Report: Orioles landed draft steals early, but one puzzling decision stood out

Baltimore Orioles executive Mike Ellis

The 2025 MLB Draft is now in the rearview mirror, and there’s little doubt that Mike Elias and the entire Baltimore Orioles front office have to be feeling pretty good about their most recent haul.

Many draft experts and pundits lauded the Orioles front office after Baltimore secured several top talents from both the college and high school ranks.

But while Elias and Co. are undoubtedly feeling rather confident after walking away with the likes of Ike Irish, Caden Bodine, and others, something was missing from the Orioles’ early-round selections.

Despite having four of the first 37 picks in the 2025 MLB Draft, Baltimore failed to land a pitcher until Round 2.

While the O’s ultimately walked away from the draft with 13 new hurlers, those impact arms that Baltimore so desperately needs were gobbled up early on.

While talents like Irish, Bodine, and Wehiwa Aloy were almost too good to pass up, there were opportunities to help solidify one of the weakest areas of the O’s farm system.

Orioles landed draft steals early, but failed to land an impactful pitcher

The “best player available” strategy applied almost universally to the MLB Draft. Unlike the NFL and NBA, rarely will fans see players make their Major League debut during the same year in which they were drafted.

But for a team like Baltimore, who has an obvious need on the mound, it would’ve made a ton of sense to draft at least one pitcher within the first 37 picks.

When the O’s selected Irish at No. 19, players like Gage Wood and Zach Root — both of whom pitched for the Arkansas Razorbacks during the College World Series — were still on the board.

University of Louisville pitcher Patrick Forbes was selected just before Baltimore drafted Bodine and Aloy.

But Tennessee hurler Marcus Phillips, Alabama starter Riley Quick, and Anthony Eyanson of LSU were all still available.

High school pitchers take a lot more time to develop, and there’s oftentimes risk involved, but Angel Cervantes, Landon Harmon, and Johnny Slawinski had yet to be selected when the O’s were making their first four picks on Sunday night.

Baltimore did add Joseph Dzierwa and JT Quinn with their next two picks of the draft, but both are likely to top out as middle-of-the-rotation starters.

The Orioles need an ace, but didn’t find one during the MLB Draft, meaning that Elias may need to trade some of these high-upside position player prospects in order to secure a top-flight arm for the future.

Related Posts

EXCLUSIVE: No filters, no holding back — Gunnar Henderson gets brutally honest about his limited role with Team USA at the World Baseball Classic, raising real questions about usage, trust, and missed opportunities.

The Baltimore Orioles are counting on a major bounce-back season from Gunnar Henderson in 2026—and if his performance in the World Baseball Classic is any indication, there…

Future is knocking in Atlanta 🔥 — Atlanta Braves prospects dominate the New York Yankees 8–3 in a statement Spring Breakout performance. Young talent showed up, showed out, and made one thing clear: the next wave is coming fast.

The Atlanta Braves prospects closed out the 2026 Spring Breakout Series in style, powering past the New York Yankees prospects with an impressive 8–3 victory on Saturday…

Don’t Count Houston Astros Out From Trading for Outfielder

Houston Astros hat | Brett Davis-Imagn Images Opening Day is just five days away for the Houston Astros, who will welcome the Los Angeles Angels to Daikin…

Chicago Cubs Make Roster Decision With Former Mets Player

Getty NEW YORK, NEW YORK – AUGUST 30: Jeff Brigham #43 of the New York Mets reacts after a double play ended the tenth inning against the…

RANGERS SHOCKING CUT: Veteran Reliever Released With ZERO Path to Opening Day — Fans Already Demanding Answers

Chicago Cubs pitcher Ryan Brasier. | Patrick Gorski-Imagn Images The Texas Rangers are getting down to the most important decisions of spring training. Some are easier than…

Cardinals injury news: Multiple prospects placed on long-term injured list

Feb 17, 2026; Jupiter, FL, USA; St. Louis Cardinals pitcher Sem Robberse (79). Mandatory Credit: Jim Rassol-Imagn Images | Jim Rassol-Imagn Images Opening Day is quickly approaching…