Phillies’ Nolan Hoffman makes history not done since a player named The Only Nolan in 1885! Can you believe it? This incredible feat has been waiting to be repeated for over 135 years, and Hoffman has finally broken the drought. The Only Nolan, a legendary player from the 19th century, was the last to achieve this remarkable milestone, and now Hoffman has etched his name alongside him in the record books. What an accomplishment for the young player! 🎉🏆

Phillies' Nolan Hoffman makes history not done since a player named The Only Nolan in 1885 image

There was once a Major League Baseball player named The Only Nolan.

There’s really no other way to begin this story than by sharing that fact.

It’s relevant this week because Nolan Hoffman pitched for the Philadelphia Phillies on Monday night. And he’s the first Nolan to play for the Phillies since our friend The Only Nolan, according to The Athletic’s Matt Gelb.

As Gelb wrote, “He’s no longer The Only Nolan.”

 

And now, you get to learn everything we know about The Only Nolan.

His real name? Edward Sylvester Nolan.

He was born on Nov. 7, 1855 in Trenton, Canada.

The Only Nolan was a 5-foot-8 left-hander who pitched along with playing the outfield and third base.

He made his MLB debut in 1878 for the Indianapolis Blues, who played in the National League.

The Only Nolan returned to the majors, again the NL, for the Cleveland Blues in 1881.

In 1883, The Only Nolan pitched for Allegheny City in the American Association.

In 1884, it was onto the Wilmington Quicksteps in the Union Association.

 

And in 1885, The Only Nolan competed in his final season, back in the NL, for Philadelphia, which didn’t even have a nickname yet.

The Only Nolan had a 4.17 ERA in seven appearances with Philadelphia. He also batted .077 in 29 plate appearances.

He was actually an OK hitter the rest of his career, at a .240 average even including that rough ending.

As a pitcher, The Only Nolan compiled a 23-52 win-loss record but did it with a 2.98 ERA across 676 innings. In that era, he only had 274 strikeouts across nearly three-times the innings.

The Only Nolan died at age 57 on May 18, 1913, in Paterson, N.J. and is buried at Holy Sepulchre Cemetary in Totowa, N.J.

 

Related Posts

💥 REPORT Mets jump into the frenzy for a 4-time All-Star, $430 million outfielder, turning the free-agent market into a full-blown spectacle. New York fans are buzzing as speculation explodes across social media about how this signing could instantly transform the lineup. Could this be the splash that finally pushes the Mets into contender territory?..ll 👇👇👇

The Toronto Blue Jays may be watching Kyle Tucker’s free agency closely, but it’s the New York Mets who continue to loom largest in the conversation surrounding…

💥 EXCLUSIVE A predicted blockbuster Tigers–Dodgers trade is sending shockwaves through the league—and it could be great news for Twins fans. The ripple effects of this deal might quietly reshape the AL Central race in Minnesota’s favor. Social media is buzzing as fans connect the dots and debate what comes next..ll 👇👇👇

The American League Central is shaping up to be one of the most unpredictable divisions in baseball heading into the 2026 season, and that uncertainty is exactly…

🔥 REPORT With Cody Bellinger talks going quiet, the Yankees reportedly shift gears and reach out to a star infielder, sparking fresh speculation. The sudden pivot has fans guessing about a major roster shakeup brewing in the Bronx. Social media is buzzing as everyone wonders if this is the next blockbuster move..ll 👇👇👇

The New York Yankees are once again circling the top of the free-agent market, and this time their attention has landed on one of the most intriguing…

🔥 REPORT: Braves Are Making the Perfect Trade Offer for Luis Robert Jr. – Could This Be the Key to Unlocking Their 2025 Championship Dreams? The Pressure Is On as the White Sox Face a Tough Decision!👇

🔥 REPORT: Braves Are Making the Perfect Trade Offer for Luis Robert Jr. – Could This Be the Key to Unlocking Their 2025 Championship Dreams? The Pressure…

🔥 JUST IN: Braves Make the Perfect Trade Offer for White Sox’s Luis Robert Jr. – Could This Be the Move That Puts Atlanta Over the Top? Fans Are Buzzing with Excitement as the Deal Could Shake Up the AL and NL!👇

🔥 JUST IN: Braves Make the Perfect Trade Offer for White Sox’s Luis Robert Jr. – Could This Be the Move That Puts Atlanta Over the Top?…

🚨 BREAKING: Alex Bregman’s Latest Update Sends Red Sox Fans Into a Frenzy – Could This Be the Nightmare Scenario They’ve Been Dreading? The Astros Star is Making Moves That Could Shake the AL East to Its Core!👇

🚨 BREAKING: Alex Bregman’s Latest Update Sends Red Sox Fans Into a Frenzy – Could This Be the Nightmare Scenario They’ve Been Dreading? The Astros Star is…