Cubs shockingly-aggressive trade deadline plan could backfire

Jed Hoyer, Chicago Cubs

Jed Hoyer, Chicago Cubs | Nuccio DiNuzzo/GettyImages

The Chicago Cubs’ offense has entered a new stratosphere this season behind the arrival of Kyle Tucker and the MVP-level breakout of Pete Crow-Armstrong. This team just couldn’t score runs consistently last season. Now, Chicago might thump its way to the top of the National League.

With the World Series to clearly within reach, never has there been more motivation for Jed Hoyer to operate aggressively at the trade deadline. Tucker’s upcoming free agency looms over the clubhouse, but Chicago needs to maximize this window and worry about the future in the future. They can’t let Tucker scare them off of adding money to the payroll.

It’s clear that Chicago’s biggest need is rotation depth. With Justin Steele done for the season and with Shota Imanaga and Javier Assad on the IL, the Cubs’ starting pitching is not up to par with their National League peers. The Dodgers’ rotation will get stronger as it gets healthier. New York, Philadelphia and San Diego boast some of the very best pitching staffs in MLB.

So grave is Chicago’s need on the mound that Hoyer might spring to action earlier than expected, per 670 The Score’s Bruce Levine (h/t Bleacher Nation).

“I will say that the Cubs are certainly out there trying to fortify their pitching right now,” Levine said. “And over the next two to three weeks, I think they’ll put a strong effort into trying to acquire a starting pitcher or two.”

Cubs want to trade for a starting pitcher in the next 2-3 weeks

This is an unconventional strategy from the Cubs front office. The trade deadline isn’t until the final day of July. That’s almost two full months until the buzzer sounds. Generally, teams use as much time as possible to gather data, chart trends, and come to an internal consensus before pulling the trigger on a deal. There’s a reason we get a flurry on deadline day every year, rather than weeks of trades trickling out all summer.

That does not mean Chicago will or won’t adhere to tradition, as there are certain benefits to upgrading the rotation right now. The sooner the Cubs can land a pitcher, the more starts that pitcher (ideally) logs in a Cubs uniform. It could mean the difference between a division win and a Wild Card berth when the season wraps up.

We can’t ignore the considerable downside, however. It’s still early in the season. It’s generally smart to wait a couple more months for research purposes. What if the Cubs trade for a pitcher tomorrow, only for his production to plummet over the next two months? Then Chicago emptied the clip and is stuck with a sunk cost.

The longer the Cubs wait, the more opportunities to see which pitchers trend up and down as the sample size of the 2025 campaign expands. It also decreases the odds of trading for a pitcher who gets hurt before the stretch run. If the Cubs drop the prospect bag on a talented pitcher and he gets hurt on July 7, it leaves Jed Hoyer in an impossible bind. Injuries are part of the game and never fully predictable, but again, there’s a reason the deadline exists — and a reason teams usually wait until the very last moment to swing a trade.

Matybe the Cubs can get better value right now, but also, most opposing front offices will want to give it time for a broader market to materialize. So, there’s a chance the Cubs end up overpaying. Maybe, just maybe, Hoyer should let this offense carry Chicago for another month and change before he gets trigger-happy on the trade front.

Related Posts

🚨 Pirates vs Astros SPRING CLASH ALERT: Don’t Sleep on This LECOM Park Showdown – First Pitch Time, TV Channels, Streaming Hacks & Why This One’s Heating Up Fast

Spring training baseball continues to build momentum across Major League Baseball, and another intriguing matchup will see the Pittsburgh Pirates face the Houston Astros at LECOM Park…

🚨 Nationals vs STL Cardinals SPRING CLASH ALERT: Don’t Sleep on This FITTEAM Ballpark of the Palm Beaches Showdown – First Pitch Time, TV Channels, Streaming Hacks & Why This One’s Heating Up Fast

Spring training action continues across Major League Baseball, and one matchup drawing attention features the Washington Nationals taking on the St. Louis Cardinals at FITTEAM Ballpark of…

🚨 Guardians vs Cubs SPRING CLASH ALERT: Don’t Sleep on This Goodyear Ballpark Showdown – First Pitch Time, TV Channels, Streaming Hacks & Why This One’s Heating Up Fast

Spring training baseball continues to deliver exciting matchups, and one game drawing strong attention features the Cleveland Guardians facing the Chicago Cubs at Goodyear Ballpark in Arizona….

🚨 Orioles vs Red Sox SPRING CLASH ALERT: Don’t Sleep on This Ed Smith Stadium Showdown – First Pitch Time, TV Channels, Streaming Hacks & Why This One’s Heating Up Fast

Spring training continues to build momentum across Major League Baseball, and one matchup drawing plenty of attention features the Baltimore Orioles facing the Boston Red Sox at…

🚨 Padres vs San Francisco Giants SPRING CLASH ALERT: Don’t Sleep on This Peoria Sports Complex Showdown – First Pitch Time, TV Channels, Streaming Hacks & Why This One’s Heating Up Fast

Spring training continues to deliver compelling matchups, and one of the most anticipated games on the schedule features the San Diego Padres taking on the San Francisco…

TRADE BREAKING!! Rumors suggest the Atlanta Braves could trade for a $56M Cy Young winner to pair with Chris Sale. If it happens, could this become the best pitching duo in the league?

Braves Predicted to Target $56M Cy Young Winner Sandy Alcantara in Blockbuster Trade to Strengthen Rotation The Atlanta Braves could be one of the most aggressive teams…