Yankees face $36m dilemma as star man opts out of $144m deal

  • READ MORE: Yankees RELEASE star man in aftermath of World Series loss 

By Jack Bezants

Published: | Updated:

Gerrit Cole, the star pitcher for the New York Yankees, has opted out of his contract with the Bronx Bombers days after they lost the World Series to the Los Angeles Dodgers.

But under the terms of Cole’s deal, the Yankees can still keep hold of him. He has four years left on his current contract, worth $144m. But the Yankees have the first option to extend that deal by another year, for a cost of $36million.

The 34-year-old Cole is one of the finest pitchers in the game but made a humiliating error in Wednesday’s night game against the Dodgers that sparked an awful collapse from his team.

With two outs but the bases loaded for the Dodgers, Mookie Betts drilled the ball low to Anthony Rizzo but Cole failed to cover first and Betts made it easily, allowing the Dodgers to score.

From there, the Yankees 5-0 lead was obliterated and the Dodgers ended the inning with the score at 5-5. They ended up winning 7-6 for their eighth World Series title.

Gerrit Cole, the star pitcher for the New York Yankees , has opted out of his contract

‘I just didn’t know how hard he hit it and by the time the ball got by me, I was not in a position to cover first,’ Cole said after the game. ‘Neither of us were based on the spin of the baseball and [Rizzo] having to secure it. Just a bad read off the bat.’

Ultimately, it was not a surprise that Cole opted out of his deal with the chance to extend his stay on lucrative terms.

It would be a shock if the Yankees let him go. Cole missed the start of the season with an elbow issue and at one stage, there were fears he may have needed surgery that would have ended his campaign before it even started.

The Yankees also face a serious fight to keep Juan Soto, with the slugger entering free agency and a host of teams pursuing him on huge terms.

Soto, 26, is expected to be offered multi-year deals starting at around $600m. The Mets and Dodgers have been linked with rivaling the Yankees for him.

Earlier on Saturday, the Yankees announced that they are letting Anthony Rizzo go, meaning they will be in the market for new first baseman.

Related Posts

Cubs Fans Convinced William Contreras Taunted Craig Counsell

**NLDS Reality Check: Brewers Outclass Cubs, Counsell Caught in the Crossfire** If the first two games of the NLDS are any indication, the Chicago Cubs aren’t just behind the…

Giants’ Rising Phenom Ignites 2026 Hype with Untouchable Mound Mastery

Young SF Giants hurler Trevor McDonald only made two starts down the stretch in 2025. However, he impressed during that brief audition, and could pitch his way

Aѕtroѕ Mаke Bold 2026 Move Involvіng Brown аnd Eѕраdа

Astros Retain Dana Brown and Joe Espada-But the Pressure Is Real in Houston The Houston Astros won’t be making any front office changes just yet. After a disappointing season…

Cardinals’ Arbitration Bombshell: Fan Favorites Donovan and Nootbaar on the Chopping Block for Shocking Fire Sale

Each year, MLB Trade Rumors releases their arbitration projections around this time. While these are simply projections, MLBTR, who uses Matt Swartz’s model for

Corey Seager’s Jaw-Dropping Homer Rampage Redefines Rangers’ Record Books

аug 27, 2025; аrlіngton, Texаѕ, Uѕа; Texаѕ Rаngerѕ ѕhortѕtoр Corey ѕeаger (5) hіtѕ а two-run home run durіng the fourth іnnіng аgаіnѕt the Loѕ аngeleѕ аngelѕ аt…

5 tаkeаwаyѕ from Red Sox’ ѕeаѕon-endіng рreѕѕ conference

The Boston Red Sox wrapped up their 2025 season with a bittersweet press conference at Fenway Park on October 6, drawing a crowd of reporters eager for clues