REPORT: Braves’ walk-off win would not have happened without this critical ‘mistake’

Cincinnati Reds v Atlanta Braves

Atlanta Braves fans were treated to a thrilling end to Tuesday’s extra innings win over the Reds. Pitching put on an impressive show and kept the Reds scoreless through eight innings.

Cincinnati put up the game’s first run in the top of the eighth, and it appeared the Braves were headed for a disappointing loss.

However, a gutsy decision in the bottom of the ninth inning helped ensure that didn’t happen. Sean Murphy coaxed a walk to start the inning, and Stuart Fairchild was called on to pinch run against his former team.

A moment of hesitation and a deranged send allowed the Braves to salvage a win

This decision proved to be a difference maker for Atlanta. With one out, Michael Harris II laced a splitter into right field, and Fairchild was off to the races.

It looked like the Braves would have runners at second and third with a chance to tie. Third base coach Matt Tuiasosopo had other plans and surprised everyone, including the Reds, by sending Fairchild home.

His decision to send the runner caused a brief moment of hesitation from Cincinnati second baseman Matt McClain in getting the ball to home plate.

By the time he realized what was happening and made the throw, it was too late.

Outfielder Jake Fraley making the cut-off throw to second instead of to the first baseman for some reason helped the cause as well.

That, coupled with McClain’s hesitation, is all the Braves needed to get themselves back in the game.

Fairchild’s speed is a key reason he remains on Atlanta’s roster, and he used that speed to get revenge on a team that DFA’d him before eventually trading him to the Braves.

Braves insider Justin Toscano spoke with Tuiasosopo after the game, he mentioned having a gut feeling that influenced his decision to send the runner. Fairchild running hard also didn’t make the decision very hard.

He stated, “Once I saw the throw go toward second and they didn’t set up to come home at all, I saw the ball’s flight going toward second, I just said, ‘Let’s go.’

Just one of those gut feels where I just felt like we had a chance with where they were throwing the ball and how hard Stu was running, that he (could score).”

It was an extremely risky decision, but with the Braves’ troubles with runners in scoring position, it was worth it. Luckily, the Reds misplayed the situation and allowed Atlanta to tie things up. Marcell Ozuna then sent everyone home happy with a walk-off single in the 10th.

Related Posts

New York Yankees @ San Francisco Giants: Will Warren vs. Tyler Mahle

After two consecutive shutout victories to start the season, the Yankees are on pace to go 162-0 with zero runs allowed. Will that happen? Probably not, but…

🚨EXCLUSIVE: Nico Hoerner receives a bold prediction right after his $141 million extension—expectations skyrocket as Chicago places its faith in him to lead a new era. This is no longer potential, this is pressure, and all eyes are watching.

CUBS BET BIG ON NICO HOERNER AS BATTING TITLE BUZZ EMERGES FOLLOWING $141 MILLION EXTENSION The Chicago Cubs have made a significant long-term commitment to one of…

🚨BREAKING: Braves and Chris Sale make Opening Day history—an unforgettable performance that instantly sends a message to the entire league. This is more than a win, it’s a statement that Atlanta has arrived with something to prove.

Getty ATLANTA, GEORGIA – MARCH 27: Chris Sale #51 of the Atlanta Braves reacts after pitching against the Kansas City Royals in the fourth inning of the…

🚨EXCLUSIVE: Red Sox vs Reds today—don’t miss a single moment as Boston looks to stay hot and Cincinnati fights to respond at home. First pitch is set, the tension is rising, and this showdown could swing momentum early in the season.

RED SOX VS REDS SHOWDOWN SET FOR SATURDAY AS SONNY GRAY MAKES HIGHLY ANTICIPATED BOSTON DEBUT The 2026 MLB season is already gaining momentum, and the upcoming…

🚨EXCLUSIVE: Red Sox quietly pull off a win with the Brendan Rodgers deal—no noise, no hype, just a move that could change everything behind the scenes. Sometimes the biggest impact comes from the quietest decisions.

RED SOX QUIETLY SECURE HIGH-UPSIDE DEPTH WITH BRENDAN RODGERS DEAL DESPITE INJURY SETBACK In a move that may not dominate headlines but carries long-term strategic value, the…

🚨EXCLUSIVE: Camilo Doval looks absolutely dominant as he locks down the Yankees’ setup role—power, control, and confidence all coming together at the perfect time. This surge could quietly become the backbone of New York’s bullpen.

When the Yankees traded for Camilo Doval from the Giants last year, they expected the closer to transition into a setup role as part of a deep,…