Red Sox rookie Payton Tolle receives legendary comparison from Pirates star Andrew McCutchen: “He has electric stuff”

Red Sox rookie Payton Tolle receives legendary comparison from Pirates star Andrew McCutchen: “He has electric stuff” originally appeared on The Sporting News

The Boston Red Sox just received a phenomenal debut from their top pitching prospect in Payton Tolle, who pitched the lights out against the Pittsburgh Pirates. Although the Sox lost, the Pirates still had plenty of respect for the rookie.

Advertisement

Pirates star and future legend Andrew McCutchen was one of them, as he compared Tolle to another former Red Sox superstar: Chris Sale.

MORE: Red Sox superstar ace Garrett Crochet receives easily justifiable ranking in AL MVP race

“He kind of reminds me of Chris Sale a little bit with his arm angle and his extension. He’s obviously bigger than he is, but just from the way he was releasing it, it felt a lot like Sale. Obviously Sale has the better secondary stuff, but the fastball plays and I felt like it plays like Sale. He has electric stuff. His fastball is electric,” McCutchen stated (via Ian Browne).

Tolle did have an amazing outing, going 5.1 innings with eight strikeouts, and only gave up two runs, which were both only given up by the reliever who came in for him.

Advertisement

MORE: Red Sox rising superstar Roman Anthony given bold prediction about his rookie campaign

Tolle also was pumping fastballs in there, as McCutchen said. He topped out at 99.2 miles per hour, and was hitting 99 and 98 multiple times.

Overall, it looks like Tolle is here to stay. He’s proven he can pitch at the major league level, and even opposing players believe he’s got potential. If he can keep this talent working through October, the Sox will be a force to be reckoned with.

MORE BOSTON RED SOX NEWS

Red Sox veteran All-Star pitcher’s revitalization in Boston might not be as good as expected for his future with team

Red Sox listed as their eternal rival’s kryptonite in a potential postseason clash; a matchup October may have in store

Red Sox see record-setting viewership through their broadcast, highest since 2021

Related Posts

🚨 REPORT CUBS VS PHILLIES SHOWDOWN SET FOR APRIL 21, 2026: FULL GAME DETAILS, WEATHER IMPACT, AND HOW TO WATCH LIVE IN THE U.S., insiders say conditions and timing could play a crucial role in this matchup, everything is lining up for a game fans won’t want to miss 👇👇👇

Chicago Cubs vs Philadelphia Phillies on April 21, 2026 Full Match Update, Weather Forecast, TV Channel, and How to Watch Live in the U.S. Baseball fans across…

Rаngerѕ Eye Trірle A Helр Aѕ Gаrcіа Scаre Growѕ

IMAGE: Imagn Images The Texаѕ Rаngerѕ bullрen іѕ fаcіng а bіt of а ѕhаke-uр eаrly іn the ѕeаѕon, wіth key рlаyerѕ lіke Luіѕ Curvelo аnd Chrіѕ Mаrtіn…

Are San Francisco Giants fans starting to turn on the beloved Buster Posey?

Sep 9, 2025; San Francisco, California, USA; San Francisco Giants president of baseball operations Buster Posey sits in the dugout before the game against the Arizona Diamondbacks…

Theѕe Cаrdіnаlѕ Could Loѕe Roѕter Sрotѕ Wіth Eаrly Struggleѕ

арr 10, 2026; ѕt. Louіѕ, Mіѕѕourі, Uѕа; ѕt. Louіѕ Cаrdіnаlѕ cаtcher рedro раgeѕ (43) аt bаt аgаіnѕt the Boѕton Red ѕox аt Buѕch ѕtаdіum. Mаndаtory Credіt: Tіm…

Red Sox’s 3 Best Options to Replace Sonny Gray in Starting Rotation

WooSox pitcher Payton Tolle starts against Columbus April 13 at Polar Park. | Rick Cinclair/Telegram & Gazette / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images As we all…

Astros Just Signed Former Orioles & Giants Outfielder — This Depth Move Has Houston Buzzing!

Troy Tаormіnа-іmаgn іmаgeѕ The Houѕton аѕtroѕ аdded outfіeld deрth on ѕundаy, ѕіgnіng Dаnіel Johnѕon Jr. to а mіnor leаgue contrаct followіng hіѕ recent releаѕe from the Mіаmі…