Giants Face Offseason Questions With Familiar Faces as Possible Solutions

The San Francisco Giants are on the outside looking in as October baseball unfolds without them. It’s a familiar, frustrating position-and one that has the front office laser-focused on course correction. There’s still a manager to hire, but as the Giants start mapping out their offseason priorities, a pair of familiar names could be key to patching some glaring roster holes.

Two Midseason Trades, One Set of Regrets

At the trade deadline, with their playoff hopes fading fast, San Francisco made the tough but sensible call to deal right fielder Mike Yastrzemski and reliable setup man Tyler Rogers. The team was mired in a midseason collapse and needed to reset.

In the short term, the moves sparked a low-pressure turnaround. Bringing in energy guys like outfielder Drew Gilbert helped the Giants play loose, and for a brief stretch in late August and early September, they looked like a team reborn.

But the magic didn’t last. When the dust settled, the Giants were left a few wins shy of a postseason berth-and a few arms short in the bullpen.

That’s where the absence of Rogers, one of the steadiest relievers in baseball, may have hurt the most. As the ‘pen ran on fumes down the stretch, the value of Rogers’ consistency became painfully clear.

Even a couple of well-timed, lockdown appearances might’ve turned the postseason conversation from hypothetical to reality.

Then there’s Yastrzemski. The Giants saw flashes from young outfielders like Luis Matos and the newly acquired Gilbert, but neither sustained their early sparks. What San Francisco missed was a stabilizing presence in right field-what they had for years in Yaz.

Both Set for Free Agency-And Both Could Be Fits Again

Here’s where things get interesting: both Rogers and Yastrzemski will hit the free agent market this offseason. And while the Giants could look elsewhere to fill those needs, familiar faces might be the most straightforward-and sensible-solutions.

Rogers, now pitching for the Mets, closed the season with a vintage 2.30 ERA across 28 appearances. His funky arm slot and rubber-arm consistency don’t generate headlines, but they win games-and they especially calm bullpens in October.

Yastrzemski, meanwhile, found his groove in Kansas City. He hit .237 with a .339 on-base percentage and a solid .500 slugging mark over 50 games, swatting nine home runs and collecting 18 RBIs. That kind of left-handed power and steady outfield defense would have played well at Oracle Park, just like it did for much of his Giants tenure.

Right Field Options Are Slim, Bullpen Help Is Priceless

The Giants could try shooting big in right field-Kyle Tucker is the splashy name on the market-but that may be a long shot. Left-handed sluggers in their prime don’t last long in free agency, and San Francisco may not be able to win a bidding war. Sure, they could pivot to the trade market, but if those avenues dry up, Yastrzemski would be a reliable alternative-if he’s still available.

As for the bullpen, there are always clubs shopping for arms, and that puts someone like Rogers on plenty of radars. Plug-and-play eighth-inning relievers with his track record don’t sit on the market long, and if the Giants want him back in the orange and black, they’ll need to act quickly.

Familiarity Could Be the Path Forward

There’s no guarantee either reunion happens. Both players will have options.

But given their ties to the club-and the clear areas they could improve-it’s a logical conversation for San Francisco to have. After all, both Rogers and Yastrzemski spent their entire big-league careers in San Francisco before being dealt.

A return wouldn’t just make sense on paper-it might just be the right kind of emotional reset this roster needs heading into 2026.

The Giants aren’t that far off. A few solid moves, the right voice in the dugout, and a little more consistency in the second half could be enough to flip the script. Bringing back a couple of known quantities might just be step one.