The Buzz Around Garrett Mitchell: Could He Be Milwaukee’s Next Major Star?

The Brewers’ season possessed an underlying theme of incorporating young players into the team’s everyday lineup. From rookies like Joey Ortiz and several members of the pitching corps to sophomore seasons from Sal Frelick and Brice Turang, the young talent helped form a promising foundation around an excellent group of veterans.

Garrett Mitchell's go-ahead two-run home run

With plenty of questions about how the team will create its defensive alignment, Garrett Mitchell seems like an interesting character in this puzzle.

The Brewers have no shortage of outfielders, offering several options as they pursue their offseason plan. However, when this is all resolved, if Mitchell capitalizes on this opportunity, he could emerge as one of the best players on the roster — assuming he isn’t a departing piece from that surplus.

Mitchell, finally with at least a fair bit of health and opportunity on his side, put together a convincing 2024 season. In 69 games, he slashed .255/.342/.469 (126 wRC+). He hit eight home runs and stole 11 bases.

That’s essentially a hand-curated profile for everything you want in a player. There’s patience, speed, and reason to believe he could push for 20 homers over a full season.

While Mitchell walks a lot (an impressive 11.2% rate), he still strikes out frequently. His 31.7% strikeout is leaning toward untenable, but it still seems too early to label that as something that will ultimately limit his ceiling. It’s important to remember that, although 26 years old, he hadn’t passed 100 total MLB games until this season.

This graph shows Mitchell’s 15-game rolling average, overlapping his swinging strike rate and wOBA:

We see a spike late in the season again, but there was a stretch just around that game 50 mark where we saw Mitchell thrive with a sub-10% swinging strike rate. If that talent level is in Mitchell’s game more consistently, he could provide some of the extra offensive firepower the Brewers are going to need next year.

And while Mitchell’s offensive potential is tantalizing, his defensive profile fits the team’s strengths too. Players like Frelick and Blake Perkins deserve all the credit that comes their way for their defensive play this year, but Mitchell represents more potential offensively.

Mitchell didn’t get as much attention for his glove, but he’s still a respectable defender. Perkins and Frelick ranked 12th and 22nd in Outs Above Average, respectively. Mitchell wasn’t far behind, ranking 39th out of 133 outfielders.

Health is always a concern for Mitchell, who will be entering his fourth season appearing in the majors with just 116 games under his belt. But 2024 was a major step forward for his role and career. The Brewers roster might look slightly different next year, but the best version involves Mitchell growing on his promising season.

Related Posts

Breaking!! The Twins Pitcher Boston Did Get Could Be the Deadline Steal They Needed

The Red Sox entered the deadline with pitching atop their wish list. As the clock ticked toward zero, MLB on Fox mistakenly lit up X (formerly Twitter)…

Breaking: Braves’ dream Brian Snitker replacement might be a former star no one expected

Could the Braves turn to an all-time great as their next manager? Atlanta Braves manager Brian Snitker | Dale Zanine-Imagn Images That sound you hear is the…

Report: Orioles pitching prospect is forcing the team to consider another call-up

With a 1.55 ERA since his promotion, Trey Gibson is emerging as one of the Orioles’ most exciting pitching prospects. Houston Astros v Baltimore Orioles | Scott…

Chicago White Sox Rookie Colson Montgomery Sets Record With Long Home Run

Montgomery’s solo homer Sunday against the Cleveland Guardians was the longest at Rate Field this season.

White Sox 6-4 Guardians (10 Aug, 2025) Game Recap – ESPN (UK)

Expert recap and game analysis of the Chicago White Sox vs. Cleveland Guardians MLB game from 10 August 2025 on ESPN (UK).

Cowboys news: Dak Prescott makes declaration to Rams owner

After a preseason loss, Dak Prescott sent a bold message to Rams owner Stan Kroenke about January football.