Orioles GM Mike Elias sure does love his prospects
It’s no secret that the Baltimore Orioles remain in the market for a front-line starter to solidify their rotation.
Even with the additions of veteran pitchers Charlie Morton and Tomoyuki Sugano there is still ongoing speculation and persistent trade chatter about whether the team will make a blockbuster move.
One of the biggest names linked to Baltimore? Dylan Cease, a powerful right-hander currently fronting the San Diego Padres’ staff.
Discussions between the Orioles and Padres were rumored to have been in motion for some time, but according to FanGraph’s prospect analyst Eric Longenhagen, negotiations may have hit a major snag the moment Chayce McDermott’s name surfaced in trade talks.
“McDermott is one of those guys where, when you talk about the Cease trade rumors, it sounds like that’s the bridge too far for Baltimore,” Longenhagen noted. “So they must think pretty highly of him if that’s actually true.”
That speaks volumes about Baltimore’s commitment to its young arms. McDermott, a 26-year-old right-hander with a deep pitch mix and an impressive 13.0 K/9 over four minor league seasons, is more than just a promising prospect—he’s a key piece of the Orioles’ future.
While his high walk rate (5.3%) raises concerns about command, Baltimore’s brass clearly sees his upside outweighing his inconsistencies.
Chayce McDermott has his first strikeout in the big leagues!
The @Orioles’ No. 7 prospect racked up 12.8 K/9 this season at Triple-A. pic.twitter.com/aXREhQkVIS
— MLB Pipeline (@MLBPipeline) July 24, 2024
Orioles stay committed to long-term stability over short-term splash
The Orioles’ stance on McDermott is further solidified when looking at the bigger picture.
Their current rotation features more aging pitchers than most, with Grayson Rodriguez (25) and Dean Kremer (29) being the only two starters under 30.
Acquiring Cease would undoubtedly be an upgrade to the staff, but at what cost?
The move could potentially gut their farm system and disrupt the club’s long-term pitching development—an unnecessary gamble for a team whose offensive core is already built to outlast its veteran starters.
With newly acquired arms like 41-year-old Charlie Morton and 35-year-old Tomoyuki Sugano on one-year deals, Baltimore has bolstered its rotation without mortgaging its future.
These veteran additions provide short-term stability, ensuring the Orioles remain competitive without feeling pressured into a reactionary move.
Meanwhile, the organization is developing Roansy Contreras back into a starter and grooming Chayce McDermott for a larger role.
If McDermott can fine-tune his mechanics and refine his command, he presents a legitimate long-term solution, whether as a mid-season injury replacement in 2025 or a full-time rotation fixture by 2026.
The Orioles’ approach is deliberate: they’re investing in sustainability rather than making rash decisions.
While the Padres may be eager to shape the trade market, Baltimore’s message is clear: they are playing the long game, and they won’t let the Padres dictate their future.
