BREAKING: Is Aaron Boone’s ‘Grady Little Moment’ in the World Series the Final Straw for the Yankees?

Aaron Boone

Did New York Yankees manager Aaron Boone just have his “Grady Little moment”?

Two outs from winning Game 1 of the World Series 3-2 on Friday night, Boone turned to left-handed pitcher Nestor Cortes, who hadn‘t pitched in 37 days, to save the game by facing the top of the Los Angeles Dodgers’ order.

It failed miserably — and could raise uncomfortable questions about Boone’s job security if the Yankees do not win the World Series.

Although Cortes got Shohei Ohtani to fly out in foul territory for the second out, the Yankees walked Mookie Betts to load the bases to pitch to Freddie Freeman, who proceeded to launch a walk-off grand slam. Dodgers 6, Yankees 3 in 10 innings.

On Thursday‘s ESPN “Baseball Tonight” podcast, MLB insider Buster Olney was asked which manager, Boone or the Dodgers’ Dave Roberts, was more “vulnerable” in terms of his job security. While Olney thought both were safe and would get extensions in the offseason, he left one caveat — the type that played out Friday.

“I think they are equally vulnerable,” Olney said. “It sounds like a cop-out but I think they are in a really great position now that they‘ve reached the World Series. … The Yankees getting back to World Series for the first time since 2009.

“(But) I do think that if there‘s a Grady Little moment. Like if there’s one major decision in a big spot that turns out to be decisive, that fuels talk radio, especially for Aaron Boone. Then, yeah, potentially that manager could be more vulnerable.”

Boone turned to Cortes, who last pitched Sept. 18, over Tim Hill, a funky left-handed reliever with a 3.36 ERA in the regular season and one earned run allowed in 5 2/3 innings in the postseason. Additionally, he was a player who at least had been pitching in competitive games, unlike Cortes who was resting and rehabbing his flexor tendon strain (which will likely require surgery) over the past month-plus.

In Game 7 of the 2003 AL Championship Series, former Boston Red Sox manager Grady Little kept in Pedro Martinez in the eighth inning against the Yankees with a 5-2 lead. Five batters later, the score was 5-5 and the Yankees would win via an 11th-inning Boone home run to knock out Boston, ultimately losing to the Marlins in the World Series.

The decision that drew heavy criticism was keeping Martinez in at 115 pitches with one batter on and left-handed slugger Hideki Matsui up, five outs from advancing to the World Series. The score was 5-3. Little could have called on lefty Alan Embree. Instead, Matsui hit a double and Jorge Posada doubled to score two more. The rest, as they say, was history.

Little was fired less than two weeks later, though the Red Sox say his insistence on a multi-year deal played a factor.

Related Posts

CUBS FANS, THIS ONE HURTS: The highly rated prospect everyone’s pinning 2026 hopes on is now battling a scary elbow strain that could quietly derail Chicago’s future if it turns into the nightmare no one wants to admit!

Chicago player hats are seen on the dugout steps | Aaron Doster-Imagn Images The Chicago Cubs have provided an update on one of their top prospects following…

GIANTS FANS, PUMP THE BRAKES: These 3 MASSIVE overreactions to Tony Vitello’s first Spring Training lineup are already spiraling out of control… and could quietly set the tone for a breakout 2026 season if everyone chills!

Feb 18, 2026; Scottsdale, AZ, USA; San Francisco Giants manager Tony Vitello (23) reacts during a Spring Training workout at Scottsdale Stadium Mandatory Credit: Matt Kartozian-Imagn Images…

ASTROS FANS, THE ROTATION JUST GOT A MAJOR UPGRADE: The shocking selection of this new arm as the starter against the Cardinals could quietly UNLOCK Houston’s depth and turn a shaky rotation into a postseason NIGHTMARE for St. Louis!

Houston Astros pitcher Mike Burrows. | Sam Navarro-Imagn Images The Houston Astros begin their spring training schedule on Saturday against the Washington Nationals. But they’re already looking…

RANGERS FANS, THE FUTURE JUST FLASHED BRIGHT: Kumar Rocker’s encouraging Spring debut against the Cubs could be the EXPLOSIVE sign that Texas finally has its long-awaited ace ready to DOMINATE and silence every doubter!

Texas Rangers starting pitcher Kumar Rocker. | Jerome Miron-Imagn Images   MESA, Ariz. — For Texas Rangers pitcher Kumar Rocker, the battle for the No. 5 starter…

CARDINALS FANS, THIS IS MAKE-OR-BREAK YEAR: Oli Marmol’s 4 CRUCIAL goals in 2026 that could SECURE his future… or quietly END it if the young core doesn’t explode onto the scene!

Feb 16, 2026; Jupiter, FL, USA; St. Louis Cardinals manager Oliver Marmol (37) takes questions from the media before spring training workouts at Roger Dean Stadium. Mandatory…

RED SOX NATION, THIS IS THE MISSING PIECE: The latest bombshell report just dropped a 2.30 ERA southpaw who could quietly LOCK DOWN Boston’s rotation and finally give them the elite lefty ace they’ve desperately needed to cap off a monster offseason!

Getty Toronto Blue Jays could be a fit for Danny Coulombe The Boston Red Sox are reportedly eyeing another left-handed pitcher to add to their bullpen, according…