Phillies’ Nick Castellanos Not Happy With Shrinking Role — And Why Should He Be?

Going forward, this is how it will be: The Philadelphia Phillies will have a four-man outfield rotation, and Nick Castellanos will just have to deal with it. But the situation isn’t without innuendo — and a little drama — from Castellanos, who cloaks very little when asked a question from the media.

Yeah, Casty isn’t happy.

Phillies’ Nick Castellanos Not Happy With Shrinking Role — And Why Should He Be?

Phillies outfielder Nick Castellanos has voiced concern over losing playing time. (Photo by Mitchell Layton/Getty Images)

Getty Images

Castellanos — the everyday right fielder for the Phillies for the past three-and-a-half seasons — is suddenly losing playing time. He recently got benched in favor of Max Kepler when the Phillies faced a right-handed starter. And he got pulled for a defensive replacement on Friday night when Harrison Bader entered the game in the ninth inning to play center field, thus moving Brandon Marsh to left and Kepler to right.

It was the first time Castellanos was lifted from a game for defensive reasons since June 16 in Miami when he made an “inappropriate” comment to Phillies manager Rob Thomson, who benched Castellanos the following game.

“(Castellanos) makes near the last out in the eighth inning,” Thomson said, “so we put Bader in because he’s the best defender we’ve got. … I think we’re all at the point now where we’re all-in. Whatever is best for the team to win a game that night, we’re all-in. Check your ego at the door and let’s go.”

But can Castellanos check the ego? “Absolutely,” Thomson said. “We don’t need to make a big deal out of this. He’s frustrated because he wants to play and that’s it. I understand that. I wouldn’t respect a guy if he wanted to come out of the game.”

There’s a tad more drama to this: Castellanos made sure to mention that it was first base coach Paco Figueroa — not Thomson — who told him that he was exiting Friday night’s game.

So it was more explaining from Thomson on why he personally didn’t deliver the news to Castellanos.

“Because he was on base (when the eighth inning ended),” Thomson said. “I wasn’t going to run out there (on the field). I couldn’t tell him before he went to the plate. If he hits a home run, I probably don’t take him out of the game.”

The best way Castellanos can ensure more playing time: hit better. Over his past 21 games, his slash line is awful: .165/.214/.442. And since the All-Star break, he’s batting .192 with four home runs. In the past, Thomson gave Castellanos time to solve his slumps, but it looks like that has changed.

Castellanos also ranks at the bottome or near it in several defensive metrics — though some critics say defensive metrics are a bunch of bunk. And for what it’s worth, Castellanos can whip up a beautiful play in the field, especially when the pressure is on, as he did with Friday night gem:

Related Posts

⚡ **QUIET MOVE, BIG QUESTIONS: Chicago White Sox have quietly added Ryan Borucki on a minor league deal, but insiders say this signing isn’t as small as it sounds. The timing has raised eyebrows, especially with roster decisions looming. Sometimes the most overlooked moves end up meaning the most.**

The Chicago White Sox officially announced the signing of left-handed pitcher Ryan Borucki to a minor league contract that includes an invitation to the club’s Major League…

🚨 **SHOCKING UPDATE: Ha-Seong Kim is suddenly gone for 4–5 months after finger surgery, and the timing has raised serious internal concerns. What the Braves expected to be manageable has quietly turned into a looming question mark. Some inside the organization believe this absence could trigger changes no one is ready to discuss yet.**

The Atlanta Braves are entering the 2026 season under an unusually heavy cloud, following one of the most disappointing campaigns the franchise has experienced in recent memory….

🚨 **TRADE ALERT: Boston Red Sox have been quietly linked to a blockbuster move involving a $116 million star. League insiders say conversations are deeper than fans realize, with timing becoming the key factor. If this deal materializes, it could instantly redefine the Red Sox’s competitive direction.**

The Boston Red Sox have experienced a turbulent and unpredictable MLB offseason, marked by shifting priorities, missed opportunities, and reactive decision-making as the front office attempts to…

💥 **EXCLUSIVE BUZZ: New York Yankees are quietly positioning themselves for a massive $180 million move that could reshape the league. Insiders believe this is more than just spending — it’s a statement of dominance. If it goes through, the balance of power may tilt overnight.**

The New York Yankees have endured an underwhelming MLB offseason so far, with limited tangible progress despite aggressive expectations from fans who anticipated decisive roster upgrades following…

🚨 **INSIDE REPORT: Alex Bregman is now carrying a weight few stars ever face after a Cubs legend delivered a brutally honest message. The ambition for a third title has been exposed, and suddenly expectations feel heavier than ever. What was meant to inspire may have quietly turned into pressure that could define his legacy.**

The moment Alex Bregman arrived in Chicago, expectations followed immediately, heavy and unmistakable, as the Cubs placed their long-term hopes on a player who understands pressure, October…

UPDATE: Help for the Orioles’ bullpen hasn’t disappeared yet. Free agency still provides options that could stabilize high-leverage situations. The question is which one fits Baltimore best.

Which Veteran Free-Agent Relievers Could Still Help the Orioles? Old friends Danny Coulombe and Seranthony Domínguez headline a thinning but intriguing bullpen market. With pitchers and catchers…