NFL insiders sound off on Mike McCarthy’s coaching future with Dallas Cowboys

NFL insiders sound off on Mike McCarthy's coaching future with Dallas Cowboys
Credit: Sam Navarro-USA TODAY Sports

Dallas Cowboys head coach Mike McCarthy is on the hottest of hot seats entering Week 9 as the team has been struggling mightily this season.

With McCarthy calling plays, the 3-4 Cowboys rank 15th in total yards (330.1 per game), 11th in passing yards (1,792), last in rushing yards (519), and 22nd in points per game (21.4). Quarterback Dak Prescott has played inconsistently this season, throwing 10 touchdowns and eight interceptions with a quarterback rating of 84.5. He has already been sacked 18 times.

The situation is even worse on defense after defensive coordinator Dan Quinn left to become the head coach of the 6-2 Washington Commanders. Under Mike Zimmer, the Cowboys have fielded one of the NFL’s worst defenses. They’re allowing 28.3 points per game, ranking 31st in the league. Only the Carolina Panthers (33.9 points per game) have performed worse defensively.

The Cowboys have also dealt with numerous injuries to their top players, including defensive stalwarts Micah Parsons, DeMarcus Lawrence, and DaRon Bland. This week, the team learned that All-Pro cornerback Trevon Diggs has a calf tear and will be a game-time decision against the Atlanta Falcons on Sunday.

In five seasons with McCarthy as head coach, the Cowboys have made the playoffs three times but have failed to advance past the divisional round. If the Cowboys cannot turn their season around, NFL insiders believe a legendary coach will take the helm next season.

Related: Dallas Cowboys game today: 2024 Cowboys schedule, latest depth chart, stats and injury report

Bill Belichick looms over Dallas Cowboys’ Mike McCarthy

NFL insiders sound off on Mike McCarthy's coaching future with Dallas Cowboys
Credit: Eric Canha-USA TODAY Sports

The Athletic NFL insiders Zak Keefer and Jeff Howe report former the shadow of former New England Patriots head coach Bill Belichick is hovering over McCarthy and the Cowboys.

“As with anything involving the Cowboys, every situation is always the most extreme there, and the attention on Mike McCarthy’s job with Bill Belichick potentially waiting in the shadows is an unmatched situation this season,” Howe wrote.

Keefer added that McCarthy’s “future in Dallas at this point is a fait accompli.”

“The Cowboys have been far too uneven, and the roster isn’t nearly as deep as it was in the past, for this team to become a serious contender later in the season. Missing the playoffs would seal the end of McCarthy’s five-year run, and possibly open the door for Belichick to join the circus,” Keefer noted.

Cowboys owner Jerry Jones has previously said he won’t be changing head coaches in-season, so McCarthy’s job appears safe through the end of the year. However, with Jones, things can change in an instant. It’s essentially Super Bowl-or-bust every season in Dallas, despite the Cowboys not winning a championship in 29 years.

The Cowboys will look to get back on track against the Falcons on Sunday. Dallas is 3.5-point road underdogs.

Related: Retired 4-time Pro Bowler suggests Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones purposely sabotaging 2024 team

Related Posts

SAN FRANCISCO HIT BY A NUCLEAR BLAST: Maxx Crosby Ignites Wild 49ers Chaos with His Mind-Blowing Latest Social Media Tease!

It’s pretty clear the edge rusher wants to leave Las Vegas. One of the San Francisco 49ers’ best-case scenarios this offseason would be somehow figuring out how…

BILLS LAND THEIR MISSLE! One electric playmaker with BLISTERING speed is Buffalo-bound. This move FIXES the deep threat—but DESTROYS the salary cap!

The Buffalo Bills have been starving for a true game-changing wide receiver to pair with superstar quarterback Josh Allen, and this offseason, general manager Brandon Beane might…

🚨 REPORT LATEST DOLPHINS RUMORS JUST SWUNG OPEN A DOOR THE SAINTS CANNOT AFFORD TO IGNORE, a sudden shift in Miami’s plans that creates a golden opportunity New Orleans may be forced to pounce on before the rest of the league catches up. 👇👇

Dec 15, 2025; ріttѕburgh, рennѕylvаnіа, Uѕа; Mіаmі Dolрhіnѕ runnіng bаck De’Von аchаne (28) runѕ wіth the bаll whіle defended by ріttѕburgh ѕteelerѕ cornerbаck Brаndіn echolѕ (26) іn…

🚨 REPORT AN NFL INSIDER JUST DROPPED A BOMBSHELL THAT COULD COMPLETELY SHIFT THE DOLPHINS’ QUARTERBACK SEARCH, a revelation stirring urgency inside Miami’s front office and sending fans into instant speculation mode as the offseason suddenly takes a sharp turn. 👇👇

North Dakota State QB Cole Payton | Vasha Hunt-Imagn Images The Miami Dolphins are hunting up a new quarterback this offseason, as Tua Tagovailoa’s departure is all but…

🚨 BREAKING: A Bаltіmore cheer ѕquаd member fіleѕ а ѕhockіng lаwѕuіt аgаіnѕt а ѕtаr рlаyer, аllegіng lаte-nіght cаllѕ аnd flіrty meѕѕаgeѕ thаt croѕѕed the lіne — ѕendіng the entіre frаnchіѕe іnto dаmаge-control mode аѕ the ѕtory exрlodeѕ аcroѕѕ ѕocіаl medіа. 👇👇

The Bаltіmore Rаvenѕ аre cаught іn the mіddle of а ѕcаndаl thаt’ѕ ѕendіng ѕhockwаveѕ through the NFL communіty аnd іgnіtіng іntenѕe debаte аmong fаnѕ. Grаce Krаmer, а well-known member…

🚨 REPORT MAC JONES TRADE PROPOSAL STUNS FANS AND SENDS 49ERS NATION INTO A FRENZY, а curvebаll іdeа thаt’ѕ іgnіted nonѕtoр debаte аbout uрѕіde, fіt, аnd whether Sаn Frаncіѕco would dаre ѕhаke uр іtѕ quаrterbаck room thіѕ boldly. 👇👇

іMаGe: іmаgn іmаgeѕ аѕ the NFL offѕeаѕon buzzeѕ wіth ѕрeculаtіon, one of the hot toріcѕ іѕ whether the ѕаn Frаncіѕco 49erѕ wіll trаde quаrterbаck Mаc Joneѕ. Whіle…