Rob Thomson finally admits harsh reality about Nick Castellanos’ place with Phillies

Philadelphia Phillies outfielder Nick Castellanos

Philadelphia Phillies fans and media love scrutinizing the daily lineups that manager Rob Thomson puts together for 162 games every season. One of the most recent obsessions has been with the corner outfield spots and specifically right field. More specifically, we’ve all become captivated by the building drama around Nick Castellanos’ current role on the team.

Ahead of Thursday’s series finale against the Milwaukee Brewers, Thomson put out a lineup that was missing Castellanos’ name for the second time in three games, per On Pattison’s Tim Kelly. Media in attendance, including MLB.com’s Paul Casella, questioned the Phillies skipper about the status of right field and whether it’s now a full-on platoon situation.

Rob Thomson, Phillies finally admit Nick Castellanos needs to be in right-field platoon

The simple answer is yes. Not that Thomson actually said the word “platoon.” He might as well have though, considering the answer he gave during his pre-game scrum.

“It looks that way,” Thomson said, per Casella. “I mean, you can call it whatever you want, but at this point in the year, I’m gonna put out what I think is the best lineup on any given day to win.”

Nick Castellanos isn’t starting for 2nd time in 3 games. Fair to say RF is a full-on platoon?

Rob Thomson: “It looks that way. I mean, you can call it whatever you want, but at this point in the year, I’m gonna put out what I think is the best lineup on any given day to win.”

https://twitter.com/Paul_CasellaMLB/status/1963679855779938474?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw

With Brewers ace Freddy Peralta, a right-hander, on the bump for the finale, Thomson loaded up his lineup with left-handed bats. That included Brandon Marsh in left field and Max Kepler patrolling right in Castellanos’ stead. One notable right-hander in the lineup on Thursday was center fielder Harrison Bader, who has seemingly finally earned the tag of “everyday center fielder” with his outstanding performance of late.

As for Castellanos, on top of his well-known ongoing defensive deficiencies, he has been riding the struggle bus at the plate. He just completed a dreadful August that saw him hit .180 with a .509 OPS and a 26 percent strikeout rate. The 33-year-old did collect a pair of singles and scored a couple of times on Wednesday, but those were his first hits in his last six games. He has a 30.4 percent strikeout rate over that span.

This latest relegation is the third time in the Phillies’ last five games against right-handed starters that Castellanos has started on the bench.

Last week, the veteran seemed nonplussed about being pulled in the ninth inning for a defensive replacement. That was the first time it had happened since his mid-June benching for having words with Thomson after being pulled in the eighth inning of a game in Miami.

It made perfect sense though, since Bader has been one of the top defenders in the league based on advanced metrics, as noted by Casella, while Castellanos has … not. Now that Castellanos seems to be firmly in a platoon in right field, he can likely expect more late-game pulls when he does start.

Castellanos will have to get his bat going again to earn back that playing time. Although it might be too late with the Phillies eyeing the best possible lineups — both on offense and defense — with October right around the corner.

Related Posts

🚨 INSIDE TRADE SWAP: The Red Sox quietly moved Luis Perales to the Nationals in exchange for Jake Bennett, but the timing and reasoning behind this one for one deal are raising eyebrows across league circles. What Boston believes it gained here may not be obvious yet, and that uncertainty is exactly why this trade is drawing more attention than expected.

The Boston Red Sox trade Luis Perales to the Washington Nationals for left-hander Jake Bennett in a pitching prospect swap.

🚨 INSIDE LAST-MINUTE TWIST: Just when the international signing window was about to close, the Yankees made a move almost no one saw coming by grabbing a teenage strikeout ace, and the reason this arm slipped until the final day is now sparking intense curiosity among scouts and rival front offices alike.

The New York Yankees got in just under the wire of the international signing deadline with an 18-year-old southpaw strikeout pitcher.

Kyle Tucker could benefit from breaking character and acting like a Scott Boras client

If Kyle Tucker wants to earn the best possible contract, he’ll forego being the good guy and take the aggressive approach.

BREAKING NEWS: Dodgers owe $1.06 billion US in deferred money through 2047 after Edwin Diaz deal

Edwin Diaz won’t receive all of his $69 million from the Dodgers until 2047, with the closer’s deal raising deferred payment obligations for the two-time World Series…

Breaking!! Braves received encouraging news regarding Bo Bichette’s chances after a recent report, sparking optimism among fans and analysts alike. The update could influence roster decisions and the team’s strategy heading into the next stretch of the season. With Bichette’s potential impact under consideration, discussions are heating up about how this could shape Atlanta’s pursuit of postseason success

The Atlanta Braves are having themselves a quality offseason thus far. Atlanta has made two meaningful free-agent signings in Robert Suarez and Mike Yastrzemski. They are also bringing back…

🚨 INSIDE FRONT OFFICE STRATEGY: The White Sox appear to be quietly cornering the market on minor moves, and while these decisions may look small on the surface, insiders believe they reveal a much larger plan taking shape behind the scenes. What Chicago is really building through these low key transactions could surprise fans who are only watching the headlines.

Trying to find players on cheap deals is one thing — but it’s no excuse to continue sidestepping major acquisitions