Proposed Red Sox trade deals Payton Tolle, two other top prospects for $15.5 million two-time All-Star ace to create 1-2 punch with Garrett Crochet

Proposed Red Sox trade deals Payton Tolle, two other top prospects for $15.5 million two-time All-Star ace to create 1-2 punch with Garrett Crochet originally appeared on The Sporting News. Add The Sporting News as a Preferred Source by clicking here.

One of the Boston Red Sox’ main goals this offseason is to find a No. 2 pitcher to support Garrett Crochet in the starting rotation.

Advertisement

Milwaukee Brewers ace Freddy Peralta has been one of the names being floated around, with the Sox being a top suitor. Fansided’s Mark Powell believes that the Sox are a top suitor as well and believes he has a potential trade that could get Peralta to Boston.

MORE: Former Mets star Brandon Nimmo reveals interesting reason why he waived no-trade clause to be dealt to Texas Rangers

The trade would look like this:

Red Sox get: RHP Freddy Peralta 

Brewers get: LHP Payton Tolle, OF Jhostynxon Garcia, RHP David Sandlin

MORE: Proposed Red Sox trade would deal Jarren Duran for $75 million All-Star ace to create 1-2 punch with Garrett Crochet

“I’ll lean heavy on the Red Sox. If Boston is serious about winning a World Series in the next few years, then trading for and keeping a player like Peralta could go a long way. He’s just 29 years old and would serve as a perfect No. 2 starter behind Crochet. Boston has a litany of top pitching prospects, including several who are nearing the majors or already have MLB experience. They also have a surplus of outfield talent, which Milwaukee could pluck from,” Powell wrote.

Advertisement

This past season, Peralta posted a 17-6 record, a 2.70 ERA, 204 Ks, and a WHIP of 1.075 over 176 innings pitched. Combine him with Crochet, and the Sox get one of the best 1-2 punches in baseball.

Powell did state that this might be a bit of an overpay for Peralta, but at the same time, an ace like Peralta being put up for trade is a once in a blue moon type of situation. If the Sox are smart, they’ll start negotiations right away.

MORE MLB NEWS

MLB insider links Red Sox to incredibly cost-effective All-Star, Gold Glove utility man to serve as upgrade from Romy Gonzalez, entire infield

Red Sox legend sends strong message on Roman Anthony’s future in Boston, MLB: “He’s going to be a tough out”

Dodgers predicted to sign $8.6 million two-time All-Star to replace Roki Sasaki as closer

Related Posts

🚨 BREAKING | A ROUTINE SPRING CLASH BETWEEN THE New York Yankees AND Pittsburgh Pirates AT LECOM Park SUDDENLY MORPHS INTO A HEADLINE-SHAKING MOMENT AFTER A BEHIND-THE-SCENES DEVELOPMENT ROCKS BOTH DUGOUTS. Insiders across every platform are scrambling as whispers spread about the unexpected twist that shifted the entire tone of the afternoon. Social feeds erupt as fans sense this may be far bigger than just another Spring Training storyline 👇👇👇

When the New York Yankees travel to face the Pittsburgh Pirates at LECOM Park on February 24, 2026, the matchup represents far more than a routine Grapefruit League fixture. Spring Training games often…

🚨🔥 DON’T MISS THIS: Tаmра Bаy Rаyѕ vѕ. Boѕton Red Sox іѕ аbout to lіght uр аt Chаrlotte Sрortѕ Pаrk— аnd here’ѕ EXACTLY how to wаtch іt lіve. TV chаnnel, kіckoff tіme, ѕtreаmіng oрtіonѕ… рluѕ the one remіnder you MUST ѕet before the gаme begіnѕ

DON’T Mіѕѕ THіѕ: Tаmра Bаy Rаyѕ vѕ. Boѕton Red ѕox іѕ аbout to Lіght Uр Chаrlotte ѕрortѕ раrk — Here’ѕ eXаCTLY How to Wаtch іt Lіve +…

🚨 BREAKING | A SPRING SHOWDOWN IS SET TO IGNITE AT Ed Smith Stadium AS THE Baltimore Orioles FACE THE Atlanta Braves IN A CAN’T-MISS CLASH THAT HAS FANS SCRAMBLING FOR LIVE ACCESS DETAILS. Insiders across every platform are lining up the exact TV channel, first pitch time, and streaming paths to make sure no one misses a second. Social feeds surge with urgency as viewers rush to lock in reminders before this high-energy matchup takes center stage 👇👇👇

Orioles vs. Braves 2026: A Marquee Interleague Series to Watch As the 2026 Major League Baseball season unfolds, one of the more intriguing interleague matchups on the…

CUBS FANS, THIS ONE HURTS: The highly rated prospect everyone’s pinning 2026 hopes on is now battling a scary elbow strain that could quietly derail Chicago’s future if it turns into the nightmare no one wants to admit!

Chicago player hats are seen on the dugout steps | Aaron Doster-Imagn Images The Chicago Cubs have provided an update on one of their top prospects following…

GIANTS FANS, PUMP THE BRAKES: These 3 MASSIVE overreactions to Tony Vitello’s first Spring Training lineup are already spiraling out of control… and could quietly set the tone for a breakout 2026 season if everyone chills!

Feb 18, 2026; Scottsdale, AZ, USA; San Francisco Giants manager Tony Vitello (23) reacts during a Spring Training workout at Scottsdale Stadium Mandatory Credit: Matt Kartozian-Imagn Images…

ASTROS FANS, THE ROTATION JUST GOT A MAJOR UPGRADE: The shocking selection of this new arm as the starter against the Cardinals could quietly UNLOCK Houston’s depth and turn a shaky rotation into a postseason NIGHTMARE for St. Louis!

Houston Astros pitcher Mike Burrows. | Sam Navarro-Imagn Images The Houston Astros begin their spring training schedule on Saturday against the Washington Nationals. But they’re already looking…