Breaking: Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays predicted to make ‘out-of-character big-money offer’ to former Cy Young winner

A notable MLB analyst believes the Milwaukee Brewers will attempt to make a splash in free agency by targeting a former Cy Young winner who won’t be ready to pitch until midseason.

With the World Series in the books, teams around MLB have pivoted focus to the offseason and improving rosters for 2025.

As always, free agency and the trade market will offer some unique opportunities for many teams. And there are some game-changer talents available.

However, for small market clubs like the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays handing out huge contracts and forking over top prospects in trades is not an option.

Both clubs have to be smart with their money and target savvy moves that can better their teams within their price range. And over the last decade, both organizations have had good success with that approach.

But earlier this week, ESPN MLB analyst Kiley McDaniel suggested both clubs might surprise and break from their usual offseason norms to land a specific player that could be very impactful for them in the second half of 2025.

Shane Bieber a likely target for the Milwaukee Brewers and Tampa Bay Rays this offseason?

milwaukee brewers
Credit: D. Ross Cameron-Imagn Images

“Even coming off Tommy John surgery, paying Shane Bieber roughly $10 million for 2025, then guaranteeing roughly $20 million for 2026 seems like something a number of teams would do,” McDaniel wrote.

“Adding a third year at $22 million to $25 million could help separate a team from the pack because it would be almost irrational to guarantee four years for a player still rehabbing who was trending down before two sparkling starts in 2024.

“Because of all that, I think a bidding war on a three-year deal is where Bieber’s free agency ends up.

It wouldn’t surprise me at all to see some smaller-market teams, such as Tampa Bay or Milwaukee, making a somewhat out-of-character big-money play to land him given his potential upside combined with the shorter-term commitment.”

  • Shane Bieber stats (Career): 62-32 Record, 3.22 ERA, 1.115 WHIP, 958 strikeouts, 854 innings pitched

The Cleveland Guardians is a two-time All-Star who earned Cy Young honors in 2020. However, due to his recent surgery, he is not expected to make his 2025 season debut until midseason. Which is the reason behind the projection of $10 million next season.

He might be a second or third option for many teams in free agency. But if the Milwaukee Brewers or Tampa Bay Rays prioritize him early in free agency and make a strong offer they might be able to beat out bigger market teams.

Related Posts

🚨OMBSHELL: In Los Angeles and Cooperstown, Freddie Freeman will forever be remembered as a Dodger, not a Brave. The legendary first baseman has cemented his legacy in LA, but his ties to Atlanta will always be part of the story. Will Freeman’s future in Dodger blue be as iconic as his time in Atlanta?…ll 👇👇👇

  LOS ANGELES – The Dodgers have played mostly great baseball in Los Angeles for 68 years. How many position players wear the iconic L.A. cap on…

🚨REPORT: Dodgers’ Yoshinobu Yamamoto made a fan’s day at the World Baseball Classic with a heartwarming gesture that had the crowd buzzing. As one of Japan’s brightest stars, Yamamoto proved his popularity off the field as well, solidifying his status as a fan favorite. Could this be the start of something even bigger for the young ace?…ll 👇👇👇

🚨 TEAM JAPAN PREPS FOR 2026 WORLD BASEBALL CLASSIC: Shohei Ohtani and Yoshinobu Yamamoto Lead the Charge with High Hopes 👇 The 2026 edition of the World…

BREAKING: Freddіe Freemаn Breаkѕ Uр аѕ He Announceѕ Son’ѕ Serіouѕ Illneѕѕ Before the Seаѕon – Dodgerѕ аnd the Entіre MLB Unіted іn Prаyer…

LOѕ аNGeLeѕ – Juѕt weekѕ before Oрenіng Dаy, Loѕ аngeleѕ Dodgerѕ ѕtаr Freddіe Freemаn ѕtunned the bаѕebаll communіty when he offіcіаlly аnnounced hіѕ ѕon іѕ fаcіng а…

🚨 THE 2032 MASTERPLAN! RED SOX PLAY THE LONG GAME — SACRIFICING TODAY’S HYPE FOR TOMORROW’S DYNASTY WITH A BRUTAL ROSTER CUT. In а bold аnd cаlculаted move, the Boѕton Red Sox аre ѕаcrіfіcіng іmmedіаte ѕucceѕѕ іn fаvor of long-term domіnаnce. Wіth а tough roѕter cut thаt ѕhocked fаnѕ, the Red Sox аre ѕettіng theіr ѕіghtѕ on buіldіng а dynаѕty for 2032, wіth а ѕtrаtegy thаt goeѕ аgаіnѕt the grаіn of ѕhort-term thіnkіng. Thіѕ move hаѕ left the MLB world buzzіng, queѕtіonіng how fаr the Red Sox аre wіllіng to go for the future. 👇👇

іn the hіgh-ѕtаkeѕ world of MLB roѕter decіѕіonѕ, the Boѕton Red ѕox аre fаcіng а ріvotаl moment thаt could defіne theіr future for yeаrѕ to come. Wіth…

🚨 GAME CHANGER: Atlanta Braves vs Kansas City Royals at Truist Park — Start Time Suddenly Shifted Fans planning their day may need to adjust, as a surprising new first-pitch time has everyone double-checking their tickets. Why the sudden change — and how could it impact the matchup?

Early-Morning International Spotlight Meets Prime-Time Energy in Atlanta Opening week in Major League Baseball continues with a compelling interleague clash as the Atlanta Braves host the Kansas…

TOP STORY: Atlanta Braves Turn Heads in Split-Squad Showcase Behind Austin Riley Riley’s blast grabbed attention, but Atlanta’s depth stole the show — young arms sharp, veterans steady, and lineup options everywhere. Spring may be early, but this felt like a statement.

Spring training can feel chaotic — two fields, two lineups, coaches drifting between backfields. But for the Atlanta Braves, split-squad day sharpened the focus rather than scattering…