Spring training is always a time for hope, competition, and tough decisions. For the Atlanta Braves, the latter will be front and center as they finalize their 2025 Opening Day roster. Several players find themselves out of minor league options, meaning they cannot be sent down without passing through waivers. That wrinkle makes their roster battles even more intense-and their futures in Atlanta uncertain. With a team built for championship contention, the Braves’ front office must decide whether to keep these players, trade them, or risk losing them for nothing. Let’s break down what it means for the Braves and how each of these out-of-options players fits into the team’s plans.
Ian Anderson: Make-or-Break Season for Former Postseason Hero Remember when Ian Anderson was one of the Braves’ most reliable postseason arms? It wasn’t long ago-his 2021 playoff run cemented him as a big-game pitcher. But injuries and inconsistency have plagued the right-hander since then, and now he finds himself in a precarious spot. Anderson is out of minor league options, meaning he either makes the rotation or the Braves could be forced to explore a trade. The good news? Early reports from camp suggest his velocity is ticking back up, and his command looks sharper than it has in years. If he can reclaim his past form, he could provide critical depth behind Spencer Strider and Max Fried. But with Bryce Elder, AJ Smith-Shawver, and Hurston Waldrep also vying for rotation spots, Anderson’s role isn’t guaranteed. Atlanta could try to stash him in the bullpen, but his value remains highest as a starter. If he falters, the Braves might have to make a tough call.
Nick Allen: A Glove-First Infielder in a Crowded Mix The Braves added Nick Allen from Oakland for infield depth, but with Orlando Arcia entrenched at shortstop and Ozzie Albies at second, Allen’s path to playing time isn’t clear. His elite defense makes him a valuable bench option, but his bat has never been a strong suit.
The bigger question: Is there enough room on the roster? Atlanta already has Vaughn Grissom and Luke Williams (another out-of-options player) who provide defensive flexibility. If the Braves prioritize offense off the bench, Allen could be the odd man out. Grant Holmes & Angel Perdomo: Bullpen Wild Cards The Braves bullpen has been a strength in recent years, and both Holmes and Perdomo are fighting to keep it that way. Holmes, a former top prospect, has yet to carve out a consistent MLB role, but he flashed swing-and-miss potential in Triple-A. Perdomo, meanwhile, brings a power left-handed arm but is coming off an injury-shortened season. With A.J. Minter and Tyler Matzek already in place, Perdomo must prove he belongs-especially with no minor league safety net.
One of these arms could stick if the Braves need extra bullpen depth, but Atlanta has been aggressive in acquiring veteran relievers. Holmes and Perdomo will have to earn their spots or risk hitting the waiver wire. Chadwick Tromp: Catcher Depth Dilemma The Braves love depth behind the plate, but with Sean Murphy and Travis d’Arnaud leading the charge, Tromp faces an uphill battle. Atlanta values his defense and familiarity with the pitching staff, but keeping three catchers on the roster is a luxury they may not afford.
The Braves could look to trade Tromp to a catching-needy team, especially since he’s out of options. If not, he’s a prime candidate to be waived and claimed elsewhere. Eli White & Luke Williams: Utility Specialists Fighting for a Spot Both White and Williams provide defensive versatility, but will the Braves carry both? White’s speed and outfield defense are assets, but with Ronald Acuña Jr., Michael Harris II, and Jarred Kelenic locked into everyday roles, his path to playing time is murky. Williams, meanwhile, has played nearly every position in the infield and outfield, making him a more flexible piece. If the Braves opt for a true Swiss Army knife off the bench, Williams could have the edge. White, on the other hand, might be the odd man out unless Atlanta sees him as a must-have defensive replacement.
What’s Next for the Braves? The Braves are in win-now mode, and every roster spot counts. With these out-of-options players, the front office has three choices: keep them, trade them, or expose them to waivers. Anderson and Perdomo have the highest upside and are most likely to stay. Allen and Williams are competing for one utility spot. Tromp and White are on the bubble. Spring training will be their proving ground. For some, it’s their last chance to stick with the Braves. For others, it’s an opportunity to showcase their value to another team. Atlanta’s depth is a luxury, but with that comes difficult decisions. The next few weeks will determine which of these players will don a Braves uniform on Opening Day-and which ones will be searching for a new home.
