Mel Kiper reveals 49ers’ 2025 NFL Draft ‘hinge’ point after ‘questionable value’ picks

Led by No. 11 overall pick Mykel Williams, the San Francisco 49ers left the 2025 NFL Draft with nine new players added to the roster. As usual, ESPN draft analyst Mel Kiper Jr. believes the team largely nailed the three-day event, with one caveat that will determine its success.

Kiper liked most of the team’s recent draft picks, giving them a ‘B’ grade in his post-draft analysis. He ended his recap by noting that most of the class’ success will hinge on Williams’ immediate success as the complementary pass-rusher to Nick Bosa.

“The class will likely hinge on whether Mykel Williams can become a force on the other side of Nick Bosa,” Kiper wrote. “The 49ers ranked 28th in pressure rate last season (27.7%) and have to figure out ways to take pressure off their defensive backs. Williams is extremely explosive, but his modest sack totals (five in 2024) scared away some teams. Can San Francisco figure out how to get the best of him on every snap? He has elite upside.

“I like a few of the players Lynch took, but the value was questionable. Again, that matters in an exercise like this because you want to see organizations maneuver the board and add extra capital.”

Though many expected the 49ers to address their biggest need of a defensive tackle in the first round, Williams was also projected to fall in the 10-15 range. Williams was one of five edge rushers taken in the first round, including Jalon Walker, his teammate at Georgia.

49ers’ full 2025 NFL Draft class

Related San Francisco 49ers NewsArticle continues below

Mel Kiper reveals 49ers' 2025 NFL Draft 'hinge' point after 'questionable value' picks
Brett Davis-Imagn Images

Of the 49ers’ nine new rookies, six are defensive players, including each of their first five picks. Including Williams, three of their first five selections are also defensive linemen.

After taking Williams in the first round, the 49ers left Day Two with Texas defensive tackle Alfred Collins in the second round and Oklahoma State linebacker Nick Martin and Western Kentucky cornerback Upton Stout in the third. They continued their defensive focus with Indiana defensive tackle C.J. West in round four.

San Francisco’s first offensive selection did not come until late round four, when John Lynch took Ole Miss wideout Jordan Watkins at No. 138. The 49ers continued the offensive trend in the fifth round with Oregon running back Jordan James before going back to defense and taking Kansas State safety Marques Sigle at No. 160. They concluded their draft with Indiana quarterback Kurtis Rourke as their lone round seven selection.

Overall, the 49ers left Green Bay with a ton of new talent, most in positions of need. San Francisco’s heavy defensive focus signals its attempt to return to the team’s roots after a dismal 2024 campaign.

Related Posts

🚨 BREAKING CONTROVERSY: Cowboys owner Jerry Jones sends a bitter message after Micah Parsons suffers a serious injury, a shocking reaction that has stunned NFL fans, ignited fierce backlash online, and intensified debate over whether one of the league’s most powerful owners crossed the line at the worst possible moment.

MAJOR SHOCK! Dallas Cowboys owner Jerry Jones the football mogul famous for his “cold-blooded” decisions just “fired shots” with a “bitter” message to a Green Bay Packers…

🚨 TIME UPDATE CONFIRMED: Bears vs Packers at Soldier Field is officially set, and one of the NFL’s oldest rivalries now has its moment locked in. This kickoff time quietly raises the tension, reshaping preparation and emotional stakes on both sides. When these two meet, timing can turn history into something unforgettable.

The NFL has officially confirmed the kickoff time for one of the most iconic rivalries in all of professional sports, as the Chicago Bears prepare to host…

🚨 TIME UPDATE CONFIRMED: Titans vs Chiefs at Nissan Stadium is officially locked in, and the stage is now set for a clash heavy with pressure and expectations. This kickoff time quietly shifts preparation, rhythm, and the emotional balance on both sidelines. When the moment arrives, timing may matter just as much as talent.

The NFL has officially confirmed the kickoff time for the Tennessee Titans versus Kansas City Chiefs showdown at Nissan Stadium, and this update carries far more significance…

🚨 TIME UPDATE CONFIRMED: Cowboys vs Chargers at AT&T Stadium is officially set, and the clock is now working against both sidelines. This kickoff time is not just a detail on paper, it quietly reshapes preparation, momentum, and the emotional swing of game day. Under the lights in Arlington, timing could decide everything before the first hit lands.

The NFL has officially confirmed the kickoff time for the highly anticipated clash between the Dallas Cowboys and the Los Angeles Chargers at AT&T Stadium, and while…

🚨 TIME UPDATE CONFIRMED: Colts vs 49ers at Lucas Oil Stadium is officially locked in, and the countdown has begun. Behind this kickoff time lies a strategic decision that could shape momentum, preparation, and fan energy from the first snap. This matchup may feel routine on paper, but the timing changes everything.

The NFL has officially locked in the kickoff time for the Indianapolis Colts versus San Francisco 49ers showdown at Lucas Oil Stadium, and while the update may…

🚨 TEARS OF “IRON MIKE”: Brandon Aubrey bows his head in an emotional moment after costly mistakes that may have ended the Cowboys’ season, cameras capture the silence on the sideline as fans debate whether the pressure finally cracked Dallas’ most reliable weapon, igniting painful questions about blame, heartbreak, and a season slipping away in real time.

ARLINGTON, Texas – Sometimes an athlete’s career isn’t defined by the highlight reel, but by the nights they’d give anything to forget. For Brandon Aubrey — the…