MLB trade grades: Maniacal AJ Preller adds pop to Padres lineup with brain-melting deal

San Diego has acquired two impact bats from the Baltimore Orioles as A.J. Preller’s all-time trade deadline continues.
Colorado Rockies v Baltimore Orioles
Colorado Rockies v Baltimore Orioles | Greg Fiume/GettyImages

The San Diego Padres will acquire two major bats from the Baltimore Orioles, Ryan O’Hearn and Ramón Laureano, as A.J. Preller’s mad dash to the MLB trade deadline at 6 p.m. E.T. continues. ESPN’s Jeff Passan first reported the news.

Few GMs are as bold as Preller, but even he has outdone himself today, now adding an All-Star starter and a premium outfielder to a haul that includes Mason Miller, J.P. Sears and Freddy Fermin. In case there was any doubt, the Padres plan to play deep into October.

O’Hearn is on an expiring contract. Laureano has a club option for $6.5 milion in 2026, which will almost certainly be picked up based on his production this season.

San Diego is still working the phones, with Dylan Cease’s name prominent in trade talks, but even if this is the end of the Padres’ deadline maneuvering, it will go down as one of the most absurd displays of GM sting-pulling in recent memory.

Orioles add major offensive pop with Ryan O’Hearn, Ramón Laureano trades

Baltimore will receive six prospects in return, per MASN’s Roch Kubatko. Among them: LHP Boston Bateman, the No. 4 prospect in San Diego’s system.

This comes after San Diego has already traded SS Leo De Vries, their No. 1 prospect, and Ryan Bergert, their No. 7 prospect, among many others on a day of sweeping changes. O’Hearn, Laureano, Miller, Sears and Fermin is quite the haul on paper. All five should play important roles down the stretch. But it’s worth noting just how much long-term prospect capital and depth Preller has sacrificied in this all-out push.

Unlike Miller and Fermin, both under club control for many years to come, O’Hearn is a rental and Laureano only has one more year left on his deal. This is a true win-now investment.

Update: Here is the full list of prospects going back to Baltimore.

Padres are all-in with chaotic trade deadline moves

To be fair, O’Hearn and Laureano will both help — a lot. The former can knock Luis Arráez to the DH role or occupy the DH role himself, where he started for the American League in the All-Starr Game. The latter should address San Diego’s well-documented need for outfield help.

O’Hearn has been one of the few bright spots in a dour Orioles season, vastly outperforming expectations on the field and becoming a true leader off of it. He’s hitting .283 with an .837 OPS and a 134 wRC+. Laureano is hitting .290 with an .884 OPS and 144 wRC+. Those were the Orioles’ leaders in both OPS and wRC+.

Rarely are two players this consequential acquired in the same trade, much less hours after the very same team dealt its top prospect for a dominant relief arm like Mason Miller and gave up two young starters for a new catcher.

A.J. Preller… you are a madman.

Padres grade: A
Orioles grade: A

Related Posts

🚨 INSIDE UPDATE: Chris Getz instantly shut down Teel trade rumors with a single emoji, and the message was louder than words. Behind that brief reaction, the White Sox quietly revealed a broader offseason vision. What looks casual on the surface may signal a much firmer stance internally.

After a strong rookie season, Kyle Teel is off limits in trade talks as GM Chris Getz discusses the White Sox offseason.

🧨 INSIDE STRATEGY: The Braves quietly borrowed Scott Boras’ famous blueprint once used with Pete Alonso and Alex Bregman. This time, the target was Ha-Seong Kim, and the execution shocked parts of the league. What looked routine on the surface was anything but.

GM Alex Anthopoulos might be a genius with the move he made.

🔥 INSIDE OUTLOOK: After MLB Winter Meetings, the Red Sox face a defining moment that could reshape their roster overnight. Sources suggest one aggressive move would instantly change expectations across the AL East. Standing still may no longer be an option for Boston.

The Red Sox failed to sign slugger Pete Alonso, so they must bring back Alex Bregman to anchor the infield

🔥 INSIDE UPDATE: Mets and Yankees are suddenly back in play for a high profile free agent, and the price tag is no longer what anyone expected. Executives around the league are closely monitoring how this situation unfolds. One quiet rumor may soon rewrite the balance of power in New York baseball.

An interesting MLB rumor seems to open the door to either the New York Mets or New York Yankees landing […]

🔥 MARKET ALERT: Cubs are now firmly in the final group chasing a $200 million superstar, and the tone around the franchise has shifted. Executives league wide are watching closely as momentum builds in unexpected ways. This could be the boldest statement Chicago has made in years.

While the Chicago Cubs have been relatively quiet this offseason, this seems to be a byproduct of the current market as opposed to an indication that the club w

🚨 TIME UPDATE CONFIRMED: Brewers vs White Sox at American Family Field is officially locked in, and the countdown now feels far more intense. This game time quietly alters pitching rotations, crowd momentum, and the emotional tempo on both dugouts. At this stadium, timing can shape the night long before the first pitch.

The schedule is now officially set for the Milwaukee Brewers and the Chicago White Sox at American Family Field, and with the kickoff time confirmed, this Midwest…