MLB nailing Juan Soto video review is scathing indictment of baffling Aaron Judge call

On Monday night in Flushing, Queens, $765 million (plus escalators) Mets superstar Juan Soto broke out of his slump in a massive way, stomping all over an inside pitch and sending the Phillies to an early grave with a three-run moonshot down the right field line and onto the Pepsi Porch. The Mets’ $765 million light show (we assume) went wild. The fans celebrated. Soto admired and gesticulated. Only one problem: the ball wasn’t gone.

Even after Soto rounded the bases, slapped hands, and the crowd went wild, their arms full of $22 Shake Shack burgers and $38 whiskey lemonades (all proceeds go to the Soto Fund), the umpires had to get together and reckon with the difficult reality that the ball passed to the right of the orange pole. It was so close. It was also clearly foul.

It must’ve been tough to tell both Soto and the raucous, rowdy crowd that three runs were about to be taken off the board, but somehow they managed. After all, it’s better to be plainly correct than to do fan service.

Anyway, just mentioning this for no reason. But … while we’re here … why couldn’t the umpires in Tampa, FL in front of 12,000 casual observers — many of them fans of the road team — treat a clear and obvious Aaron Judge home run with the same amount of care and reverence as a Soto foul fly?

— Just Baseball (@JustBB_Media) April 22, 2025

Umpires did a great job taking a home run away from Juan Soto on review. Why did they fail at giving Yankees’ Aaron Judge the home run he deserved?

It’s petty to count the numbers of Judge home runs that the universe owes the Yankees slugger due to poor umpiring but oh, what the hell, it’s two; the answer is two homers. One in 2017 where the umpires couldn’t discern where the wall ended, and one this past weekend, in the bright sun against the trees, where it was exceedingly easy to spot a small white pill cascading 15 feet fair.

The umpiring crew and the replay review booth got the tougher call completely correct on Monday night at Citi Field, and Soto lost a signature moment — but, hey, at least the correction was made. It would be tough to justify tainting history with an incorrect call. That was the justification for messin’ with Max Fried’s no-hitter, after all.

But Judge is someone who might be chasing home run records in any given season. You never know when he’ll be threatening 60, or cracking 500, or pushing the limits even further. Losing even one means that history has been handed an asterisk. And it’s fair to wish Sunday’s mammoth blast was treated with the care and accuracy of Soto’s dissolving moment.

Related Posts

🏆 IMMORTALIZED FOREVER: THE BRAVES JUST GAVE BRIAN SNITKER THE ULTIMATE HONOR AT TRUIST PARK ❤️⚾ In a moment filled with emotion, legacy, and deep respect, the Atlanta Braves officially unveiled a statue honoring manager Brian Snitker outside Truist Park — cementing his place forever in franchise history. 👏🔥 For Braves fans, this wasn’t just about celebrating a manager. It was about honoring loyalty. Patience. Leadership. And a man who dedicated decades of his life to the organization long before championship parades and national headlines arrived. 💥 Snitker climbed through every level of the Braves system, enduring rebuilding years, criticism, uncertainty, and pressure — yet never stopped believing in the culture he helped build. That unwavering commitment eventually led Atlanta back to baseball’s mountaintop with a World Series title and one of the most respected clubhouses in MLB. 🏆⚾ Now his legacy stands permanently outside Truist Park as a reminder that greatness isn’t always built overnight. Sometimes it’s built quietly through years of sacrifice, trust, and relentless belief in an organization’s future. Fans at the ceremony reportedly became emotional seeing the statue revealed, with many calling Snitker one of the most important figures the Braves franchise has ever had. And honestly, it’s hard to argue against that. ❤️ Because championships may define eras… …but loyalty is what makes legends immortal. 🔥 #Braves #BrianSnitker #AtlantaBraves #MLB #TruistPark

Braves Immortalize Brian Snitker With Emotional Statue Unveiling at Truist Park In the long and emotional history of the Atlanta Braves, countless legends have shaped the franchise…

🚨 THE BRAVES MAY SOON FACE SOME TOUGH DECISIONS — AND A FEW PLAYERS ARE RUNNING OUT OF TIME 👀⚾ For years, the Atlanta Braves have built one of baseball’s strongest cultures around consistency, accountability, and winning expectations. But as the season continues, it’s becoming harder to ignore that several players may already be slipping dangerously close to losing their current roles within the organization. 😳🔥 In Atlanta, talent alone has never guaranteed security. The Braves expect production. Execution. Composure in big moments. And right now, a handful of players are struggling to provide the stability this roster desperately needs during a season filled with pressure and postseason expectations. 💥 Whether it’s inconsistency at the plate, defensive mistakes, bullpen struggles, or missed opportunities in critical situations, fans are starting to notice patterns that can no longer be brushed aside. And with Atlanta built to compete for championships NOW, patience may not last forever. ⚠️ What makes this situation even more intense is the depth waiting behind them. Young talent is pushing. Coaches are evaluating everything. Front office pressure is growing. And in a clubhouse chasing October success, roles can disappear much faster than people expect. 👀 That’s why Braves Nation is suddenly asking a difficult question: Who will respond to the pressure… and who may already be playing themselves out of Atlanta’s future plans? 🔥⚾ #Braves #AtlantaBraves #MLB #BravesCountry #Baseball

Four Braves Players Quietly Playing Their Way Out of Atlanta’s Plans Despite MLB-Best Start The Atlanta Braves may currently own the best record in Major League Baseball,…

🚨 THE TWINS CANNOT AFFORD TO LET RYAN JEFFERS BECOME “JUST ANOTHER GOOD PLAYER” WHO LEAVES MINNESOTA ⚾🔥 In a baseball era obsessed with superstar headlines and blockbuster contracts, Ryan Jeffers has quietly become something every contender desperately needs — reliable, tough, intelligent, and deeply connected to the identity of the Minnesota Twins. 👀💙 He may not always dominate national conversations, but inside the clubhouse and throughout Twins Nation, Jeffers has steadily evolved into one of the most important pieces of this roster. His power at the plate, game-calling behind it, leadership with pitchers, and ability to deliver in big moments make him far more valuable than casual fans often realize. 💥 And that’s exactly why many believe Minnesota needs to think beyond short-term roster management and commit to keeping Jeffers for the long haul. Because championship-caliber teams are rarely built only around flashy stars. They’re built around players who stabilize pressure moments, understand the organization, and give teams consistency through the emotional grind of a 162-game season. ⚾ The Twins have spent years trying to build sustainable success instead of temporary momentum. Letting a player like Jeffers walk away could create the exact type of leadership void teams don’t notice until it’s too late. 🔥 Now the conversation around Minnesota is growing louder: Is Ryan Jeffers simply part of the current roster… or should he become part of the long-term foundation of Twins baseball? 👀 #Twins #MinnesotaTwins #MLB #RyanJeffers #TwinsNation

Twins Facing Massive Ryan Jeffers Decision as Yankees Rumors Intensify Around Breakout MLB Catcher The Minnesota Twins may soon face one of the most difficult decisions in…

🚨 THE YANKEES ARE NOW BEING LINKED TO A MAJOR TWINS TRADE TARGET — AND THE ENTIRE LEAGUE IS STARTING TO CIRCLE 👀⚾ As the MLB trade deadline slowly approaches, one thing is becoming very clear around baseball: the New York Yankees are preparing to hunt aggressively — and insiders now believe a key Minnesota Twins player could be firmly on their radar. 😳🔥 The moment the rumor surfaced, rival fanbases immediately reacted. Because whenever the Yankees enter the conversation for a high-impact deadline piece, the pressure across the American League instantly changes. Other contenders begin watching closer. Front offices start moving faster. And suddenly, what looked like a quiet market becomes an all-out bidding war. 💥 What makes this situation even more fascinating is the growing belief that multiple teams are already monitoring the same target, creating the feeling that “the vultures are circling” around Minnesota ahead of a potentially massive deadline decision. For the Yankees, the motivation is obvious. This roster still carries championship expectations. Aaron Judge’s window matters. The pressure in the Bronx never disappears. And if New York believes one more impact bat or arm could tilt the postseason race, history says they won’t hesitate to make a move. ⚾👀 Now fans everywhere are asking the same thing: Are the Yankees simply monitoring the situation… or quietly preparing for another classic Bronx blockbuster? 🔥 #Yankees #MLB #NewYorkYankees #Twins #MLBTradeDeadline

Yankees Emerging as Serious Threat to Steal Twins Fan Favorite Ryan Jeffers Before MLB Trade Deadline The New York Yankees may already be preparing for another aggressive…

🚨 THE ORIOLES KNOW ONE THING RIGHT NOW: THEY CANNOT AFFORD TO GET JACKSON HOLLIDAY’S DEVELOPMENT WRONG ⚠️🧡🖤 Jackson Holliday isn’t just another top prospect anymore. He represents the future heartbeat of the Baltimore Orioles franchise — and that’s exactly why every decision surrounding his development is now being watched so closely across baseball. 👀⚾ The pressure is enormous. Fans see the talent. The swing. The baseball IQ. The confidence beyond his age. But developing a young superstar in today’s MLB isn’t only about potential anymore — it’s about timing, patience, leadership, and protecting a player from being overwhelmed before he fully settles into the major league spotlight. 💥 That’s why many around baseball believe the Orioles are entering one of the most important balancing acts of their entire rebuild. Push Holliday too quickly, and confidence could take a hit under intense expectations. Hold him back too long, and frustration begins building among fans eager to see the franchise fully unleash its next generation. 🔥 And make no mistake: Baltimore’s future championship hopes are deeply connected to getting this process right. Because if Jackson Holliday becomes the superstar many scouts believe he can be, the Orioles won’t just have another great young player… They could have the face of baseball in Baltimore for the next decade. ⭐⚾ #Orioles #JacksonHolliday #MLB #BaltimoreOrioles #Birdland

Orioles Risky Jackson Holliday Experiment Raises Serious Questions About Baltimore’s Long-Term Plan The Baltimore Orioles may have found themselves facing a difficult roster dilemma, but their latest…

🚨 OUTRAGE ERUPTS IN BALTIMORE AFTER CITY HALL ACCUSED OF SPENDING $50,000 ON FOOD AT ORIOLES GAMES 😳🦀 A political firestorm is exploding across Baltimore tonight after reports surfaced accusing City Hall officials of spending nearly $50,000 on crab cakes, chicken wings, and stadium hospitality connected to Orioles games — and taxpayers are demanding answers fast. 👀🔥 What began as a routine spending discussion has suddenly turned into one of the city’s most controversial public debates, with frustrated residents questioning priorities at a time when many communities continue facing economic pressure, rising costs, and public service concerns. And the details are what truly caught people off guard. Crab cakes. Chicken wings. Game-day hospitality expenses. Thousands upon thousands reportedly tied to events surrounding Orioles games at Camden Yards. ⚾💥 Now social media is exploding with reactions from every direction. Some argue relationship-building and city representation at major sporting events are normal parts of business and politics. Others believe the reported spending reflects a disconnect between public officials and everyday residents struggling financially. Meanwhile, Orioles fans are finding themselves unexpectedly pulled into the middle of a controversy that has rapidly become much bigger than baseball itself. 😳 One thing is certain: What was supposed to be a conversation about entertainment spending has now become a citywide debate about accountability, leadership, and public trust. 🔥 #Orioles #Baltimore #MLB #CamdenYards #BaltimoreOrioles

Baltimore Spending Scandal Erupts as Mayor Brandon Scott and Inspector General Clash Over Alleged Misuse of Taxpayer Funds A growing political firestorm has exploded inside Baltimore City…