Report: Cowboys left with brutal roster decision after Joe Milton’s disastrous debut

Dallas Cowboys v Los Angeles Rams - NFL Preseason 2025
Dallas Cowboys v Los Angeles Rams – NFL Preseason 2025 | Ronald Martinez/GettyImages

 

There wasn’t a player Dallas Cowboys fans were more excited to watch against the Los Angeles Rams than Joe Milton.

Unfortunately, Milton never found a rhythm under center and he ended up being one of the worst players on the field for either team.

A lot of Milton’s biggest red flags reared their ugly head.

He went 0-for-3 on the Cowboys’ first offensive possession and all three passes were absolute fireballs with zero touch.

He telegraphed his third throw by staring down Jalen Tolbert and was lucky to avoid an interception.

Perhaps Milton had a case of first game jitters or he tried to do too much. Regardless, the Cowboys need a lot better from their expected backup.

You have to wonder if Dallas will keep third-stringer Will Grier on the 53-man roster out of sheer necessity.

Joe Milton’s nightmare debut may force the Cowboys to keep Will Grier

Cowboys fans hoped that Milton would show enough in preseason that the team wouldn’t have to reserve a spot on the roster for Grier.

While one game doesn’t mean Grier has jumped ahead of Milton – whom the Cowboys acquired from the Patriots for a fifth-round pick – Milton’s performance could still change how Brian Schottenheimer and company evaluate the position before the roster deadline.

It wouldn’t be the end of the world if Dallas kept three quarterbacks, as they did last year, but that could mean keeping one fewer wide receiver, defensive end, or safety, positions where they are extremely deep. That would be a real shame.

Maybe the Cowboys have intended to keep three quarterbacks the entire offseason. Howeevr, Grier could serve as the emergency third quarterback.

NFL rules state that an emergency QB “must be on the 53-man roster or as one of three standard elevations per week.”

Ask yourselves this Cowboys fans: if Dak Prescott suffered a multi-week injury, would you have any confidence in Milton running a competent offense?

While it would help to have CeeDee Lamb and George Pickens running routes, it didn’t matter who was at receiver on Saturday.

Milton overthrew a wide open Ryan Flournoy on multiple occasions. It seemed on first watch that Milton trusted his arm to make throws and threw late rather than on time because of it.

A half-second can be the difference between moving the chains and throwing a pick-six. NFL quarterbacks have to deliver the ball on time, and Milton is still learning how. Odds are, he won’t figure it out before the preseason ends.

 

Related Posts

🚨BREAKING: Todd McShay predicts a franchise-altering night for the Miami Dolphins — and it starts in Pittsburgh! By landing USC superstar Makai Lemon at No. 11 and lockdown corner Colton Hood at No. 30, Miami isn’t just reloading… they’re rewriting their identity after losing elite speed. One draft night could flip the entire trajectory of this rebuild. 👀🔥👇👇

The 2026 NFL Draft is less thaп oпe moпth away, with this year’s selectioп process kickiпg off iп Pittsbυrgh, Peппsylvaпia oп Thυrsday, April 23rd. After tradiпg away…

🚨BREAKING: The Eagles just pulled off a quiet but DANGEROUS move — signing a former Jets second-round WR to a prove-it deal and reuniting him with A.J. Brown. This isn’t just a reunion… it’s the revival of one of college football’s most explosive duos, and the NFL might not be ready for what’s coming next. 👀🔥👇👇

The Philadelphia Eagles did not make this move simply to add depth. They made it for a clear reason: speed, separation, and a special connection with the…

🚨BREAKING: A star WR is willing to take a shocking 50% pay cut to join the Packers. This isn’t just a contract decision — it’s a statement that something BIG is brewing in Green Bay. When elite talent starts sacrificing money, the rest of the NFL knows a serious contender is being built behind the scenes. 👀🔥👇👇

🚨 SHOCKING SACRIFICE: Star WR Willing to Take 50% Pay Cut for Packers — A Stunning Decision That Sparks Debate on Loyalty, Money, and the True Meaning…

🚨BREAKING: Nick Bosa draws a line and the NFL cannot decide which side to stand on. The 49ers defensive star declines the league’s Pride armband, calling it a “political display” — instantly igniting one of the most DIVISIVE firestorms in San Francisco this season. Half the league is nodding in support, half is furious, and Bosa isn’t moving an inch from where he planted his stance. 👀🔥👇👇

The NFL has once again been pulled into a heated cultural debate — this time sparked by San Francisco 49ers star pass rusher Nick Bosa. Just days…

🚨BREAKING: THE $10 MILLION REVEAL — Jalen Hurts is taking over Netflix! When Hurts quietly confirmed a $10 million deal for a limited scripted series in 2026, it didn’t feel like a normal announcement — it felt like a cultural takeover in the making. This isn’t just football anymore… it’s legacy, influence, and a whole new arena where Hurts is ready to dominate. 👀🔥👇👇

Iп a world satυrated with headliпes, few aппoυпcemeпts feel like a trυe momeпt. This oпe did. Wheп Jaleп Hυrts qυietly coпfirmed a reported $10 millioп deal with…

🔥 Breaking!! Packers are seriously considering bringing back Trevon Diggs, a move that could add elite playmaking to their secondary but also comes with major risk tied to consistency and fit

Should the Packers Re-Sign Trevon Diggs? Revisiting a Low-Risk, High-Upside Move at Cornerback The Green Bay Packers still have unfinished business in their secondary—and one familiar name…