Exclusive: John Smoltz calls out ‘unfair’ Aaron Judge narrative amid Yankees domination

New York Yankees designated hitter Aaron Judge (99) watches the flight of the ball on his second solo home run of the game in the eighth inning against the Los Angeles Dodgers at Dodger Stadium.

Atlanta Braves great John Smoltz is well aware that the New York Yankees are still a major threat to win the World Series.

Despite entering the season with myriad injuries, especially to their pitching staff such as ace Gerrit Cole, the Yankees are leading the AL East two months into the season by a comfortable margin. Furthermore, they have the second-best record in the American League and are just a half-game behind the Los Angeles Dodgers, the team they matched up against in the World Series last season.

A large reason for that has been the continued excellence of Aaron Judge, who has 21 home runs and 50 RBI with .398/.490/.778 batting splits. Those splits are all career highs after winning the MVP for the second time last year. He leads the American League in all three categories while ranking second in home runs and RBI.

Although the MLB trade deadline isn’t until July 31, Smoltz believes the Yankees — as is usually the case — will be a player at the trade deadline when it comes to making a move for a pitcher to help make a World Series title push. That push will also need a locked-in Judge, who hasn’t been a playoff riser in his career. Even so, Smoltz doesn’t like the playoff narrative surrounding Judge.

“I think they’re always a player for that,” says Smoltz in a one-on-one interview when asked if the Yankees will make a move at the trade deadline. “They put their roster in a good place from balance now offensively, they got a little bit of athleticism they can work with. If Aaron Judge does anything what he’s doing right now, they’re going to be in the sweet spot. Then the narrative switches to what he hasn’t done in the postseason. That’s not a fair narrative, but that’s just the nature of sports. They will add a pitcher.”

Judge has faced a narrative of not coming up big in the playoffs after turning in massive regular seasons. The 33-year-old holds a career .205/.318/.450 batting split in the postseason, major dips compared to his regular season career batting splits of .294/.411/.614.

He’ll probably have to come up huge this postseason in order to dispel that narrative.

Will Yankees make a game-changing trade to bolster Aaron Judge-led roster?

New York Yankees general manager Brian Cashman walks on the field before game three of the 2024 MLB World Series between the New York Yankees and the Los Angeles Dodgers at Yankee Stadium.
Brad Penner-Imagn Images

Two of the Yankees’ starting rotation pitchers have been out this season, with Luis Gil making strides towards a potential return in late June.

While the Yankees have obviously been able to weather the storm of losing two of their top starting pitchers, they will need to beef up their rotation if they want a chance at winning their first World Series since 2009. Cole won’t be returning this season, which means New York is down an ace. However, Max Fried — the Yankees’ big free agent signing — has stepped up in a major way to fill the void, posting a 7-1 record with a 1.92 ERA.

New York actually ranks a respectable ninth in team ERA so far this season.

“It’s a matter of which team they can cherry pick, which team is going to be in that position,” says Smoltz. “There will be a major move in the second half that drastically changes the direction of a club with the expanded playoff rosters. You have some clubs not willing to do as much, they just rather get in. Then you got some game-changer clubs where they want to be put over the top — not only just making it — but giving them a deep chance to make it to the postseason finale, and that’s the World Series.”

Smoltz, who believes we could see a rematch in the World Series between the Yankees and Dodgers, is a big believer that this year’s playoffs will be “spectacular.”

“I really think this year’s postseason is going to be spectacular, mainly because of the imbalance of teams, and the balance of teams is going to allow for interesting trade talks and prospect prospect swaps,” says Smoltz.

Related Posts

🚨 BOMBSHELL METS MAKE SHOCK MOVE: The New York Mets have officially acquired a versatile six-year veteran from the Oakland Athletics, signaling urgency as internal turmoil continues to grow in New York. This isn’t just a routine deal — it’s a clear response to a team in crisis, searching for stability, depth, and a spark to stop the slide. But behind this move, bigger questions remain about the clubhouse and direction — and whether this addition is a fix… or just the beginning of something far bigger…ll 👇👇👇

NEW YORK — In a move that underscores both urgency and necessity, the New York Mets have claimed veteran utility infielder Andy Ibáñez off waivers from the…

🚨 OPINION METS IN DISARRAY: If Carlos Mendoza still has a job, it raises real questions about who’s actually in control of the New York Mets — and whether David Stearns is pulling the strings behind the scenes. Poor defense, inconsistent hitting, and lack of discipline point to leadership issues, not just talent problems. Right now, the message from ownership under Steve Cohen feels clear — and fans are starting to lose belief fast…ll 👇👇👇

NEW YORK — Frustration is boiling over in Queens, where the early-season struggles of the New York Mets have sparked a wave of criticism aimed squarely at…

🚨LIONS LAND A GAME-CHANGER: Kayvon Thibodeaux is reportedly heading to the Detroit Lions as their new starting edge after contract talks with the New York Giants broke down. This isn’t just a roster move… it’s a statement. Detroit adds an explosive pass rusher with elite upside, instantly boosting a defense that’s been searching for consistency off the edge. For the Lions, it’s about contention. For Thibodeaux, it’s a fresh start. And for the NFL… it’s a move that could shift the balance in the NFC.

BOSTON — Four days after the Boston Red Sox abruptly fired him as manager following one of the franchise’s rockiest starts in recent memory, Alex Cora sent a…

💥 BREAKING NEWS OHTANI SILENCES THE DOUBT: Just as questions began to swirl, Shohei Ohtani erupted with three hits, a towering home run, and a commanding performance that powered the Los Angeles Dodgers to a crushing 6–0 win over the Chicago Cubs. It wasn’t just dominance — it was a reminder of exactly why he stands in a league of his own, instantly shifting the narrative back in his favor. But beneath the brilliance, one question refuses to fade… is this the beginning of another unstoppable run, or only a preview of something even bigger still on the horizon…ll 👇👇👇

The Los Angeles Dodgers didn’t just win—they sent a message. And at the center of it all was Shohei Ohtani, who delivered a flawless offensive performance in a game that…

🚨 REPORT MIGUEL ROJAS RECONSIDERS FAREWELL: Miguel Rojas may not be done just yet, as a potential three-peat run by the Los Angeles Dodgers could convince the veteran to delay retirement and chase even more history. The possibility is already sparking buzz across fanbases, with many wondering if one more season could add another chapter to his legacy in Dodger blue. If the stars align, this emotional decision might turn into one of the most feel-good storylines of the season — but the final call still hangs in the balance…ll 👇👇👇

LOS ANGELES — The future of veteran infielder Miguel Rojas has suddenly become one of the most intriguing under-the-radar storylines surrounding the powerhouse Los Angeles Dodgers, as…

“From Under the Radar to Pure Genius: White Sox’s Silent Move Is Suddenly Looking Like an Absolute Steal — The Hidden Gem That Could Pay Off Big Time”

Keep an eye on Drew Romo, as his unexpected rise could significantly impact the White Sox’s season. The Chicago White Sox have been busy bees this off-season,…