Tyler O’Neill Injury History: Every ailment that made Orioles’ offseason signing risky

Tyler O’Neill is battling his arch-nemesis, the injury bug, once again.
Baltimore Orioles v Toronto Blue Jays
Baltimore Orioles v Toronto Blue Jays | Mark Blinch/GettyImages

Tyler O’Neill is headed to the injured list for the first time as a Baltimore Oriole, landing on the 10-day IL with neck inflammation. Per manager Brandon Hyde: “O’Neill has been dealing with that probably since last week. … We need to get him right, need to get him fully healthy.”

This marks the 15th time the former Gold Glove winner has landed on the injured list in his career. O’Neill has only played more than 100 games in his career twice, which is not an encouraging fact for the Orioles faithful.

Going back to his days in St. Louis, O’Neill could only play in more than 100 games once, missing large portions of seasons with the Cardinals. Following his promising season in 2021, which saw him receive MVP votes and his second career Gold Glove, he would miss chunks of games in 2022, which surged the already growing concern of his availability.

His first stint came in May with a shoulder impingement. O’Neill would attempt to play through the pain, but it got worse, and he would ultimately be forced to miss games. Only about a month down the road, the outfielder would suffer a strained hamstring that kept him out for about a month.

The hamstring would get reaggravated in September, effectively ending his season before the Cardinals would go on to the postseason in 2022. The injuries would only worsen in O’Neill’s final year in St. Louis.

Orioles’ outfielder Tyler O’Neill has an extensive injury history

In 2023, O’Neill missed most of the year with a back pain that left him unable to hold his daughter. O’Neill spent more time on the IL that year with a sprained foot in September. O’Neill would end his season with the injury and would subsequently finish his Cardinals career on the injured list. He was on the IL for over two months with injury concerns, prompting the Cardinals to trade the outfielder to Boston following the season.

During his only season with the Red Sox, O’Neill landed on the injured list three times, once for a concussion after colliding with teammate Rafael Devers in April of 2024. Concussions are scary, but luckily, the frequency of them in Major League Baseball is not as high as in other sports.

Just around a month after his return, he was headed to the IL once again due to knee inflammation, which contributed to a stretch of games that the outfielder would likely want to forget (0-15 with 10 strikeouts). His stay was once again short, but his inability to stay on the field for a prolonged period of time is disconcerting to the teams that were looking to sign him.

O’Neill would go one last time to the injured list in 2024 with a calf infection. This was once again a freak accident, as O’Neill said: “I just woke up, my leg was blown up and totally unexpected, no idea how it happened.” This infection had hospitalized him for a couple of days in Kansas City before he was allowed to return to Boston. He was then resubmitted due to the infection arriving again.

O’Neill’s injury history is not a good one, but when he is on the field he has shown that he can play at the highest level — the issue being his availability, not his ability.

Related Posts

🚨 BREAKING FENWAY PARK FLOODED WITH EMOTION — Boston Red Sox legends returned to the iconic diamond for a first pitch moment that left fans in tears, as generations of Fenway memories came rushing back under the lights of baseball’s most historic stadium 👇👇👇

Fenway Park has never been unfamiliar with historic moments. But tonight, it witnessed more than just baseball. It witnessed memories come alive. Not a walk-off that shook…

🚨 BREAKING PANIC IN THE BRONX — Rumors are exploding across baseball that the New York Yankees could be preparing to move on from Aaron Boone, as whispers of a shocking new era begin shaking the entire franchise 👇👇👇

Winds of change are blowing through the Bronx. As the 2026 MLB season enters its crucial stage, a wave of rumors is spreading around the New York…

🚨 BREAKING CUBS ENTER THE “NEXT MAN UP” ERA — While injuries rip through the roster and pressure explodes across Chicago, Javier Assad is suddenly becoming the unexpected heartbeat of a team chasing a historic winning streak that nobody saw coming 👇👇👇

In a season where initial predictions pointed to instability, the Chicago Cubs are writing one of their most incredible chapters in years. A sustained winning streak, a…

Garrett Crochet’s Shoulder Injury Return: Exactly Where the Red Sox Ace Stands Right Now – Make-or-Break Update for Boston’s Playoff Push!

Boston Red Sox pitcher Garrett Crochet (35) throws a pitch in the second inning of the MLB Opening Day game between the Cincinnati Reds and the Boston…

2 SF Giants who obviously need to be shown the door after Patrick Bailey trade

арr 22, 2026; ѕаn Frаncіѕco, Cаlіfornіа, Uѕа; ѕаn Frаncіѕco Gіаntѕ ріtcher Ryаn Wаlker (74) celebrаteѕ wіth ѕаn Frаncіѕco Gіаntѕ cаtcher раtrіck Bаіley (14) аfter defeаtіng the Loѕ…

Cardinals Prospect Liam Doyle Is Turning Into a Monster

Getty аTLаNTа, GeORGіа – JULY 13: Mаjor Leаgue Bаѕebаll commіѕѕіoner Robert D. Mаnfred Jr. аnnounceѕ Lіаm Doyle аѕ the fіfth overаll ріck, by the ѕt. Louіѕ Cаrdіnаlѕ,…