The Buffalo Bills’ defense has been dealt a devastating setback just two weeks into the season, as All-Pro linebacker Matt Milano suffered a serious knee injury that could sideline him for months. With the heart of their defense suddenly ripped out, league sources have confirmed that the Bills are actively pursuing a trade to bring back former Pro Bowl linebacker Tremaine Edmunds, who has been playing for the Chicago Bears since 2023.

Milano, 30, has been the emotional and tactical anchor of Buffalo’s defense, earning multiple All-Pro nods and guiding the unit through some of its toughest battles. But in the Week 2 clash against the Miami Dolphins on September 14, Milano went down awkwardly while attempting a tackle, immediately clutching his knee. Early estimates project he could miss the remainder of the regular season.

Head coach Sean McDermott didn’t sugarcoat the situation after the game:

Best video game consoles

“Matt’s leadership and playmaking can’t be replaced. But as a team, we’ve got to find answers fast.”

That answer may come in the form of a familiar face. Tremaine Edmunds, Buffalo’s first-round pick in 2018 and a two-time Pro Bowler, left the team in 2023 to sign a four-year, $72 million contract with Chicago. While he flashed leadership and steady tackling with the Bears, his production has not fully matched the blockbuster contract. Through two games in 2025, he’s logged 14 tackles but no sacks or turnovers, sparking questions in Chicago media about his long-term value.

With a $22 million cap hit looming in 2026, the Bears may be willing to part with Edmunds for draft capital to retool their roster. A league source told ESPN:

“Edmunds still has talent, but Chicago’s priorities are shifting. If Buffalo wants him back, this is the perfect time.”

Best video game consoles

For Edmunds, a return to Orchard Park would be more than just another trade — it would be a homecoming. In five seasons with the Bills, he recorded over 560 tackles, 6.5 sacks, and 5 interceptions, becoming one of the youngest players in NFL history to wear the captain’s “C” on his chest.

When asked about the speculation, Edmunds didn’t hide his emotions:

“Buffalo made me who I am. I grew up in that locker room, learned what it means to play for a city that breathes football. If the Bills call, I’ll be ready. They know I left a part of me there — and I’d be proud to finish what we started.”

The Bills currently sit at 2–0, but with the AFC East heating up and Milano’s injury leaving a gaping hole, urgency is mounting. With over $12 million in available cap space, Buffalo could absorb a restructured deal if Chicago is willing to cooperate.

For fans, the news has already sparked a wave of nostalgia and excitement, with #BringBackTremaine trending across social media. A potential reunion would not only patch a critical hole in the defense but also restore a sense of identity — bringing back a player who once embodied Buffalo’s grit and resilience.

No official announcement has been made, but momentum is building. A trade for Edmunds wouldn’t just be about filling a need — it would be about rekindling the spirit of a defense that refuses to break, even in the face of adversity.