MLB Analyst Scolds Red Sox Management For Getting Bullied By Rafael Devers

The Boston Red Sox have been through two separate — albeit related — Rafael Devers conflicts already this season.

First, Red Sox management ran into trouble when Devers pushed back against moving to designated hitter to make room for new acquisition Alex Bregman (a Gold Glove third baseman and superior defensive player to Devers).

Begrudgingly, Devers ultimately acquiesced to the situation and eventually embraced his new role as Boston’s designated hitter.

Once Devers broke out of an early-season slump and started mashing, it seemed like any drama related to the position change was in the rearview for good.

But Red Sox management (Alex Cora, CBO Craig Breslow, others) made a grave mistake in its handling of the initial Devers problem — they told Devers to effectively retire his glove, or in essence, that he’d no longer be playing in the field at all moving forward.

This was a foolish way of going about things on two levels. First, by promising to Devers that he wouldn’t be returning to the field as some way of enticing him to DH full-time, Cora and Co. weren’t preparing themselves for an inevitable future in which some of Boston’s infielders (e.g. Bregman) missed time due to injury, which would ostensibly require Devers to re-enter the diamond defensively.

Secondly, by establishing Devers as some sort of “permanent” DH, the Red Sox were betraying the sacred notion that a team’s players can and must play any position they are asked to play if and when required to do so. The “DH promise” to Devers was wrong merely in the sense that it undermined the notion that no player under contract is above the collective team.

In a cruel twist of fate for Boston, Bregman is now injured, leading to a second Devers dilemma — Raffy’s refusal to play first base.

Because Devers was asked to DH in the manner he was asked, he felt empowered to vehemently reject the notion of playing first, which has caused a negative ripple effect in the clubhouse and has made things difficult for other players like Kristian Campbell as they go out of their way to adjust to Devers’s selfishness.

On Wednesday night, with Boston losers of five straight games, MLB Network’s Harold Reynolds scolded the Red Sox for their handling of the Devers-first base situation, saying that they either need to put Devers in his place or otherwise go acquire a first baseman. The Red Sox have done neither.

“I’m sorry, but the Red Sox (need to) go get a first baseman,” Reynolds insisted during a new episode of MLB Tonight.

“We said this a month ago. You either get Devers and say, ‘You’re playing first’, or you go get a first baseman.”

“This is what I don’t get. He blew up; he embarrassed the organization. They hopped on a flight and went to Kansas City. What’d they say? “It’s okay”? No! You say, ‘Your butt’s going to first base. We give you $30 million a year.’”

MLB Network’s analyst Al Leiter then challenged Reynolds.

“What if he says no?” Leiter asked, alluding to Devers.

“Then you got a problem,” Reynolds replied. “And you know what? Look, they’re falling out of this thing now. They’ve lost five (in a row).”

“You have to sit down and re-fix this thing,” Reynolds continued. “Kristian Campbell’s not the answer at first base.”

Reynolds is correct on all accounts.

More MLB: Top Podcaster Rips Red Sox For Roman Anthony Failure: ‘Indefensible’

Related Posts

🔥 BREAKING: Braves pick up the 7M option on 3-time All-Star Ozzie Albies. Early whispers say the front office made the call faster than anyone expected

ѕeр 19, 2025; Detroіt, Mіchіgаn, Uѕа; аtlаntа Brаveѕ ѕecond bаѕemаn Ozzіe аlbіeѕ (1) checkѕ hіѕ ѕwіng on а ріtch аgаіnѕt the Detroіt Tіgerѕ іn the fourth іnnіng…

UPDATE: Braves are quietly preparing to move on from three players ahead of the 2026 season. The rumored list matches the headline fans have been buzzing about: “3 Braves Who Won’t Be Back in Atlanta.”

3 Brаveѕ Who Won’t Be Bаck іn аtlаntа for 2026 ѕeаѕon Theѕe three veterаnѕ wіll be movіng on from аtlаntа thіѕ offѕeаѕon. ѕeр 24, 2025; Cumberlаnd, Georgіа,…

🚨 BREAKING STRAIN: A new “Sіlver Slugger ѕhowіng” from the Brаveѕ hаѕ reрortedly аdded fuel to whаt іnѕіderѕ cаll а growіng lіѕt of 2025 dіѕаррoіntmentѕ. Eаrly whіѕрerѕ ѕаy tenѕіonѕ іn the clubhouѕe аre quіetly boіlіng. The reаctіon from ѕeverаl veterаnѕ wаѕ deѕcrіbed аѕ unexрectedly ѕhаrр

The Atlanta Braves had a pair of Silver Slugger finalists in 2025 in Austin Riley and Matt Olson. Sadly, neither took home the hardware.

🚨 BREAKING SHAKE-UP: José Miranda has reportedly surfaced among six names suddenly removed from the Twins’ 40-man picture. Insiders hint the move was part of a deeper behind-the-scenes purge

Joѕé Mіrаndа аmong 6 рlаyerѕ dumрed off Twіnѕ’ 40-mаn roѕter The Twіnѕ аnnounced ѕeverаl roѕter moveѕ Thurѕdаy, іncludіng thаt іnfіelder Joѕé Mіrаndа hаѕ been outrіghted off the…

✅ BREAKING MOVE: The Angels have reportedly swooped in to grab righty Cody Laweryson off waivers from the Twins. Early chatter says the front office sees something “too intriguing to pass up.” Analysts claim this low-key shift might trigger a bigger roster ripple

аngelѕ clаіm rіghty Cody Lаweryѕon off wаіverѕ from Twіnѕ The Loѕ аngeleѕ аngelѕ аnnounced thаt they’ve clаіmed rіght-hаnded relіever Cody Lаweryѕon off wаіverѕ from the Mіnneѕotа Twіnѕ. Thаt’ll brіng the Hаloѕ’ 40-mаn…

🎯 INSIDE REPORT: The Twins are quietly betting that Derek Shelton’s return could mirror a Terry Francona–style revival. Early whispers hint the front office sees a “blueprint moment” forming behind the scenes

аfter leаrnіng from hіѕ tіme іn ріttѕburgh, Mіnneѕotа’ѕ new mаnаger hoрeѕ hіѕ ѕecond ѕtіnt іn the bіg chаіr mіrrorѕ how Terry Frаnconа rebounded from eаrly ѕtruggleѕ іn…