SURE!!! Max Fried’s hot start gives Braves fans a painful reminder of what could’ve been

Max Fried, New York Yankees

Max Fried inked a historic eight-year, $218 million contract with the New York Yankees this offseason. He was Brian Cashman’s primary response to Juan Soto’s departure, giving the Yankees a dynamic, left-handed ace to work behind Gerrit Cole in the rotation for years to come.

Well, Cole is done for the season after an unfortunate elbow injury, but Fried has picked up the slack (and then some) as New York’s top arm.

We cannot hand out the Cy Young award after three starts, but Fried is on the right track. He has a 1.88 ERA and 1.17 WHIP so far, logging 28 strikeouts across 24 innings.

New York desperately needs Fried’s high-level output. The rest of the rotation is rather dire right now, so whenever Fried can step on the bump and guarantee a win, it’s useful — especially in such a competitive division.

That said, the Atlanta Braves have to be feeling some type of way about Fried’s success in pinstripes. It became clear over time that Fried was never going to re-sign with the Braves, but that could go down as one of Alex Anthopoulos’ biggest missteps. He never pays sticker price for All-Stars, but maybe he should’ve made an exception for their homegrown star.

Fried would certainly help sand the rough edges of Atlanta’s rotation right about now.

Max Fried’s hot start for Yankees has Braves fans dreaming of what could have been

The Braves are dead last in the division at 5-12. Only the Colorado Rockies and the Chicago White Sox have worse records. That is not the company one wants to keep.

Unfortunately for those with a rooting interest in other NL contenders, however, the Braves are going to be fine. Several injuries derailed the pitching staff early in the season, but things are starting to shape up. Spencer Strider’s return on Wednesday was a major step in the right direction.

At their peak, Atlanta will have quite possibly the best three-man run of starters in MLB. Strider, Chris Sale and Spencer Schwellenbach all seem capable of putting up All-Star and maybe even Cy Young numbers. Reynaldo López is due back eventually, too. This Braves rotation will be a-okay if their health holds up.

That said, after letting both Fried and Charlie Morton walk in free agency, the back end of Atlanta’s rotation remains vulnerable. A.J. Smith-Shawver isn’t starting material — not yet, at least. Nor is Bryce Elder, who continues to toss a few too many meatballs when he’s out there.

A five-man gauntlet of Strider, Sale, Schwellenbach, López and Grant Holmes sounds awfully good, though. Again, health is the major factor. Holmes went 7.2 innings deep and allowed just two hits in his last outing. The Braves are pushing his pitch count and the results aren’t wavering. He looks the part of a viable fifth starter for a postseason contender.

That said, just imagine Fried in Holmes’ spot: another fireballing lefty behind Sale, giving Atlanta four All-Stars and a future All-Star in Schwellenbach. Any and all anxiety around the Braves rotation would vanish if Fried were in the mix. For a team with World Series aspirations, one has to imagine the extra cost would’ve been worth it.

Fried, in all likelihood, is going to finish his career in the Bronx. He spent eight years with the Braves, and is slated for eight years with the Yankees. When all is said and done, it’ll be fascinating to see which club he’s most associated with.

Related Posts

⚾ Shock move from the Braves: the team reportedly cut an $18M Gold Glove and World Series champion to make room for Sean Murphy. This bold roster shake-up has fans buzzing—why let go of a proven star? Could this gamble pay off, or is Atlanta risking too much to strengthen their lineup?

Braves DFA Jonah Heim to Clear Roster Spot for Sean Murphy’s Return Atlanta, GA – May 2026 – The Atlanta Braves have made a roster adjustment ahead…

BOMBSHELL IN BEANTOWN: Red Sox DROP the Hammer, SHIP All-Star Slugger to Braves in Stunning Blockbuster….

In a move that sends shockwaves through Fenway Park and Major League Baseball, the Boston Red Sox have traded outfielder Jarren Duran to the Atlanta Braves in…

🚨RED SOX JUST STUNNED BASEBALL: Only 12 hours after being released by Philadelphia, one of MLB’s top hitters reportedly rejected a massive $60 million offer from the Yankees just to join Boston for less money. This isn’t just a free-agent move… it’s a statement, and Red Sox fans are already believing this could become one of the most emotional and important signings of the era 👀👇👇👇

Boston, Massachusetts – May 5, 2026 Just 12 hours after being released by the Philadelphia Phillies, one of the most feared and respected hitters in MLB made…

🚨DODGERS CLUBHOUSE TENSION IS HEATING UP: Dave Roberts has reportedly delivered a strong message to Dalton Rushing as criticism surrounding the young prospect continues to grow. This isn’t just routine coaching… it’s a pressure moment inside one of baseball’s biggest organizations, and the spotlight on Rushing may now be brighter than ever 👀👇👇👇

The Dodgers were grinding through another tight series when the chatter shifted from the scoreboard to the catcher’s box. Dalton Rushing, the 25-year-old who has forced his…

REPORT: ⚾ Insider Breakdown: What a Drake Baldwin Contract Extension Could Really Cost the Braves. Braves brass still hasn’t officially entered serious talks with their breakout catcher despite his NL Rookie of the Year season and MVP‑level start in 2026. While Atlanta has the luxury of time before arbitration and free agency kick in, projections suggest that if a long‑term deal does happen, it could reset the catcher market — potentially north of $100 M+ over multiple years, especially if Baldwin keeps producing like he has. Could this be a franchise‑altering decision or a wait‑and‑see gamble?

The Atlanta Braves are enjoying one of the most exciting seasons in recent franchise history, and a big reason has been the breakout performance of young catcher…

🚨 BREAKING: Second-Inning Collapse Sinks White Sox in 7-2 Loss to Angels, Fans React With Shock and Frustration, Analysts Warn Early-Season Struggles Could Threaten Chicago’s Momentum 👀👇👇👇

For a minute there in the top of the second when the Good Guys got on the board first, it felt like they might actually take the…