Breaking: Shocking Trade Idea Would Swap Cy Young Winner For One Orioles Prospect

The Miami Marlins will almost certainly look to trade their ace, Sandy Alcántara, this season. Miami cleared house last season by trading nearly any player with big league service time.

Alcántara was recovering from Tommy John surgery, so the Marlins held onto him. Now the righty is back on the mound and looks to have returned to his 2022 National League Cy Young winner level of ability. Bleacher Report’s Zachary Rymer recently made a shocking prediction.

Shocking Trade Idea Would Swap Cy Young Winner For One Orioles Prospect -  Newsweek

Rymer suggested the Baltimore Orioles could be the team to land Alcántara and that it would only cost them one prospect to do so.

Here’s the full trade pitched by Rymer to send Alcántara to Baltimore:

Baltimore Orioles receive: RHP Sandy Alcántara Miami Marlins receive: C Samuel Basallo “As hard as it would be for Baltimore to part with that kind of power, Basallo is already looking up at Adley Rutschman, and there’s room at first base for only one of him and fellow elite prospect Coby Mayo,” Rymer wrote.

While Basallo is as elite of a prospect as you will find in baseball, swapping him in a one-for-one deal in exchange for a Cy Young winning pitcher seems completely outlandish.

Baltimore would likely need to pair Basallo with one or two more high-ranked prospects if it wanted to land the Marlins’ ace.

The Orioles could also refuse to trade their top-ranked catching prospect. Basallo is the kind of hitter who could be untouchable on the trade market.

At the end of the day, this trade idea just seems a bit of a reach.

The Marlins would almost never consider this trade.

Related Posts

Red Sox lose out on veteran free agent reliever Craig Breslow scouted over weekend (report)

The Red Sox made a play for veteran reliever David Robertson, but he’s going to the Phillies instead.

Photos: Chicago Cubs lose 6-1 to the Boston Red Sox at Wrigley Field

The Chicago Cubs lost 6-1 to Garrett Crochet and the Boston Red Sox on Sunday, July 20, 2025, at Wrigley Field.

Yankees linked to $400 million pitcher in MLB-altering future deal

New York classically would make this move.

Yankees Top Prospect on a Heater for the Ages

Yankees outfielder Spencer Jones’ home runs are not limping over the fence. Spencer Jones is hitting bombs, and at an Aaron Judge-like pace.

Matt Shaw starts second half with nice weekend, but how much will it affect Cubs’ trade-deadline plans?

The rookie third baseman came out of the All-Star break with four hits, including a homer, in three games against the Red Sox, but is that enough to keep the Cubs from shopping for a third baseman?

3 Cubs trade rumors that must become reality to hold off Brewers in the NL Central

The Chicago Cubs are neck and neck with Milwaukee in the NL Central race and they have to be active at the MLB trade deadline if they want to separate.