The Houston Astros have navigated the 2025 season with surprising steadiness, even after dealing away one of their cornerstone players in Kyle Tucker. While trading a homegrown All-Star is never easy, the pieces they got in return have started to show why the front office was willing to roll the dice.
Isaac Paredes has slotted in seamlessly, taking full advantage of Minute Maid Park’s short porch in left field. His swing was practically built for the Crawford Boxes, and his comfort at the plate has helped ease the sting of losing Tucker’s left-handed bat.
Rookie Cam Smith has had his share of growing pains, as most first-year players do, but there’s clearly something to build on. His instincts, poise, and flashes of power suggest he could be a key piece in Houston’s long-term blueprint.
And even though Hayden Wesneski’s season was cut short by Tommy John surgery, the early glimpses of his stuff were enough to keep optimism alive for what he might bring once healthy.
Meanwhile, over in Chicago, Tucker’s second half with the Cubs has been derailed by a string of frustrating injuries-the kind Astros fans know all too well. It’s the same brand of “injury weirdness” that’s often haunted Houston’s most talented players. So far, the trade has leaned in the Astros’ favor.
But that balance could shift dramatically this offseason.
According to reports, the Dodgers are now emerging as early favorites to land Tucker in free agency. That’s not just a wrinkle-it’s a potential gut punch to the Astros faithful.
Houston was never considered a frontrunner to re-sign Tucker, even before the Dodgers’ interest surfaced. The financial ceiling that Tucker’s next deal could hit-especially with a bidding war involving a heavyweight like L.A.-likely exceeds what Houston has been willing to spend in the past. Let’s not forget, this is an organization that’s been strategic with its payroll, rarely venturing into the deep end of the free-agent pool.
Still, the thought of Tucker in Dodger blue hits different.
There’s no sugarcoating the tension between these two franchises. Ever since the 2017 sign-stealing scandal, the Astros and Dodgers have been locked in one of the most emotionally charged rivalries in baseball.
Every time Houston heads to Chavez Ravine, it’s a hostile environment, with Jose Altuve often bearing the brunt of the crowd’s venom. Now imagine Tucker-once the pride of the Astros’ farm system-donning a Dodgers uniform and playing in front of that same crowd.
It’s a visual that doesn’t sit well with Houston fans.
And yet, it’s very much on the table.
Tucker still holds a special place in the hearts of Astros supporters. Despite the trade, his return to Houston earlier this season with the Cubs was met with admiration and respect.
Fans applauded him not just for what he accomplished in an Astros uniform, but for the way he carried himself throughout his time in the organization. But if his next trip back comes in a Dodgers jersey, that reception could feel very different.
This is the business side of baseball in full view. The Astros made a calculated decision to move on from Tucker when they did, and so far, the return has justified the risk. But as free agency looms and L.A. circles, the next chapter in this saga could reshape how that trade is ultimately remembered.
