Did Cubs Really Trade Away a 60 Home Run Hitter for One Season of Kyle Tucker?

As spring training wraps up, Major League roster spots are filling up, and the Chicago Cubs are facing the reality of their Kyle Tucker trade.

After a strong abbreviated season in the minors last year, the Cubs’ first-round pick of the 2024 draft, Cam Smith, is going off for his new team in spring training, leaving Chicago fans in a state of disbelief.

The Houston Astros are seriously considering a Major League roster spot for their newly-acquired talent, while the Cubs are working out a way to use Tucker in their favor for one year before he hits free agency.

If the Astros go against past form and place Smith on their Opening Day roster rather than sending him to Double or Triple-A, Tucker, and the team as a whole, would have to put together a fantastic showing this season based on the potential that the rising superstar has.

Things are getting so hype for Smith that there are those who are deeming him to potentially be the next 60-homer player in The Show.

Cam Smith is “built like a Transformer,” possibly “the next 60-homer guy” and has captivated the entire Astros’ clubhouse. Here’s a story with insights from Jeremy Peña, Christian Walker, Jose Altuve, Mauricio Dubón, Omar López and Troy Snitker – https://t.co/ggWMWnPDLX

— Chandler Rome (@Chandler_Rome) March 21, 2025

Tucker has become a perennial MVP candidate the past few years once he hit his prime, but there is a chance Smith becomes the next megastar in the sport based on how people are viewing him right now.

If Chicago doesn’t extend Tucker, and if they don’t have a successful year, seeing their former prospect become the face of a different franchise would be a tough pill to swallow.

Until Smith has some years under his belt in the Major League, the value of the trade will still be up in the air, but Cubs fans can’t help but feel the sting of regret while reading about Smith’s spring performance.

At the time of writing, the 22-year-old has recorded a .419/.500/.871 slash line, completely blowing away expectations during his first Major League camp.

It will also be interesting to see what position Smith plays.

During his tenure in Chicago, he was viewed as a third baseman long term, something which likely made the front office more comfortable giving him up in the package to land Tucker since they already have top prospect Matt Shaw positioned at the hot corner.

But Houston is experimenting with using him in the outfield, something the Cubs could have benefited from if they kept him since it’s not a given they’ll get more than a year of Tucker.

Still, this is all conjecture at this point.

Without a concrete answer about Smith’s future, Chicago can rest easier knowing Tucker should make a notable difference for them in the upcoming campaign, potentially being a driving factor in them getting into the playoffs.

However, if Smith is as capable of big-league stardom like the new hype is suggesting he could be, then the Cubs will have to wallow in this decision for years to come.

Related Posts

🚨 BREAKING CUBS VS BRAVES TURNS INTO MUST-WATCH BASEBALL CHAOS — Two National League powerhouses are set to collide Thursday night as Chicago fights to stop the bleeding against a red-hot Atlanta squad led by the terrifying Chris Sale, with playoff energy already exploding inside Truist Park and fans scrambling for stream links, TV channels, and betting odds before first pitch 👀🔥👇👇👇

The Chicago Cubs and Atlanta Braves are preparing for what feels far bigger than an ordinary regular-season finale, as two National League division leaders collide under the…

Jung-Hoo Lee Juѕt Shаttered Gіаntѕ Hіѕtory wіth Jаw-Droрріng Inѕіde-the-Pаrk Home Run – Sаn Frаncіѕco’ѕ New Stаr Delіverѕ Mаgіc!

Getty Jung Hoo Lee mаde ѕаn Frаncіѕco Gіаntѕ hіѕtory wіth аn іnѕіde-the-раrk home run аgаіnѕt the Loѕ аngeleѕ Dodgerѕ. Wіth hіѕ ѕаn Frаncіѕco Gіаntѕ trаіlіng 2-0 to…

Astros Hit with Concerning Jeremy Peña Injury Update – Houston’s All-Star Shortstop Status Now in Serious Doubt!

Getty The Houston Astros were supposed to be getting Jeremy Peña back. Instead, his rehab assignment just created a new reason to worry. Peña missed his scheduled…

Cardinals’ Jordan Walker Receives Massive Extension Update – St. Louis on the Brink of a Franchise-Altering Blunder or Masterstroke!

There has been a lot to be excited about this season for St. Louis Cardinals fans, as their record is a lot better than anyone could’ve expected…

Tanner Houck Return Timeline Just Dropped – Major Update Red Sox Fans Have Been Desperately Waiting For!

Worceѕter’ѕ Tаnner Houck fаceѕ Buffаlo аt рolаr раrk June 18. | Rіck Cіnclаіr/Telegrаm &amр;аmр; Gаzette / Uѕа TODаY NeTWORK vіа іmаgn іmаgeѕ Tаnner Houck wаѕn’t one of…

🚨BREAKING: “I’m Not Going To Sit There Feeling Sorry For Myself.” — Trevor Story Just Delivered A Fierce And Emotional Message As Pressure Continues To Mount Around The Red Sox. At a moment when frustration and criticism are surrounding Boston from every direction, Story’s mindset is quickly becoming a rallying cry for fans desperate to see this team fight back 👀👇

Pressure was mounting on Fenway Park. Booing was becoming more frequent whenever Trevor Story stepped onto the plate. Terrible numbers, defensive errors, and a season spiraling out…