Will Boston Red Sox rookies make postseason roster?

Rookies Connelly Early and Payton Tolle both made their case Saturday to earn a spot on the Red Sox’ wild card-round roster.

Early started and pitched five innings in a 2-1 loss to the Tigers. He allowed two runs, four hits and one walk while striking out seven. The 23-year-old lefty has given up just five earned runs in 19 ⅓ innings (2.33 ERA) over four starts.

“He’s a big part of what we’re trying to accomplish,” manager Alex Cora said about Early. “Let’s see what happens — the (playoff roster) decisions we make, — but he’s a part of it.”

Tolle, meanwhile, pitched a scoreless sixth inning. After allowing a leadoff single, he struck out Spencer Torkelson swinging and forced Riley Greene to ground into a double play. The 22-year-old lefty has allowed two runs while striking out seven in six innings since Boston moved him to the bullpen.

When Cora was asked if Tolle is in the mix for a postseason roster spot, he replied, “Those decisions, it all depends on who we play. Right now we have no clue who we’re going to play.”

Detroit, Cleveland, New York or Toronto all remain potential wild-card round opponents for Boston.

“Whatever happens, happens,” Tolle said. “If they want to keep me around, then I’m more than happy.”

Both Early and Tolle have the ability to generate whiffs, which is extremely valuable during the postseason.

Early induced 10 whiffs, including six with his curveball, against the Tigers. He induced 19 whiffs in his MLB debut on Sept. 9 vs. the Athletics. He has struck out 36.7% of the batters he has faced in the big leagues.

“Throwing strikes, swing and miss, he’s a good pitcher,” Cora said.

The Sox could use Early as a reliever in the wild-card round and potentially as a fourth starter in a longer postseason series.

“I’ll be ready to go whenever they call my name,” Early said. So if AC makes that decision to maybe move me to the ‘pen or something or whatever that may be, I’m ready to go.”

Tolle added, “He’s been pitching his butt off.”

Tolle began the year at High-A Greenville while Early started it at Double-A Portland.

“If I look back at it and go back to around the All Star break, would have never expected being in this spot,” Early said. “So being able to be with this team, do it with these guys who have been able to do it for 161 games now, being able to make a postseason, it’s a dream come true.”

Tolle threw the fastest pitch of his career Saturday, reaching 100.8 mph. He has struck out 25.7% of the batters he has faced.

“I’ve joked around and said I kind of take my brain out of it whenever I’m out there,” Tolle said. “I get to come in and just cut it loose, just go right at guys.”

He called it “offensive pitching.”

“Just kind of come at guys with what I’ve got,” Tolle said.

Tolle’s fastball is well ahead of his secondary pitches at this point. He’s been focusing on his offspeed pitches during bullpen sessions and struck out Torkelson on a slider away.

“It’s like, ‘Oh we can strike somebody out that’s not on a fastball.’ So it was good and we’ll keep fiddling with pitches. Threw a curveball for the first time out of the pen today. Terrible pitch, way outside. But still we’re going to keep working on those offseason pitches, keep getting that feel.”

  • Some Things I Think I Think: How far can the Red Sox expect to go in October?
  • How Saturday’s loss to Tigers impacted Red Sox playoff picture
  • Red Sox reactions: Boston’s postseason seed remains undecided after loss
  • Red Sox’ Alex Cora: ‘Nobody thought we were going to make it to October’
  • Red Sox lineup: Three regulars not playing Saturday after already clinching

If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Related Posts

First-year White Sox manager Will Venable sees ‘real progress’ despite another 100-loss season

ill Venable knows there’s a balance between some of the strides the Chicago White Sox made in 2025 and also the team’s poor win-loss record.

Braves Trade Pitch Secures Costly but Perfect Fit for Pitching Rotation

The Braves are urged to make a trade for Cardinals pitcher Sonny Gray, a costly but ideal addition to stabilize Atlanta’s rotation for 2026.

Yankees hit with injury concern right before playoffs begin

Suddenly, the Yankees have a new injury concern to a star in their lineup with one game remaining in the regular season.

NL playoff race takeaways: Cubs clinch home field for wild card, Reds and Mets survive

The Reds and Mets are tied for the NL’s third and final wild-card spot, but Cincinnati can clinch a berth with a win or a New York loss.

TRADE RUMOR: CARDINALS EYE $260M STAR FOR NICK CASTELLANOS ⚡. An insider hints at a blockbuster move that could instantly reshape the roster hierarchy, shift lineup dynamics, and impact the playoff race. Is this a bold gamble that could redefine St. Louis’ title aspirations, or just preseason chatter?

A St. Louis Cardinals insider reportedly floated a trade involving $260 million star Nick Castellanos, raising questions about the team’s roster plans.

SHOCKING REVERSE: EX-PHILLIES PROSPECT MICK ABEL DOMINATES FOR TWINS ⚡. Abel silences his former team in a 5-0 blowout, sending waves through the roster and locker room while raising questions about Philadelphia’s pitching depth. Could this performance spark a postseason rethink for the Phillies or just add salt to the wound?

Mick Abel struck out in his first start against his former team, and the Minnesota Twins beat the Philadelphia Phillies 5-0.