Braves surprise trade idea would land $270 million All-Star shortstop from NL rival | Sporting News

As the Atlanta Braves look to the 2025 season, there’s only one position on the diamond that truly looks like a question mark.

Though he surprisingly made the 2023 National League All-Star team, starting shortstop Orlando Arcia has been at risk of losing his job for quite some time now. A year removed from one of the worst offensive seasons in all of baseball, Arcia has to be on thin ice heading into spring training.

Fortunately for Arcia, the Braves haven’t made any signings or trades to replace him this winter, while their internal options to replace him remain thin. But there’s still time for Atlanta to pull off one of their signature surprise blockbuster deals before Opening Day.

If the Braves are feeling truly audacious, they could look to acquire one of the more risky contracts in the league from an NL rival hoping to shed salary.

On Monday, Zachary D. Rymer named San Diego Padres shortstop as an unlikely, but plausible trade candidate before the 2025 season, while singling out the Braves as the top team that should inquire about acquiring the four-time All-Star.

“It’s a real ‘Good luck with that…’ idea,” Rymer wrote. “Though Bogaerts has name value aplenty, he’s coming off a 1.2-rWAR season and his 11-year, $280 million contract still has nine seasons left.”

“But if trading for Bogaerts is a means of essentially buying a prospect, it could work. And if any contender should pick up the phone, it’s the shortstop-needy Braves.”

Bogaerts, 32, made all four of his All-Star teams and won five Silver Slugger Awards with the Boston Red Sox. The Padres surprised nearly everyone with their albatross contract offer two winters ago, and with the team now clawing to stay under the luxury tax, that expenditure seems unwise.

Still, Bogaerts has a 106 OPS+ in his injury-shortened time with the Padres thus far, and he’s got a .289/.352/.451 career slash line. Plus, he wouldn’t be the first veteran to find a second wind in Atlanta, should the Braves and Padres agree on an offer that both sides find agreeable.

More MLB: Blue Jays hypothetical blockbuster ships $150 million four-time All-Star to Royals

Related Posts

🚨 GOOD UPDATE: The wait may finally be coming to an end for Braves fans as Ronald Acuña Jr. is reportedly on track to return immediately after completing exactly 10 days on the injured list. ⚾ Atlanta has been fighting to stay dominant without its superstar spark plug, but the possibility of Acuña returning this quickly could completely change the energy surrounding the club. 🔥 Opposing pitchers may not be ready for what’s coming next, because a healthy Acuña has the power to instantly reignite the Braves’ offense and put the entire National League on alert. 👀 If this timeline holds, one of baseball’s most electric stars could be back far sooner than many expected.

Ronald Acuña Jr. Injury Update Gives Braves Fans Massive Boost Ahead of Crucial Stretch The Atlanta Braves may be getting one of baseball’s most electrifying superstars back…

🚨 BREAKING: Just when it looked like the season was slipping away, the Minnesota Twins are suddenly seeing a shocking path back into the AL playoff race. ⚾ The latest American League standings have quietly given Twins fans a real reason to believe that October baseball may still be alive despite months of frustration and inconsistency. 🔥 Injuries, tough losses, and growing pressure haven’t broken this team yet — and now momentum could be shifting at exactly the right time for Minnesota. 👀 If the Twins catch fire over the next few weeks, this remarkable playoff picture could turn into one of the biggest comeback stories of the 2026 MLB season.

Minnesota Twins Still Have a Pulse in the AL Playoff Race Despite Brutal Start to 2026 Season The 2026 MLB season has been frustrating, disappointing, and emotionally…

⚡ BREAKING: White Sox see a golden opportunity in a wide-open AL Central, signaling they could make bold moves to seize control. Every game, every roster decision could tip the balance in this highly competitive division. Chicago’s front office is ready to strike—and the race just got a whole lot more intense 👇👇👇

With the AL Central title up for grabs, the Chicago White Sox have a prime opportunity to capitalize and climb to the top of the standings. IMAGE:…

🔥 BREAKING: Craig Breslow speaks out on Jason Varitek’s current role with the Boston Red Sox, shedding new light on the veteran’s influence behind the scenes. Insights reveal how “Tek” continues to shape the clubhouse and mentor the next generation. Could this mark a pivotal moment in Boston’s rebuilding story? 👇👇👇

Boston Red Sox game planning coordinator/catching coach Jason Varitek looks on from the dugout during a baseball game against the Texas Rangers Saturday, Aug. 3, 2024, in…

💥 BREAKING: Phillies and Red Sox make history with shock managerial firings this early in the season. The MLB world is reeling as two franchises pull the trigger before anyone expected, sending ripples through clubhouse dynamics. Could this unprecedented move reshape the race for the pennant? 👇👇👇

Before the calendar even flipped to May, the Philadelphia Phillies and Boston Red Sox made major changes to their teams. Both franchises decided it was time to…

🚨 ALERT: Atlanta Braves face a critical decision — trade their $73 million star before it’s too late? The clock is ticking as fans and analysts debate whether holding onto such a high-value player risks chemistry, salary cap strain, or missed opportunities. Every game, every pitch matters, and the pressure to act grows with each passing day. Braves Nation, what would you do: keep loyalty alive or make the strategic move before it’s too late?

Atlanta Braves May Face Tough Decision on Catcher Sean Murphy After Early-Season Struggles The Atlanta Braves, currently holding MLB’s best record, recently dropped two of three games…