos’ current role on the team.

Ahead of Thursday’s series finale against the Milwaukee Brewers, Thomson put out a lineup that was missing Castellanos’ name for the second time in three games, per On Pattison’s Tim Kelly. Media in attendance, including MLB.com’s Paul Casella, questioned the Phillies skipper about the status of right field and whether it’s now a full-on platoon situation.

Rob Thomson, Phillies finally admit Nick Castellanos needs to be in right-field platoon

The simple answer is yes. Not that Thomson actually said the word “platoon.” He might as well have though, considering the answer he gave during his pre-game scrum.

“It looks that way,” Thomson said, per Casella. “I mean, you can call it whatever you want, but at this point in the year, I’m gonna put out what I think is the best lineup on any given day to win.”

Nick Castellanos isn’t starting for 2nd time in 3 games. Fair to say RF is a full-on platoon?

Rob Thomson: “It looks that way. I mean, you can call it whatever you want, but at this point in the year, I’m gonna put out what I think is the best lineup on any given day to win.”

https://twitter.com/Paul_CasellaMLB/status/1963679855779938474?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw

With Brewers ace Freddy Peralta, a right-hander, on the bump for the finale, Thomson loaded up his lineup with left-handed bats. That included Brandon Marsh in left field and Max Kepler patrolling right in Castellanos’ stead. One notable right-hander in the lineup on Thursday was center fielder Harrison Bader, who has seemingly finally earned the tag of “everyday center fielder” with his outstanding performance of late.

As for Castellanos, on top of his well-known ongoing defensive deficiencies, he has been riding the struggle bus at the plate. He just completed a dreadful August that saw him hit .180 with a .509 OPS and a 26 percent strikeout rate. The 33-year-old did collect a pair of singles and scored a couple of times on Wednesday, but those were his first hits in his last six games. He has a 30.4 percent strikeout rate over that span.

This latest relegation is the third time in the Phillies’ last five games against right-handed starters that Castellanos has started on the bench.

Last week, the veteran seemed nonplussed about being pulled in the ninth inning for a defensive replacement. That was the first time it had happened since his mid-June benching for having words with Thomson after being pulled in the eighth inning of a game in Miami.

It made perfect sense though, since Bader has been one of the top defenders in the league based on advanced metrics, as noted by Casella, while Castellanos has … not. Now that Castellanos seems to be firmly in a platoon in right field, he can likely expect more late-game pulls when he does start.

Castellanos will have to get his bat going again to earn back that playing time. Although it might be too late with the Phillies eyeing the best possible lineups — both on offense and defense — with October right around the corner.

Related Posts

Red Sox Predicted To Sign Veteran Slugger Coming Off Monster Season

Eugenio Suárez could be a great addition to the Red Sox Aaliyan Mohammed 21 Hours Ago2 Min Read The Boston Red Sox lost Alex Bregman to the…

🚨EXCLUSIVE: Bo Bichette can’t wait to reunite with Marcus Semien, and the excitement is palpable! The former Blue Jays teammates are ready to rekindle their chemistry on the field, and fans are already buzzing about the dynamic duo. Will their reunion lead to a dominant season together? The anticipation is building..ll 👇👇👇

🚨 Bo Bichette Eager to Reunite with Marcus Semien in 2026 👇 As Bo Bichette prepares for the 2026 season with the New York Mets, one aspect…

REPORT: A former Braves general manager once pushed out in disgrace has quietly made a shocking return to professional baseball. His new position comes far from the spotlight, but it raises inevitable questions about accountability, second chances, and how the league really treats controversial figures. Fans are now wondering how — and why — this comeback was allowed to happen.

John Coppolella Reemerges in Baseball Eight Years After Lifetime Ban, Joins Baseball America as Contributor More than eight years after his dramatic fall from grace, former Atlanta…

🚨REPORT: Bo Bichette and Jonah Tong will not play in the World Baseball Classic, a decision that’s raising eyebrows across the baseball world! The Mets’ new third baseman and their No. 3 prospect will stay behind in Port St. Lucie for spring training, focusing on preparation for the upcoming season. This move could have long-term implications for both players’ development and the Mets’ roster..ll 👇👇👇

🚨 BREAKING: Bo Bichette and Jonah Tong Opt to Skip the World Baseball Classic, Focus on Mets Spring Training 👇 Bo Bichette, the New York Mets’ newly…

BREAKING NEWS: Jackson Holliday didn’t grow up chasing baseball — he grew up inside it. Life alongside his father Matt Holliday meant daily exposure to preparation, pressure, failure, and greatness long before the spotlight arrived. As his own career accelerates, fans are realizing those quiet lessons may be the biggest advantage of all — and the ceiling might be even higher than expected

Jackson Holliday Set for Historic MLB Debut as Baseball Legacy Comes Full Circle Nearly twenty years after he was toddling through Major League clubhouses alongside his father,…

🚨BOMBSHELL: The Dodgers could be without a key starting pitcher on Opening Day, and the implications are massive! This potential setback is sending shockwaves through the organization, with fans left wondering how it will impact their season opener. With the stakes so high, every move in the coming weeks will be under the microscope..ll 👇👇👇

🚨 DODGERS FACING OPENING DAY UNCERTAINTY: Blake Snell’s Health Could Affect Starting Rotation 👇 The Los Angeles Dodgers, fresh off a second consecutive World Series victory, are…