Ex-Mets GM douses excitement over his former player making Yankees: ‘I’m sorry’

The Dominic Smith hype train is full steam ahead at the start of New York Yankees spring training. But it’s destined to end in disappointment if one former general manager is to be believed.

Speaking on SNY’s “Baseball Night in New York,” ex-New York Mets general manager Zack Scott said that despite Smith’s hot start — home runs in back-to-back games — he is still on the outskirts of the Yankees’ Opening Day lineup.

BUY YANKEES TICKETS: STUBHUB, VIVID SEATS, TICKETMASTER

“I don’t think he has much of a shot,” Scott said Wednesday. “And I definitely don’t think him having a good early start to spring training makes any difference. But, when I look at their roster, if (Giancarlo) Stanton’s on the IL, I guess he does have some chance being a left-handed bat. But I think they’d opt for versatility on their roster and fill the DH spot with a rotation in giving guys days off. I think he’s pretty low down on the depth chart, but i could be wrong.”

Scott, who was Smith’s general manager for a short period in 2021, doubled down on X afterward. He has not been a believer from the start.

“I’m sorry, Dom, but I don’t see it,” Scott wrote. “I still wonder if I didn’t initially get the Mets GM job because, in the interview, I suggested selling high on Dom after his great 2020 season. It probably wasn’t a good political suggestion when interviewing with the GM who drafted him. Oops.”

Scott likely was referencing Sandy Alderson, who drafted Smith in 2013 and was the team’s president in 2021. Smith, a high school draftee, made his major-league debut with the Mets in 2017 before Pete Alonso became entrenched as their first baseman two years later.

Smith broke out in 2020 as a part-time left fielder and first baseman (alongside Alonso) with a .316/.377/.616 line (168 OPS+) with 10 home runs and 42 RBIs. But he’s been a below-average offensive producer in the four major league seasons since and has spent considerable time in Triple-A in recent seasons.

In 693 major-league games and 2,266 plate appearances, Smith has a .246/.313/.403 line (97 OPS+) with 64 home runs and 259 RBIs. He batted .233/.313/.378 with six home runs and 34 RBIs in 307 plate appearances last season with the Boston Red Sox and Cincinnati Reds.

As Scott alluded, Smith, who signed a minor-league deal this offseason, needs his bat to carry him because he’s at the edge of the defensive spectrum as a first baseman and DH, where he played Wednesday.

But he’s still only 29 years old, in the middle of his prime years.

Speaking about the lefty earlier this month, Yankees manager Aaron Boone recognized that while Smith has been a good hitter throughout his big-league career, he realistically won’t make the Opening Day roster without a lane opening up.

“He’s here because we know if that lane does open up, we’ve got a quality hitter, quality person that you can add in the mix real easy,” Boone said.

That lane could be opened because Stanton is injured (tennis elbows in both arms) and away from the team.

And even if Smith doesn’t get the first opportunity now, he at least has put himself in the conversation to be part of the major-league mix eventually.

NJ Advance Media’s Max Goodman contributed to this report

  • Yankees thinking about Mets free agent slugger in wake of Giancarlo Stanton situation
  • Ex-Yankees outfielder lands on injured list
  • Why did Yankees ditch ‘New York, New York?’ It was the Dodgers. No kidding | Klapisch
  • Yankees’ Jazz Chisholm stays true to himself, throws out some massive self promotion
  • Latest on Giancarlo Stanton’s mystery absence, Yankees’ backup plans for DH

Thank you for relying on us to provide the journalism you can trust. Please consider supporting us with a subscription.

If you purchase a product or register for an account through a link on our site, we may receive compensation. By using this site, you consent to our User Agreement and agree that your clicks, interactions, and personal information may be collected, recorded, and/or stored by us and social media and other third-party partners in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Related Posts

🚨BOMBSHELL: One crucial question the NY Mets need to answer about Carlos Beltran after his Hall of Fame announcement — will the organization finally recognize his legacy and what he meant to the franchise, or will the past controversies overshadow his well-deserved honor? As Beltran’s induction stirs emotions, fans are eager to see how the Mets respond. Can the team embrace the moment, or will they struggle with the weight of history…ll 👇👇👇

CARLOS BELTRAN TO ENTER COOPERSTOWN WEARING A METS CAP—NOW THE QUESTION: WHEN WILL HIS NUMBER BE RETIRED? BREAKING NEWS: Carlos Beltran, one of the most iconic players…

Report: Timing Is Everything — and the Orioles’ Framber Valdez Pursuit Reflects That. With competition still forming, Baltimore appears uniquely positioned to turn this into a golden opportunity rather than a bidding war.

Seriously, Now Might Be the Time for the Orioles to Just Sign Framber Valdez Already At this point in the offseason, the ongoing “will they or won’t…

Breaking!! What Once Felt Like Patience Now Feels Like Pressure in Baltimore. The Orioles being tied to a $200M, two-time All-Star suggests a calculated win-now shift that could redefine the franchise’s immediate future.

JUST IN: A Bold Win-Now Shift Emerges as the Orioles Are Linked to a $200 Million Two-Time All-Star Following the White Sox Deal The tone surrounding the…

🚨EXCLUSIVE: Nolan McLean drops a truth bomb about Freddy Peralta’s impact on the Mets, revealing how the ace pitcher could elevate their pitching staff to new heights. McLean’s insight has fans buzzing, as Peralta’s potential to shake up the rotation becomes the hot topic in New York. Will this unexpected connection push the Mets to the top, or is it just another pipe dream…ll 👇👇👇

NEW YORK METS ACQUIRE FREDDY PERALTA TO LEAD ROTATION: A GAME-CHANGER FOR 2026 SEASON BREAKING NEWS: The New York Mets made a major move in their pursuit…

BRAVES NEWS: This Wasn’t a Revelation or a Projection — Spencer Strider Simply Confirmed What Braves Fans Already Believe About Spencer Schwellenbach

Spencer Strider’s Words on Spencer Schwellenbach Confirm What Braves Fans Already Know Spencer Strider didn’t break news. He confirmed a feeling. When the Atlanta Braves ace recently…

🚨REPORT: The Mets are among the top favorites to land a $210 million free agent, and the deal could reshape the landscape of the MLB. With their aggressive approach in the market, New York is making a major push to strengthen their roster for the upcoming season. Will this big-money move catapult the Mets into championship contention, or will it fall short of expectations…ll 👇👇👇

NEW YORK METS LINKED TO FRAMBER VALDEZ AS THEY LOOK TO BOLSTER THEIR ROTATION FOR 2026 SEASON BREAKING NEWS: After a disappointing 2025 season, the New York…