Cardinals Predicted To Trade Two Stars To Loaded Yankees

The St. Louis Cardinals and New York Yankees have long been connected to some blockbuster trade rumors over the last few months. With many expecting the Cardinals to sell this season, though this may change, their expiring pieces fit the Yankees very well.

Ryan Helsley, Phil Maton, Erick Fedde, and others would fit the Yankees very well.

Zach Kaplan of Athlon Sports recently predicted the Cardinals would send Nolan Arenado and Helsley to the Bronx in a trade for Jasson Dominguez, Oswaldo Cabrera, Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz, and $37 million in cash considerations for Arenado’s contract.

“If the Cardinals value a longer window for contention instead of hanging onto assets like Arenado and Helsley who would help them win now, then this trade would prove advantageous over time,” Kaplan wrote. “On the other side, the Yankees get one of the best everyday third basemen in baseball and another high-octane arm to loosen the burden on potential question marks like Ian Hamilton and Mark Leiter Jr as they look to finally win their 28th ring.”

This trade idea doesn’t make much sense at all.

First of all, Arenado has a no-trade clause and hasn’t shown any willingness to waive it for a deal to the Yankees. That idea would stop this trade from getting off the ground unless Arenado changes his mind.

Secondly, the Yankees have made Dominguez untouchable in trades for the last few years. It’s very unlikely they would make him available in a deal for a regressing infielder and an expiring reliever. That just doesn’t make sense for the Yankees.

At the end of the day, Arenado and Helsley fit the Yankees’ roster. But if Arenado doesn’t want to waive his no-trade clause for a deal to the Yankees, this can’t happen. Still, Helsley would be a good fit in a trade that involves a lot less going back to St. Louis.

More MLB: MLB Insider Shares High Praise Of Cardinals’ Oli Marmol

Related Posts

White Sox Minor League Player of the Week (August 18-24, 2025): Kyle Lodise

In another splendid week for Sox shortstops, a newcomer rose above all others

🚨 Red Sox Injury Alert: Refѕnyder, Abreu & Slаten – Whаt Thіѕ Meаnѕ for the Teаm! ⚾🔥😱 Boѕton Red Sox fаnѕ аre on hіgh аlert аѕ Rob Refѕnyder, Wіlyer Abreu, аnd Juѕtіn Slаten аll remаіn on the іnjury lіѕt. Theіr аbѕence could ѕhаke uр the lіneuр, аnd fаnѕ аre ѕрeculаtіng when eаch key рlаyer wіll return. Could theіr comebаck ѕраrk а turnаround for the teаm? Socіаl medіа іѕ buzzіng wіth рredіctіonѕ, excіtement, аnd debаteѕ! 🔴⚪💥

After a series win against the New York Yankees, the Boston Red Sox took hold of the top American League Wild Card spot and got some good news about a few injur

🚨 Red Sox Roѕter Uрdаte: Juѕtіn Slаten Set to Return Soon! ⚾🔥😱 No roѕter moveѕ were mаde Mondаy, but аll eyeѕ аre on Boѕton аѕ Juѕtіn Slаten іѕ exрected bаck іn the comіng dаyѕ. Fаnѕ аre buzzіng wіth ѕрeculаtіon—wіll Slаten mаke аn іmmedіаte іmраct? Could hіѕ return ѕhаke uр the lіneuр аnd ѕраrk а wіnnіng ѕtreаk? Socіаl medіа іѕ аlreаdy аlіve wіth excіtement, аnd Red Sox Nаtіon cаn’t wаіt to ѕee hіm іn аctіon! 🔴⚪💥

The Red Sox won’t make a roster move Monday but Justin Slaten, Rob Refsnyder are expected back in coming days.

Braves All-Star World Series Champ Singled Out as Brian Snitker Replacement

The Atlanta Braves have a clear replacement for their legendary manager, according to an MLB insider, as the season falls short of expectations.

All-time Boston Red Sox starting lineup: Greatest players at every position

During their more than 100 years of existence, they’ve had some of the all-time greats come through their locker room.

Yankees manager Aaron Boone reveals next step for Anthony Volpe after shortstop declaration

Aaron Boone lays out what’s next for New York Yankees shortstop Anthony Volpe amid inconsistency and Jose Caballero’s strong push.