As the offseason drama unfolds, it’s becoming increasingly evident that Willy Adames and the Milwaukee Brewers are headed for a split. With Adames’ stock sizzling on the free-agent market and a dearth of quality shortstops available, it’s conceivable that he’s eyeing a deal flirting with the $200 million mark.

While a return to Milwaukee isn’t completely off the table, the numbers just don’t add up for the Brewers, leaving them with some big shoes to fill.

The logical first move for the Brewers could involve sliding Joey Ortiz over to shortstop, which, while patching one hole, opens another at third base. Enter Alec Bohm, a surprising name now on the trading block who could be the perfect fit.

Bohm has been a steady performer at third base, posting a solid .772 OPS over the past two seasons. His experience and two years of team control make him an enticing option, even if there are whispers about him having perhaps overstayed his welcome in Philadelphia.

The challenge for Milwaukee is figuring out what exactly they’d need to offer to snag Bohm. His trade value is a bit of a moving target thanks to a dip in his numbers during the latter part of 2024 and some rumblings about maturity issues.

Yet, his arbitration eligibility combined with postseason experience and offensive potential keeps his trade value buoyant. One idea floated around is using Devin Williams—Philly could certainly use him to bolster their bullpen—but a straight swap is lopsided given Bohm’s extra year of control.

Considering Bohm’s likely arbitration-induced price bump and the questions surrounding his character, the Brewers would be wise to hold back their premium prospects in these negotiations. Instead, a package focusing on depth—such as offering two from the trio of Brock Wilken, Bishop Letson, or Brett Wichrowski—might be an appealing counterbalance for Philadelphia.

This approach offers the Phillies some developmental assets alongside Williams, without the Brewers having to gamble their future entirely.

Would this proposition be enough to sway the Phillies’ decision-makers? Perhaps.

They’re definitely in need of bullpen reinforcement, and while Bohm represents a valuable trade chip, making his availability public doesn’t exactly strengthen Philly’s bargaining position. This deal could strategically align with their current competitive objectives, providing both sides a win-win scenario.