Ex-Packers WR says Steelers’ Aaron Rodgers wanted him to sign — but explains why he passed

Pittsburgh Steelers QB Aaron Rodgers recently put on his infamous general manager hat — but this time, unfortunately, he wasn’t able to reunite with his former teammate.

On Thursday, The Athletic’s Matt Barrows reported that ex-Packers WR Marquez Valdes-Scantling’s choice to sign with the San Francisco 49ers over a reunion with Rodgers on the Steelers was a “50/50” decision.

Advertisement

“He wanted me back over there,” Valdes-Scantling said, via Barrows.

Valdes-Scantling then admitted that while it was a toss-up between the two landing spots, he ultimately decided that signing with San Francisco was the best career decision.

On Thursday, the 49ers officially signed Valdes-Scantling to their practice squad — putting an end to any potential Green Bay reunion in the Steel City.

This wasn’t the first time Rodgers was interested in a Green Bay pass catcher, as a few days ago insider Bill Huber claimed Rodgers had called to inquire about the availability of Packers WR Romeo Doubs.

For up-to-date Steelers coverage, follow us on X @TheSteelersWire and give our Facebook page a like.

This article originally appeared on Steelers Wire: Steelers, 49ers were ’50-50′ decision for WR Marquez Valdes-Scantling

Related Posts

Steelers Hit with Shocking News on “Future MVP” QB Prospect in 2026 First-Round Draft — Head Coach Mike Tomlin Declares Pittsburgh Ready to Go “All-In”

After years of living in quarterback uncertainty, the Pittsburgh Steelers may have finally found the clearest path forward. Just days after Round 1 of the 2026 NFL…

“IF THEY WANT the San Francisco 49ers to win at all costs, then just hand them the championship trophy and spare us from having to play these meaningless games.” Nick Sirianni, the head coach of the Philadelphia Eagles, accused the three referees in the 49ers vs. Eagles game of cheating and intentionally ignoring all of the 49ers’ fouls, putting the Eagles at a severe disadvantage. He went even further by insulting Christian McCaffrey, saying that facing McCaffrey was “an insult to my career” and calling him “a cheater.” However, the NFL did not allow the situation to escalate and immediately issued a heavy punishment to Nick Sirianni after the 49ers’ dramatic 23–19 victory over the Eagles, a loss that officially eliminated Philadelphia from playoff contention

“IF THEY WANT the San Francisco 49ers to win at all costs, then just hand them the championship trophy and spare us from having to play these…

🚨GAME CHANGER: Seattle Seahawks vs. San Francisco 49ers at Lumen Field – You Won’t Believe the New Kickoff Time!

🚨GAME CHANGER: Seattle Seahawks vs. San Francisco 49ers at Lumen Field – You Won’t Believe the New Kickoff Time! Seattle, WA – For Seattle Seahawks fans and…

🚨 HISTORIC MILESTONE FOR A LEGEND: Davante Adams, the former Green Bay Packers All‑Pro wideout, didn’t just rack up stats in 2025 — he etched his name into the NFL history books in a way few thought possible. What he accomplished wasn’t flashy — it was remarkable, and it underlines exactly why he’s regarded as one of the elite receivers of his generation 👇

The Green Bay Packers are out of the NFL Playoffs following their humiliating collapse against the Chicago Bears on Saturday night. And while the offense stalled in…

🚨 INSIDE ANNOUNCEMENT SHOCKER: Matt LaFleur just made a **definitive statement about his future with the Green Bay Packers, firmly pushing back against a suggestion from STC (Sideline Coaches’ Council) — and the subtext has sent the NFL world into speculation overdrive. This wasn’t a routine clarification; it was a stance with teeth. In rejecting the outside proposal, LaFleur may have just ignited internal tension that could determine whether he remains in command 👇

The Green Bay Packers’ painful collapse in the NFC Wild Card round against the Chicago Bears has left the organization reeling, with questions swirling around the future…

🚨 LONG‑TERM STRATEGY BACKFIRES: After a decade of underinvesting at running back, the Kansas City Chiefs are now seeing the consequences — and Patrick Mahomes is the one paying the price on the field. What once looked like a savvy allocation of resources has quietly morphed into a glaring strategic gap. Analysts are now saying the Chiefs’ commitment to one‑dimensional offense is coming home to roost 👇

The Kansas City Chiefs are facing a critical decision this offseason as they look to address a longstanding issue: the running back position. After years of minimizing…