Yankees’ Paul Goldschmidt shares honest take on Aaron Judge’s MLB status

Aaron Judge continues to put the league on notice — and his even fellow star teammates are chiming in on his dominance. After Judge’s two-homer performance in Sunday night’s 11-7 loss to the Boston Red Sox, Yankees teammate Paul Goldschmidt didn’t hold back his admiration for the Bronx Bomber’s continued excellence.

“He’s been doing it all the time,” Goldschmidt said. “That’s why he’s probably the best hitter on the planet right now. He’s been doing it for multiple years, too. It’s not just a one-night thing. We’re all almost in awe of him.”

Judge’s two blasts Sunday were part of a 3-for-4 night that lifted his season batting average to a jaw-dropping .396 with a 1.264 OPS. His first homer came in the opening frame — a 436-foot rocket off Boston rookie Hunter Dobbins on the very first pitch he saw. The second came in the ninth off Robert Stock, tying him with Lou Gehrig for third-most multi-homer games in Yankees history (43). Only Babe Ruth (68) and Mickey Mantle (46) have more.

“Any time you get mentioned with those legends, it’s quite an honor,” Judge said postgame. “But it would’ve been sweeter to talk about it after a win.”

Aaron Judge continues to put the Yankees on his back, despite loss to Red Sox

Yankees' Paul Goldschmidt shares honest take on Aaron Judge's MLB status
Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images

Article Continues BelowJudge’s monster game came with some extra motivation. Prior to the game, ESPN’s Eduardo Pérez told Judge about Dobbins’ headline-grabbing quote from the day before, where the Red Sox rookie said he’d rather retire than sign with the Yankees.

“I’ve only heard Ken Griffey say that, so I was a little surprised,” Judge said. But he didn’t forget. The AL MVP stepped into the box with that comment fresh in his mind and promptly sent Dobbins’ fastball into orbit.

Still, Judge’s individual brilliance couldn’t lift New York to a win. The Yankees’ pitching staff was rocked by five Boston home runs, including a back-breaking three-run shot by former Yankee Carlos Narváez in the sixth inning off Carlos Rodón. It was Narváez’s first career homer — and it came against the team that signed him back in 2015.

Boston’s 27 runs in the series marked their highest total in a three-game set at Yankee Stadium since 2005. Despite DJ LeMahieu’s homer and a late rally attempt, the Yankees couldn’t keep up.

Jazz Chisholm Jr. weighed in on Dobbins’ pregame remarks during ESPN’s broadcast, saying, “I love competitiveness. But to say that, being a rookie, is kind of crazy to me, to say that you’re going to rule out one out of 30 teams to be a professional athlete.”

The Yankees (now 50-27) will regroup as they travel to Kansas City, where Max Fried is set to face off against rookie lefty Noah Cameron. Meanwhile, Aaron Judge continues to lead by example — both at the plate and as the captain of a team looking to get back on track.

Related Posts

Astros’ Joe Espada and Dana Brown are making it a goal to retire in Houston

Astros brass planning to stick around Houston past the 2026 season.

Tony Vitello Reacts to Giants Rookies Wild Celebration With Perfect One-Liner

Tony Vitello Brings Fire and Familiar Faces to Giants Dugout – Now Comes the Real Test Tony Vitello isn’t your typical first-year MLB manager. He’s not easing into the role…

Cardinals Star JJ Wetherholt Stuns Fans With Bold World Classic Decision

The 2026 World Baseball Classic is still a few months away, but the buzz is already building as players across Major League Baseball begin to declare their intentions to suit up…

Yankees Hit Roadblock in Corey Seager Talks as Marte Rumors Swirl

The Yankees are doing what the Yankees do – staying aggressive and keeping their name in just about every major conversation this offseason. Whether it’s free agency or the trade…

Kyle Tucker Sends Message After Cubs Off-Field Update

  Kyle Tucker is one of the premier free agents on the market, and his future in MLB remains uncertain. He is expected to command a long-term…

John W. Henry Considers Adding Star Infielder Ketel Marte to Boost Red Sox Offense

December 14, 2025 — John W. Henry and the Boston Red Sox are reportedly weighing the option of acquiring star infielder Ketel Marte from the Arizona Diamondbacks, with the potential to significantly bolster their offense…