Braves’ spring training lineup could tip Atlanta’s hand about Sean Murphy replacement

With Sean Murphy out for the next month and change, the Atlanta Braves needed to act fast to solve their growing needs at catcher. Letting Travis d’Arnaud walk this past offseason made sense at the time, but Atlanta could really use some veteran experience behind the plate. For the time being, it will be veteran farmhand Chadwick Tromp and Atlanta’s top prospect Drake Baldwin manning the dish.

The good news for the Braves is Tromp will get some valuable MLB experience this season. He had been buried on the Braves’ depth chart for years, so this will allow other teams to potentially get a better look at him should he conceivable hit the waiver wire or trade market. To me, this Murphy injury is all about the future. Atlanta has tabbed Baldwin as such, so now is the time to see what he can do.

As if Braves Country needed any more reason to get excited about the prospects of its top prospect, Brian Snitker pencilled in Baldwin to catch for Chris Sale and bat seventh in Atlanta’s spring training game vs. the Minnesota Twins on Tuesday afternoon. Sale is coming off his best season as a professional, having won the NL Cy Young and Triple Crown in his first year with the Braves in 2024.

I would like to think that Sale and Baldwin’s growing rapport will be key to the Braves out of the gate.

Sale on the bump 💪#BravesST pic.twitter.com/Oi61l73mEU

— Atlanta Braves (@Braves) March 4, 2025

How Atlanta navigates the first month of the year will be crucial in its dreams of another postseason.

For more news and rumors, check out MLB Insider Robert Murray’s work on The Baseball Insiders podcast, subscribe to The Moonshot, our weekly MLB newsletter, and join the discord to get the inside scoop during the MLB season.

Drake Baldwin could serve as Chris Sale’s catcher for the start of season

What I think will be interesting is how much of a platoon behind the dish it will be between Baldwin and Tromp while Murphy is on the mend. One would expect Murphy will carry the lion’s share of the catching responsibilities once he returns from his rib injury. That being said, I could see Braves Country falling in love with Baldwin if he proves to be ready for the show far earlier than expected.

That being said, it would not shock me if Baldwin was the player to go back down to Triple-A Gwinnett once Murphy comes off the injured list. This is because Baldwin has options at the minor league level, something we have to consider when it comes to Tromp at this stage of the game. Both will get meaningful experience with the big-league club this year, but we all know what the future entails.

The Braves will eventually pivot to Baldwin from Murphy, just like Atlanta did by pivoting to Murphy from d’Arnaud. Tromp seems to be stuck in the middle and may have his best luck catching on with another team once this Murphy injury/Baldwin ascension runs it course. In the meantime, we should expect the guy who handles the starting rotation the best between Baldwin and Tromp to start more.

If one or both play well, then this will afford Murphy plenty of time to recover from his latest injury.

Related Posts

REPORT: The problem with Jackson Holliday projections has nothing to do with him or Orioles

The Orioles have a lot of optimism for Holliday ahead of 2025, but history isn’t on his side. Jackson Holliday has been a very scrutinized man so…

Remembering Mets Opening Days (1968) Mets win First Home Opener in Gil Hodges Debut

The Mets had lost every opening day as well as every home opener since the franchise began play in 1962. Finally in 1968, the Mets won their…

REPORT: Braves’ Michael Harris II escalated ‘feud’ with Lawrence Butler including video proof

Atlanta Braves outfielder Michael Harris II is not backing down in his friendly feud with Lawrence Butler. This time, he brought video to prove his case.

Mаrcuѕ Semіen, Jаcob deGrom, аnd Other Rаnger Fаtherѕ Shаre Theіr Thoughtѕ on Wіnnіng а Chаmріonѕhір Durіng Chаllengіng Cіrcumѕtаnceѕ for Fаther’ѕ Dаy

As Father’s Day approaches, Marcus Semien, Jacob deGrom, and several other dads from the Texas Rangers take a moment to reflect on their journeys as fathers and athletes. Each of them has experienced the thrill of winning a championship, but…

SF Gіаntѕ cаtcher ѕаyѕ young аrm hаѕ “ѕome of the beѕt ѕtuff іn the gаme”

The SF Giants have plenty of exciting young arms in their organization, but catcher Patrick Bailey singled out right-hander Hayden Birdsong, saying he has “some

Cubѕ breаthe ѕіgh of relіef аfter young ѕtаr’ѕ ѕрrіng trаіnіng іnjury ѕcаre

Cubs outfielder Pete Crow-Armstrong is back in the lineup after an injury scare caused the team to scratch him on Monday.