Giancarlo Stanton Return Could Force Surprising Yankees Change

The New York Yankees have a huge problem — but fortunately it’s a good one.

The Pinstripes have so much offensive production that, with Giancarlo Stanton set to return soon as designated hitter, they don’t have enough spots in the infield to get every slugger in the lineup. Yankees manager Aaron Boone addressed the problem following the Yankees’ win against the Kansas City Royals on Tuesday.

“It’ll be tough decisions every day trying to keep guys that are deserving of playing time playing regularly,” Boone said. “But there’s going to be some guys out of the lineup on a given day that should be in there or deserve to be in there…”

Boone then pointed to an unexpected change to further boost the lineup: putting in current designated hitter Ben Rice at catcher.

“We’ll just do the best we can to make sure we keep everyone sharp and keep everyone contributing,” he said. “It could be to get Ben Rice behind the plate here and there.”

Of course, this idea might put Austin Wells on the bench, and Yankees coaches have been nothing but complimentary of the catcher’s hitting and receiving this season. Other previous suggestions to fix this issue include moving Paul Goldschmidt to second, Jazz Chisholm to first and Rice to third, sending DJ LeMahieu to the bench. Those ideas may not be for the best, especially seeing as Goldschmidt has never really played anything other than first base in his long MLB career.

Rice has experience catching in college, where he played for Dartmouth, as well as in the Yankees’ farm system. He also completed some workouts with Pinstripes catchers during spring training this season, indicating he could be ready for the role.

It’s not the first time a team has tried unorthodox methods at various positions. Position players are sometimes called in to the mound to provide relief to pitchers in games that are considered too far gone to win, a strategy the Yankees have done in the past.

Make sure to bookmark Yankees On SI to get all your daily New York Yankees news, interviews, breakdowns and more!

Related Posts

📢 TWINS OFFSEASON IDEA: Derek Shelton could benefit from five former players returning as coaches

ѕome of theѕe аre more reаlіѕtіc thаn you thіnk. Mіnneѕotа Twіnѕ vѕ Clevelаnd іndіаnѕ – арrіl 16, 2005 | Jаmіe Mullen/Gettyіmаgeѕ   Doeѕ mаnаger Derek ѕhelton hаve room for…

⚾ SHOCKING TRADE TARGETS: 3 blockbuster outfield additions the Braves could be eyeing—could one of these stars completely reshape the team’s lineup?

One of the lesser-discussed needs for the Braves entering the offseason is outfield/DH. Marcell Ozuna is set to test free agency, and it feels unlikely the Braves…

💣 BOMBSHELL TRANSITION: Alex Cora Links the Red Sox to a $260 Million All-Star After Alex Bregman Rejects Their Offer — Boston’s Next Big Move Could Shake the Entire Landscape of the AL East!

After a disappointing turn of events with third baseman Alex Bregman declining the Boston Red Sox’s offer, manager Alex Cora has quickly turned his attention to a…

FULL-SCALE WAR: Red Sox Plot $224 Mіllіon Couр to Steаl Bo Bіchette from Blue Jаyѕ – Sendіng Shockwаveѕ Through the MLB.

Bo Bichette enters free agency as one of the most coveted middle infielders available. The 27-year-old delivered a spectacular 2025 season, posting a .311 batting average with 18 home runs, 94 RBIs, and an impressive .840 OPS across 139 games. His leadership during Toronto’s World Series run—including a three-run blast off Shohei Ohtani in Game 7—only elevated his stock further. Current projections place his market value between $182 million and $230 million on a seven to eight-year deal, with comparisons to Wil Adames serving as the baseline reference point. Bichette’s combination of elite hitting ability, relative youth, and postseason heroics makes him a generational talent worth the investment.​

Tony Mansolino to become the Atlanta Braves bench coach rather than 3rd base coach

Atlanta changed Tony Mansolino’s job four days after his hiring was announced.

Red Sox Linked To $260M All-Star After Alex Bregman Opt-Out

Third base is a significant question right now for the Boston Red Sox. With Alex Bregman opting out and testing the open market, there isn’t a clear answer for