The Milwaukee Brewers have long danced the tango of tight finances, a familiar rhythm for smaller market teams in the MLB. Under the ownership of Mark Attanasio, they’ve consistently faced the challenge of doing more with less.
Nonetheless, the Brewers have managed to make the playoffs six times in the last seven seasons. However, those financial constraints have clipped their wings, often leading them to part ways with elite talent when paychecks come calling.
While this financial juggling act isn’t exclusive to the Brewers, it does make their margin for error razor-thin. The departure of astute former general manager David Stearns sparked fears that their playoff cadence might falter.
Stearns, known for his adept maneuvering within these confines, eventually headed to the greener pastures of the New York Mets.
Despite these concerns, Matt Arnold has stepped smoothly into Stearns’ shoes, guiding the Brewers to consecutive division titles, proving that the team can hold its own amidst financial storm clouds.
But as the offseason looms, there’s a growing sense that Milwaukee might take a breather. Meanwhile, Stearns is basking in the luxury of the Mets’ vast resources. “The entirety of the player universe is potentially accessible to us,” he remarked with unbridled enthusiasm about his new role, a rather enviable position for any executive who once had to count pennies.
It’s crucial to note, however, that Stearns hasn’t disparaged his tenure with Milwaukee.
On a recent visit in late September, he spoke fondly of the Brewers, acknowledging the strong connections he forged there. Yet, the allure of endless resources with the Mets is a siren song too tempting for any competitive executive to resist.
Stearns’ glee was evident when he contrasted the freedom he now enjoys with the constraints he had in Milwaukee, his grin suggesting a Christmas morning feeling.
Imagine having the megabucks of Steve Cohen at your disposal with dreams of Juan Soto dancing in your head.
For the Brewers, the offseason is shaping up to be a labyrinth of challenges: recovering from a crushing playoff loss to Stearns’ Mets, grappling with decreased TV revenues from the Diamond Sports debacle, and potentially bidding farewell to shortstop Willy Adames in free agency.
Add to that the possibility of trading closer Devin Williams to maximize his current value — a familiar scenario of Brewers talent moving on for bigger paydays.
As Arnold navigates this maze, the road ahead is fraught with hurdles.
While there’s still hope on the horizon for Milwaukee, it’s easy to understand why Stearns can barely contain his newfound liberty from these perennial financial shackles.