Red Sox Face Tough Call With Catcher Depth

Ali Sanchez’s arrival has created a roster puzzle for the Boston Red Sox.

“Yes, Ali Sanchez — added to the 40-man roster yesterday — is out of options,” Ian Browne of MLB.com wrote Friday on X. “The only path I can see for him on the current Red Sox roster would be sending (David) Hamilton down.”

Yes, Ali Sanchez — added to the 40-man roster yesterday — is out of options. The only path I can see for him on the current Red Sox roster would be sending Hamilton down. Here is what Alex Cora said:
“There’s a lot of conversations what we’re gonna do, whenever we make the…

— Ian Browne (@IanMBrowne) August 9, 2025

Boston claimed the 28-year-old catcher off waivers from the Toronto Blue Jays on Friday while Carlos Narváez manages right knee soreness. Sanchez has spent most of the year with Triple-A Buffalo, where he posted a .279 average, .766 OPS and six home runs in 54 games. He has also appeared in eight games for Toronto this season, adding five hits and two doubles.

Manager Alex Cora confirmed before Friday’s game that Sanchez’s role hinges on Narváez’s health.

Story continues below advertisement

“There’s a lot of conversations what we’re gonna do, whenever we make the transaction, so we’ll get there,” Cora told reporters, per Browne. “Talked to Bres this morning, with some of the assistant GMs, and whatever we decide, we decide.” Cora added that Narváez could return as soon as Sunday.

If Narváez avoids the injured list, Boston’s options could get complicated. Sending down catcher Connor Wong is technically possible since he has minor league options, but moving utility infielder David Hamilton seems to be more plausible as Browne’s reporting indicates.

Hamilton, recalled July 25 after Marcelo Mayer’s injury, is hitting .176 with three home runs in 68 games for Boston this season.

Story continues below advertisement

Narváez, who was hurt running to first base Tuesday against Kansas City, said testing showed no structural damage. He told reporters Friday he felt “way better” after baseball activities, according to MassLive’s Christopher Smith, and noted the next two days would be key in determining his status.

The Red Sox wrap up its three-game set in San Diego on Sunday afternoon, with Narváez’s recovery likely to dictate roster moves ahead of a three-game series against the Houston Astros in Texas.

Story continues below advertisement

Related Posts

🚨 BREAKING AARON JUDGE SENDS A POWERFUL MESSAGE TO ANTHONY VOLPE — After Anthony Volpe’s disappointing return left Yankees fans frustrated, team captain Aaron Judge reportedly stepped in with advice that could define the young star’s future in the Bronx as pressure continues to rise around New York’s struggling offense 👀🔥👇👇👇

New York Yankees shortstop Anthony Volpe made his 2026 regular-season MLB debut during what became a 7-0 loss at the Baltimore Orioles on Wednesday afternoon. That outing…

🚨 BREAKING CHAOS AND BIG DECISIONS ARE HITTING THE CUBS CLUBHOUSE — With Ben Brown’s role suddenly under the spotlight, Matt Shaw pushing for a bigger opportunity, and a terrifying version of Chris Sale looming over the matchup, the Cubs may be preparing for lineup changes that could completely reshape the direction of the season 👀🔥👇👇👇

All the Chicago Cubs have to do to end their longest losing streak of the season is take down Chris Sale! What could possibly go wrong? *laughs…

🚨 BREAKING: WHITE SOX FAN INJURED — A fan at a Chicago White Sox game was hospitalized after falling into the bullpen while trying to celebrate. “He jumped up to celebrate and fell over,” witnesses say, turning what should have been a joyful moment into a frightening incident.

iStockphoto A fan fell more than ten feet into the visiting team’s bullpen at the Chicago White Sox game on Wednesday, sending him to the hospital. According…

🚨 BREAKING: RED SOX PITCHER SHOCKER — One of Boston’s arms reveals an unusual plan for returning from injury, leaving fans and analysts buzzing. The creative approach could change how the team manages rehab and rotations, and everyone is watching closely to see if it actually works.

Getty The Boston Red Sox have been without top starting pitcher Garrett Crochet for almost three weeks now. Boston previously placed their ace on the injured list…

🚨 BREAKING: FENWAY LEGEND HONORED — “Fenway will always welcome him back,” declares the Red Sox, extending an open invitation to Jason Varitek. Boston fans erupt with emotion as the longtime catcher’s legacy of leadership, grit, and iconic moments is celebrated, proving some bonds with the Green Monster are forever.

An emotionally charged piece of news has just sent the Boston Red Sox community into a frenzy: legendary captain Jason Varitek is reportedly still open to returning…

🚨 BREAKING: CUBS POWER MOVE — Chicago officially signs a three-time MLB All-Star right in the middle of their series against the Braves, instantly sending shockwaves through the National League. Fans are buzzing as the new acquisition promises to reshape the lineup and add star power to a team hungry for contention.

Getty CHICAGO, ILLINOIS – OCTOBER 09: Manager Craig Counsell of the Chicago Cubs speaks to the media during a press conference before game four of the National…