UPDATE: Orioles Predicted to Replace Ryan Mountcastle as Concerns Mount

The Baltimore Orioles have been disappointed in the playoffs recently. but now it looks like the team could miss them altogether.

Orioles Predicted to Replace Ryan Mountcastle as Concerns Mount - Newsweek

Baltimore is in last place in the American League East division and holds a 13-23 record after another heartbreaking loss to the Minnesota Twins on Thursday.

Despite holding one of the most talented rosters of position players in all of baseball, something seems to be off.

After losing Corbin Burnes to the Arizona Diamondbacks last winter, the starting rotation has struggled as many expected.

But there also seem to be some problems on offense, as the Orioles rank toward the bottom of Major League Baseball in batting average, on-base percentage and total hits.

Those issues could call for a roster change, particularly for a team that has several highly-touted prospects waiting in the wings. Writing for FanSided, Zach Pressnell predicted the Orioles will call up Samuel Basallo as a replacement for struggling first baseman Ryan Mountcastle by the end of May.

“Basallo could slot in at first base on a regular basis while also doubling as the backup catcher for (Adley) Rutschman,” Pressnell explained. “His potential is among the highest in the league, especially for a prospect of his age.”

At just 20 years old, Basallo has slashed .210/.286/.419 in 62 Triple-A at-bats so far this season, suggesting a call up might be a little premature.

But he’s ranked as a top-10 prospect in all of baseball and might offer the Orioles their most intriguing option to replace Mountcastle at the moment.

After a strong 2024 campaign, Mountcastle is slashing just .209/.244/.322 at a defensive position that typically provides some power for the batting order.

If he doesn’t turn it around soon and the Orioles’ playoff concerns continue to grow, the team might feel it has little to lose by giving Basallo a look.

Related Posts

Astros’ Joe Espada and Dana Brown are making it a goal to retire in Houston

Astros brass planning to stick around Houston past the 2026 season.

Tony Vitello Reacts to Giants Rookies Wild Celebration With Perfect One-Liner

Tony Vitello Brings Fire and Familiar Faces to Giants Dugout – Now Comes the Real Test Tony Vitello isn’t your typical first-year MLB manager. He’s not easing into the role…

Cardinals Star JJ Wetherholt Stuns Fans With Bold World Classic Decision

The 2026 World Baseball Classic is still a few months away, but the buzz is already building as players across Major League Baseball begin to declare their intentions to suit up…

Yankees Hit Roadblock in Corey Seager Talks as Marte Rumors Swirl

The Yankees are doing what the Yankees do – staying aggressive and keeping their name in just about every major conversation this offseason. Whether it’s free agency or the trade…

Kyle Tucker Sends Message After Cubs Off-Field Update

  Kyle Tucker is one of the premier free agents on the market, and his future in MLB remains uncertain. He is expected to command a long-term…

John W. Henry Considers Adding Star Infielder Ketel Marte to Boost Red Sox Offense

December 14, 2025 — John W. Henry and the Boston Red Sox are reportedly weighing the option of acquiring star infielder Ketel Marte from the Arizona Diamondbacks, with the potential to significantly bolster their offense…