Hal Steinbrenner’s penny pinching is set to cost the Yankees yet another ideal target

Losing Juan Soto to the rival New York Mets still stings, but the New York Yankees rebounded in an encouraging way on Tuesday, acquiring former Atlanta Braves ace Max Fried on a massive eight-year deal. Fried gives New York some much-needed firepower in its starting rotation, a true running mate as Gerrit Cole ages into his mid-30s. Even beyond the on-field impact, though, it was encouraging to see the Yankees move like the Yankees again, pouncing on the best available free agent so resoundingly that they gave him no choice but to say yes. Maybe whiffing on Soto was the wake-up call that Hal Steinbrenner and Brian Cashman needed.

Or maybe not. Even with Fried now on board, there’s still a ton of work to be done to put New York in position to contend for a World Series in 2025. The bullpen needs to be rebuilt. There are holes at first base and second base. And, perhaps most glaringly of all, they need an outfielder to replace Soto, preferably someone who can play center to allow Aaron Judge to shift over to right. All of those tasks are doable, especially with the Yankees’ resources, provided that the team’s willing to use them.

Unfortunately, the latest report from the Winter Meetings suggests that Steinbrenner and Cashman are still busy playing the same old games.

For more news and rumors, check out MLB Insider Robert Murray’s work onThe Baseball Insiders podcast, subscribe to The Moonshot, our weekly MLB newsletter, and join the discord to get the inside scoop between now and the MLB offseason.

Cody Bellinger has been on New York’s radar since even before Soto made his decision. He can play center field and first base, two positions of need, and his left-handed swing seems tailor-made for the short porch at Yankee Stadium. And given the dearth of free agent options available, there simply aren’t a ton of alternatives, let alone ones that bring Bellinger’s above-average bat.

And luckily for the Yankees, the Chicago Cubs seem dead-set on dealing him, looking to free up payroll and playing time amid a glut of outfield options. All New York has to do is take the money off of Jed Hoyer’s hands — but apparently that’s too much to ask. According to Jon Heyman of the New York Post, the $52.5 million Bellinger is due over the next two years has become a major sticking point.

Cody Bellinger would be a great fit for Yankees since he’s very good at 1B and very solid in CF, too. But for now there’s a gap on the $. Cubs don’t want to eat any of it, Yankees think they should. Bellinger is guaranteed $52.5M over 2 years with an opt-out after 2025.

— Jon Heyman (@JonHeyman) December 11, 2024

In a vacuum, sure, $52.5 million for Bellinger’s age-29 and -30 seasons is a bit much. But it’s not egregiously so, and more importantly, these things don’t happen in a vacuum. The Yankees need upgrades to contend, and Bellinger is the best one available. That’s not an excuse to “spend like drunken sailors,” as Cashman put it, but the team can add Bellinger’s salary to the Fried deal and still not touch the number it was prepared to pay Soto next season.

The money is there, in other words, but New York is balking at the idea of spending it. Maybe Cashman is correctly reading that the Cubs don’t have much leverage here, desperate to trade a player with limited suitors. Maybe the Yankees will win the staring contest and wind up winning themselves some extra flexibility. But the longer this goes, the more the team runs the risk of making the same mistake all over again, dying on principle rather than simply swallowing its pride to get better.

Related Posts

🚨 BOMBSHELL: Luke Weaver just pulled up to Mets camp with a Yankees bag, and fans are losing their minds! Is this a sign of things to come, or just a bizarre move? The drama surrounding this is only beginning…ll 👇👇👇

🚨 MLB DRAMA: Luke Weaver Arrives at Mets Camp with Yankees Bag – What Does This Mean for His Future? 👇 In an unexpected turn of events,…

🚨BREAKING: Sources say White Sox near deal with RHP Erick Fedde! Chicago is reportedly closing in on adding a veteran arm to their rotation, and if this goes through, it could be the boost the Sox pitching staff has been craving. With a potential agreement on the horizon, fans are buzzing — but is this the start of a bigger overhaul? 👇👇👇

Sources: Chicago White Sox Near Deal with RHP Erick Fedde to Strengthen Rotation The Chicago White Sox are reportedly closing in on a one-year contract with right-handed…

🚨BREAKING: Pirates sign Marcell Ozuna to a one‑year deal! Pittsburgh just added a proven power bat to their lineup, and this unexpected move instantly changes the narrative for the 2026 season. Will Ozuna’s veteran presence fuel a surprising playoff push — or is there a twist that could flip this story yet again? 👇👇👇

Pirates Sign Marcell Ozuna to One-Year Deal: What It Means for Pittsburgh’s 2026 Season In a move that signals the Pittsburgh Pirates are still looking to bolster…

🚨BREAKING: Boston Red Sox land Milwaukee Brewers’ Caleb Durbin in a 6‑player trade! The blockbuster swap shakes up both rosters as Boston adds a dynamic infielder to its lineup. With six players involved, this isn’t just a minor tweak — it could redefine the Red Sox’s direction heading into 2026. What does Durbin bring to Boston, and who did the Sox give up to get him? 👇👇👇

Boston Red Sox Land Milwaukee Brewers’ Caleb Durbin in Six-Player Trade: What This Means for 2026 In a move that shakes up their roster ahead of the…

🚨BREAKING: How ESPN graded the Red Sox’s ‘interesting’ Caleb Durbin trade — and the verdict might surprise you! Analysts didn’t call it a slam dunk, but the way ESPN evaluated the deal is stirring major debate: some see it as Boston getting savvy value, while others think the Sox gave up too much potential for immediate depth. The real takeaway isn’t just the grade — it’s why they gave it. 👇👇👇

How ESPN Graded Red Sox’s ‘Interesting’ Caleb Durbin Trade The Boston Red Sox made an interesting move on Monday, acquiring Caleb Durbin from the Milwaukee Brewers in…

🚨BREAKING: Yankees trade for 28‑year‑old infielder who grew up in the same city as Derek Jeter! New York just pulled off a hometown‑flavored move that’s getting fans buzzing — a player with deep local roots now headed to the Bronx. Could this unexpected twist be more than just nostalgia, and does it signal a bigger plan for the Yankees’ lineup? 👇👇👇

Yankees Acquire 28-Year-Old Infielder Max Schuemann, a Kalamazoo Native Like Derek Jeter In a move that might intrigue both New York Yankees fans and baseball enthusiasts alike,…