Brewers react to Yankees’ historic 20-run outburst: ‘Old-fashioned ass-whoopin’

NEW YORK — Brewers manager Pat Murphy saw some positives from his team in their 20-9 loss to the Yankees on Saturday, but he was appropriately blunt about the final result.

“What would you call that?” Murphy asked after reporters filed into his office, taking a beat. “An old-fashioned ass-whoopin’?”

The Brewers didn’t just allow 20 runs, falling to 0-2 on the season. Their pitchers gave up nine home runs in the bashing, a new single-game franchise record for the Yankees.

Left-hander Nestor Cortes, who was making his Brewers debut and facing his old team, dug his club into a hole early. The Yankees homered on the first three pitches from Cortes in the first inning, something that’s never happened before in MLB history.

Fastball to Paul Goldschmidt. Boom, a towering shot to left-center, Goldschmidt’s first home run in pinstripes.

Another fastball to Cody Bellinger. See ya, a no-doubter to right-center, Bellinger’s first homer in a Yankees uniform.

And a cutter to Aaron Judge. It was gone as soon as Judge made contact, a 468-foot missile to left that sent a sellout crowd in the Bronx into a frenzy.

“Yankees are a powerhouse,” Murphy said. “They go to the World Series last year? I think they did and they did some good things. I’ve been watching [Cody] Bellinger and [Paul] Goldschmidt for a long time. I know a little bit about how good they are. And that big giant, that kid’s good, right?”

Cortes was pulled after recording only six outs, charged with eight runs on five home runs, six total hits and five walks.

To make matters worse, Cortes didn’t speak to the media after the game.

Once Murphy spoke to reporters postgame, a Brewers official shared that Cortes had already left the stadium, not waiting to take questions at his locker.

That’s a surprise coming from the pitcher who made himself available after the walk-off grand slam he gave up to Freddie Freeman in Game 1 of the World Series at Dodger Stadium last fall. Cortes even stood at his locker and spoke with Yankees reporters on Opening Day for an extended period of time, reflecting on his time with the Yankees, the trade to Milwaukee and more.

According to Todd Rosiak of the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel, Cortes apologized through a Brewers spokesperson for the premature departure, calling it “a miscommunication.” He’s now expected to speak to reporters on Sunday morning.

“He didn’t throw the ball good,” Murphy said. “He didn’t execute. Didn’t throw the ball good, he’d be the first to tell you.”

Asked how he thinks the left-hander handled his start, the emotions of being back at Yankee Stadium and everything that followed, Murphy called Cortes a pro. He raved about the left-hander in his pregame media session on Opening Day and for the Brewers, with all their pitching injuries, Cortes is a pivotal piece of the puzzle. They need him to bounce back from this and be an anchor to Milwaukee’s rotation, like he was with the Yankees for much of these last four seasons.

“My heart goes out to him,” Murphy said, “because he’s a great, great young man. A great teammate. So, your heart just hurts more because you know what he did to put his best foot forward.”

Murphy didn’t pull Cortes earlier because he was hoping the southpaw could settle in and find a rhythm. He never did, giving up a solo shot to Austin Wells later in the first and — arguably the biggest swing of the game — a three-run homer from Anthony Volpe with two outs (and a full count) in the second. The Brewers had battled back in the top of the second against Yankees ace Max Fried and cut their deficit to one. Volpe’s homer turned it back into the beginnings of a blowout.

“I don’t know how [Nestor] handled it, but I do know he’s a professional,” ex-Yankee Jake Bauers said in the Brewers’ clubhouse. “He’s a damn good pitcher and he’s gonna bounce back and he’s gonna be solid for us.”

Bauers came in to pitch in the eighth inning and had to face Judge with the slugger on the hunt for his fourth homer of the game.

“Regardless of being a position player pitching, I didn’t want to give him a homer,” Bauers said. “I was joking with him when he was on deck, I told him I’m gonna hit him in the ribs. Then gave him the best curveball I had. He still hit it pretty good.”

Judge ripped a 108.9-mph line drive to left field on the 55.3-mph mph eephus, but he was on top of it. Left fielder Isaac Collins was able to haul it in.

“I knew it was gonna stay in,” Bauers said. “Funny moment in an otherwise not good day.”

  • Every historic stat from Yankees’ record-setting bashing of Brewers
  • Yankees’ new ‘Torpedo’ bat design looks funky, but it’s legal and already working
  • What Yankees’ Aaron Judge (3 HRs) was thinking as he almost made history | Klapisch
  • Aaron Judge leads Yankees to historic home run frenzy in blowout of Brewers
  • Yankees make history with home run barrage in Nestor Cortes’ return to Bronx

Thank you for relying on us to provide the journalism you can trust. Please consider supporting us with a subscription.

Max Goodman may be reached at [email protected].

If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Related Posts

🚨 BREAKING: HEARTFELT TRUTH — Ronald Acuña Jr. didn’t hold back after Venezuela’s win over Italy, delivering an emotional message that showed his deep pride for his country while still reaffirming where his loyalty stands with the Braves. 👇👇👇

The World Baseball Classic continues to deliver emotional, defining moments, and few have resonated more deeply than the message sent by Ronald Acuña Jr. following Venezuela’s victory…

🚨 REPORT: CLOCK IS TICKING — Mike Tauchman’s March 25 opt-out clause is putting quiet pressure on the Mets, as a decision looms that could suddenly change the roster if things don’t go his way soon..ll 👇👇👇

March 17, 2026. The New York Mets are approaching one of the more quietly intriguing roster decisions of spring training, and it centers around a player who…

🚨 BREAKING: HOPE SHAKEN — The latest update on Triston Casas is raising real concern inside Boston, as uncertainty suddenly clouds the timeline for one of the Red Sox’s most important bats. 👇👇👇

March 17, 2026. The Boston Red Sox are inching closer to Opening Day, but one of their most important offensive pieces will not be part of that…

🚨 REPORT: FUTURE ON THE EDGE — The Yankees’ sudden position shift isn’t just a tactical move, it feels like the beginning of the end for Anthony Volpe as uncertainty creeps in and a once-secure role starts slipping away in silence. 👇👇👇

March 17, 2026. The New York Yankees are once again leaning into roster flexibility as they navigate a season already shaped by injuries and uncertainty, and one…

🚨 BREAKING: HEARTS SINK — Seiya Suzuki’s latest injury update hits hard, raising real concern that the Cubs may be without their star at the worst possible time as uncertainty suddenly takes over. 👇👇👇

March 17, 2026. The Chicago Cubs are suddenly facing a potentially serious setback, as concerns continue to grow around the health of star outfielder Seiya Suzuki following…

CHRISTIAN VÁZQUEZ BACK IN ASTROS CAMP: Veteran Backstop’s Surprise Return Sparks Intense Battle for Catching Depth—Is Houston’s Behind-the-Plate Future About to Get a Major Shake-Up?

Catcher Christian Vazquez | Erik Williams-Imagn Images . The Houston Astros have established that Yainer Diaz will be the starting catcher for the team. The Astros have…