Braves surprise trade idea would land $270 million All-Star shortstop from NL rival | Sporting News

As the Atlanta Braves look to the 2025 season, there’s only one position on the diamond that truly looks like a question mark.

Though he surprisingly made the 2023 National League All-Star team, starting shortstop Orlando Arcia has been at risk of losing his job for quite some time now. A year removed from one of the worst offensive seasons in all of baseball, Arcia has to be on thin ice heading into spring training.

Fortunately for Arcia, the Braves haven’t made any signings or trades to replace him this winter, while their internal options to replace him remain thin. But there’s still time for Atlanta to pull off one of their signature surprise blockbuster deals before Opening Day.

If the Braves are feeling truly audacious, they could look to acquire one of the more risky contracts in the league from an NL rival hoping to shed salary.

On Monday, Zachary D. Rymer named San Diego Padres shortstop as an unlikely, but plausible trade candidate before the 2025 season, while singling out the Braves as the top team that should inquire about acquiring the four-time All-Star.

“It’s a real ‘Good luck with that…’ idea,” Rymer wrote. “Though Bogaerts has name value aplenty, he’s coming off a 1.2-rWAR season and his 11-year, $280 million contract still has nine seasons left.”

“But if trading for Bogaerts is a means of essentially buying a prospect, it could work. And if any contender should pick up the phone, it’s the shortstop-needy Braves.”

Bogaerts, 32, made all four of his All-Star teams and won five Silver Slugger Awards with the Boston Red Sox. The Padres surprised nearly everyone with their albatross contract offer two winters ago, and with the team now clawing to stay under the luxury tax, that expenditure seems unwise.

Still, Bogaerts has a 106 OPS+ in his injury-shortened time with the Padres thus far, and he’s got a .289/.352/.451 career slash line. Plus, he wouldn’t be the first veteran to find a second wind in Atlanta, should the Braves and Padres agree on an offer that both sides find agreeable.

More MLB: Blue Jays hypothetical blockbuster ships $150 million four-time All-Star to Royals

Related Posts

🔥 CONTRACT SHOCKWAVE: Alex Bregmаn’ѕ $120 Mіllіon Deаl Now Rаіѕіng Alаrmѕ іn Boѕton — Red Sox Wаtch аѕ Hіѕ Lаteѕt Commentѕ on “Not Chаѕіng the Bаll Quіckly” Fuel Fruѕtrаtіon Among Mаnаgement аnd Fаnѕ!

BOѕTON – The Boѕton Red ѕox’ѕ whіrlwіnd romаnce wіth аlex Bregmаn, forged іn the deѕрerаte fіreѕ of lаѕt wіnter’ѕ free аgency, аррeаrѕ to be heаdіng towаrd аn…

🔥 THIS IS NOT A DRILL: Red Sox poised for MONSTER SWING at two-time MVP in an “all-in” blockbuster move!

The Boston Red Sox stormed into the postseason last year, but they’re not resting on their laurels—they’re eyeing a seismic upgrade to catapult them deeper

⚾ OFFSEASON SHAKE-UP IN ATLANTA: The Braves have officially declined club options on relievers Tyler Kinley and Pierce Johnson, marking the start of what could be a major bullpen overhaul this winter. The moves free up nearly $12 million in payroll space, giving Atlanta flexibility to chase new arms or reallocate funds toward rotation depth. For fans, it’s a bittersweet decision — two veterans who helped steady the pen at times now hit free agency, as the Braves look to reshape their pitching identity for 2026.

The Atlanta Braves on Thursday declined club options on two right-handed relivers, according to reports.

BREAKING ANALYSIS: New numbers circulating around Green Bay paint a dramatic picture of just how hard losing Tucker Kraft could hit the Packers offense

Oct 26, 2025; ріttѕburgh, рennѕylvаnіа, Uѕа; Green Bаy раckerѕ tіght end Tucker Krаft (85) runѕ the bаll аgаіnѕt the ріttѕburgh ѕteelerѕ durіng the thіrd quаrter аt аcrіѕure…

REPORT: Brаveѕ mаke unѕurрrіѕіng $18 mіllіon Chrіѕ Sаle contrаct decіѕіon

Chrіѕ ѕаle, the 2024 Nаtіonаl Leаgue Cy Young аwаrd wіnner, hаd hіѕ $18 mіllіon club oрtіon ріcked uр by the Brаveѕ. The аtlаntа Brаveѕ аre аlreаdy mаkіng moveѕ to…

🔥 THE FUTURE OF FENWAY IS HERE: Rising star Roman Anthony has officially been named the 2025 Rookie with the Most Long-Term Value, cementing his place as Boston’s next franchise cornerstone. Scouts and analysts rave about his rare combination of plate discipline, power, and maturity beyond his years — the kind of player teams build dynasties around. For Red Sox fans, this isn’t just an award — it’s a glimpse into a brighter, more dominant era taking shape inside Fenway Park.

MLB.com’s Jim Callis ranked Roman Anthony as the top newcomers from the 2025 season based on long-term potential.