Shocker: John Lynch’s Brutal Depth Chart Jab Signals Doom for 49ers’ Rising RB Star, Igniting Roster Chaos

San Francisco 49ers v Arizona Cardinals
San Francisco 49ers v Arizona Cardinals | Brooke Sutton/GettyImages

The San Francisco 49ers have to feel much better about their running back situation heading into the season after the trade for Brian Robinson Jr. However, general manager John Lynch’s recent comments could spell trouble for Isaac Guerendo.

Appearing on KNBR last week, Lynch talked about the running back room and seemed to suggest that rookie Jordan James would have been ahead of Guerendo on the depth chart if he had been healthy:

“The idea of going with a rookie as your number two back, going into a season when he’s barely had practices, that’s a really tough thing to do. And so we remain high as can be on Jordan James. Think he’s going to be a fantastic player for us,” Lynch said.

“Isaac Guerendo is still in the mix, but we felt like it was important to have another back. It’s just the way things go at that position. And we feel like there’s some unique things we can do with Brian in there.”

49ers GM John Lynch puts the pressure on RB Isaac Guerendo

It is very interesting that Lynch seemed to view James as being ahead on the depth chart. He almost mentions Guerendo as an afterthought. Guerendo had a respectable rookie season in 2024. He saw quite a bit of action due to all of the injuries the team sustained at running back and had 420 rushing yards and four touchdowns.

After the team traded away Jordan Mason in the offseason, many assumed that Guerendo would be the No. 2 back behind Christian McCaffrey. The team did bring in some competition by drafting James and signing Corey Kiner as an undrafted free agent. However, all three players got injured in training camp and the preseason, which is part of why San Francisco felt the need to go out and add Robinson.

Head coach Kyle Shanahan has already said that Robinson will be the team’s No. 2 back on the depth chart, which means Guerendo is No. 3, at least for now. James is a bit behind schedule as he missed time with a broken finger, but based on Lynch’s comments, it would not come as a huge shock if he leapfrogged Guerendo on the depth chart at some point this season.

The second-year pro had a good rookie campaign, but he is learning the hard way that you can always be replaced. He will have to take advantage of whatever touches he gets in practice to demonstrate that he is still a viable option on the depth chart.

Related Posts

Packers rule out WR Christian Watson, list RB Josh Jacobs as questionable for Week 7

The Packers ruled out WR Christian Watson for Week 7 against the Cardinals, and RB Josh Jacobs is questionable with a new calf injury.

🚨 BREAKING: CHIEFS’ Matt Nagy Breaks Silence on Rumors Tying Him to Titans HC Job In a recent statement, Chiefs offensive coordinator Matt Nagy addressed swirling rumors that he might leave Kansas City for the Tennessee Titans head coaching vacancy — telling reporters: “the time’s not now.”

A Chiefs coach has broken his silence on rumors linking him to the Titans head coaching job – saying ‘the time’s not now’ to consider another role.

Dallas Cowboys linked to ballhawk CB ahead of 2025 NFL trade deadline

With their entire secondary struggling, the Dallas Cowboys are being urged to target a former NFL interception leader.

Brock Purdy injury update: 49ers starter to miss ‘Sunday Night Football’ vs Falcons

San Francisco is dealing with lots of injuries on both sides of the football in Week 7. Here’s the latest on their starting quarterback.

🧨 POLARIZING: PACKERS FANS MIGHT BE SPLIT ON THIS JORDAN LOVE TAKE — WHICH SIDE ARE YOU ON?

Green Bay Packers fans tend to be pretty divisive when it comes to quarterback Jordan Love.

🧨 REPORT: CHIEFS STARTER JOSH SIMMONS DEALING WITH “EXTREMELY SERIOUS” PERSONAL ISSUE The Kansas City Chiefs have categorized Simmons’ absence as a “non-injury, personal matter”, and multiple sources say the issue is more serious than initially suggested. Larry Brown Sports +1 Simmons was ruled out for Week 6, hasn’t practiced since, and team officials have declined to comment publicly, deferring to GM Brett Veach. Larry Brown Sports +4 Larry Brown Sports +4 KSHB 41 Kansas City News +4 ESPN reporter Nate Taylor reported hearing language that hints at potential severity — “fearful,” “grim,” and “if it gets resolved … he could be back” were among the more ominous statements. Larry Brown Sports Other media observers describe the situation as “ominous” due to shifting team narratives, lack of internal communication, and how unexpectedly Simmons left the team. Heavy Sports His return timeline is uncertain; Andy Reid says he has “no comment,” and Simmons remains excused for a “family situation.”

Kansas City Chiefs starting left tackle Josh Simmons missed the team’s Week 6 game against the Detroit Lions due to what was described as a personal