MLB insider reveals potential ‘Plan B’ for New York Yankees if Juan Soto leaves in free agency

The New York Yankees have made re-signing Juan Soto their priority this offseason amid MLB rumors about the perennial MVP candidate drawing significant interest around the league. While New York remains hopeful it can retain Soto there are already Yankees rumors swirling about fallback plans.

Soto isn’t just seeking to become one of the highest-paid MLB players, he’s eyeing a contract value that would only be rivaled by Shohei Ohtani. With the New York Mets, Philadelphia Phillies and Toronto Blue Jays also in the mix for Soto, the possibility remains that he could leave the Yankees.

Related: Reporter names two low-budget options New York Yankees may pursue in free agency

  • New York Yankees payroll 2025 (FanGraphs): $238 million

Fortunately for New York, there are plenty of other compelling talents available in MLB free agency at a variety of price ranges. So, while Soto is the preferred option, missing out on him could allow the front office to pivot to its backup plan and still make a significant impact.

Jon Heyman of the New York Post recently wrote that the Yankees like both Alex Bregman and Willy Adames and the organization could view one of the two as “part of their Plan B” if Soto signs with another club.

Related: Insider reveals dark-horse team who could steal Juan Soto from New York Yankees

It could mean that instead of Soto being brought back to boost the Yankees lineup, New York instead signs Bregman to play third base and Christian Walker to replace Anthony Rizzo at first base. While the two players might not necessarily replicate Soto’s production, their net value could be even greater for New York.

That would still give the Yankees the financial flexibility to sign Japanese starting pitcher Roki Sasaki or to fortify the bullpen by adding several of the best relievers available. So, while there are persistent MLB rumors that Soto could wind up with the Phillies or Mets, the Yankees do seem to have a strong backup plan ready.

 

Related Posts

🚨 REPORT MOOKIE BETTS DECLARES HIS MVP MISSION AS THE DODGERS GEAR UP FOR A HISTORIC 2026 RUN, а bold vow thаt іnѕtаntly іntenѕіfіeѕ the рoѕtѕeаѕon rаce аnd ѕetѕ the tone for one of the moѕt аntіcіраted ѕeаѕonѕ іn frаnchіѕe hіѕtory. 👇👇

аѕ the 2026 MLB ѕeаѕon аррroаcheѕ lіke а mаѕѕіve ѕtorm, Mookіe Bettѕ, the verѕаtіle ѕuрerѕtаr of the Loѕ аngeleѕ Dodgerѕ, hаѕ offіcіаlly аnnounced hіѕ bіggeѕt goаl: to…

🚨 CONFIRM RED SOX SPEEDSTER IGNITES A 2026 TACTICAL REVOLUTION, DECLARING “I WILL BE THE FASTEST DESIGNATED HITTER THIS SEASON,” а bold vow thаt turnѕ а ѕіmрle ѕрrіng trаіnіng comment іnto а leаgue wіde converѕаtіon аbout ѕрeed, verѕаtіlіty, аnd Boѕton’ѕ evolvіng offenѕіve іdentіty. 👇👇

Whіle much of MLB’ѕ аttentіon іѕ focuѕed on ріtchіng, рower hіtterѕ, or technologіcаl аdvаncementѕ, one exceрtіonаl іndіvіduаl hаѕ ѕteррed out of the crowd wіth а ѕtаtement thаt…

🚨 BOMBSHELL: Yankees’ $4 million signing of a 17-year-old shortstop is already being labeled a backfire — and the early returns are raising uncomfortable questions in the Bronx. What once looked like a bold international splash now feels clouded by development concerns and mounting scrutiny. If the trajectory doesn’t change soon, this gamble could linger longer than anyone expected.. 👇👇👇

Yankees’ $4 Million Bet on Teenage Shortstop Now Facing Early Questions 4 When the New York Yankees committed nearly $4 million to a 17-year-old international shortstop, the…

🚨 BOMBSHELL: Chicago Cubs camp just delivered two major twists — Kevin Alcántara looks ready to explode after putting his injury behind him, while insiders warn a lockout now feels all but guaranteed. One storyline screams breakout optimism, the other signals looming chaos across the league. If both trends hold, Wrigley’s future could be shaped by momentum on the field and uncertainty off it.. 👇👇👇

MESA, Ariz. — Amid a whirlwind 36 hours within the Major League Baseball Players Association, new interim executive director Bruce Meyer and MLBPA personnel kicked off their…

🚨 EXCLUSIVE: QUEENS MASTER PLAN comes into focus as Carlos Mendoza lays out the New York Mets’ “ultimate goal” for 2026, a declaration that sends a jolt through a franchise determined to transform promise into real, lasting power. Insiders are dissecting every word while fans flood social platforms sensing a cultural reset built on urgency, accountability, and a refusal to settle for mediocrity. The tone has shifted, the stakes are rising, and if this vision takes hold, Queens could be marching toward a new era faster than anyone expected..ll 👇👇👇

Mets enter 2026 with sky-high expectations after massive roster overhaul and bold championship mandate from Carlos Mendoza 4 The New York Mets enter the 2026 season carrying…

🚨 CONFIRM: ROTATION RESET IN QUEENS takes shape as Carlos Mendoza, skipper of the New York Mets, delivers a key announcement on rising arm Tobias Myers that instantly shifts expectations for the club’s pitching blueprint. Insiders are breaking down the manager’s tone and timing while fans flood social platforms sensing that Myers may be stepping into a role far bigger than initially planned. Momentum is building fast, and if this decision sparks the surge Mets fans are hoping for, the complexion of New York’s rotation could change in a heartbeat..ll 👇👇👇

The funny thing about a blockbuster trade is how it blinds people. Everyone stares at the headline name, the strikeouts, the ace label, and misses the quieter…