49ers need to get on the phone with Colts to trade for All-Pro defensive lineman

Indianapolis Colts defensive tackle DeForest Buckner (99)
Indianapolis Colts defensive tackle DeForest Buckner (99) / Jack Gorman/GettyImages

The 49ers need defensive line help, and an easy solution would be to trade for this well-known Colts All-Pro.

The San Francisco 49ers’ Week 9 bye comes at a perfect time. Not only is it squarely in the middle of the season, affording some much-needed rest and recovery, but it also takes place right before the 2024 NFL trade deadline.

That affords the Niners a chance to sit back, relax and see what happens across the league, specifically which teams will look to be buyers and which ones will “punt on the year” and turn into sellers.

General manager John Lynch said there aren’t any trades currently on the table. But things can change in a hurry. Even he admitted that.

Lynch and San Francisco can potentially take advantage, and there’s one player the 49ers should be eyeing closely.

The Niners can regret trading away one of their former Pro Bowl star players, defensive tackle DeForest Buckner, who was dealt early in 2020 to the Colts for a first-round NFL Draft pick, subsequently used on another defensive tackle, Javon Kinlaw, who never came close to replicating the former’s on-field production.

If the Colts turn into sellers at the deadline, San Francisco can rectify that mistake.

Buckner, 30 years old, continued his Pro Bowl ways after that trade, securing a first-team All-Pro nod in 2020 but has spent a chunk of this season on injured reserve with an ankle injury.

The 49ers, meanwhile, have hurt for interior defensive line help, especially after losing Pro Bowl defensive tackle Javon Hargrave to a potential season-ending triceps injury.

Should Indy be interested in moving Buckner, the Niners must find their way to first in line.

From a contract perspective, Buckner is signed through 2026 and carries $26.6 million cap hits for the next two years. However, there’s no guaranteed money on the final year of his deal, affording San Francisco a chance to get creative with either an extension or restructure to lessen a post-trade cap hit.

Buckner would no longer command a first- or even a second-round pick in return either, which means the 49ers could likely package a mid-round pick (or two) to send back in exchange.

Despite the recent injury, Buckner has shown no signs of slowing down despite being on the wrong side of 30 years old. He’s coming off back-to-back eight-sack seasons and already recorded 2.5 this year over just three games played.

The 2024 NFL trade deadline is Nov. 5.

Related Posts

🚨 TIME UPDATE: NFL аnnounceѕ new ѕtаrt tіme for Pаckerѕ vѕ. Bengаlѕ, leаvіng fаnѕ ѕcrаmblіng to аdjuѕt theіr gаme-dаy рlаnѕ

Here’s everything you need to know about what comes next for the Packers.

EXCLUSIVE STATEMENT: Cowboys offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer dropped a truth bomb about Dak Prescott that fans have secretly agreed with for weeks. The honesty in his words might just change how everyone views the quarterback.

Brіan ѕchottenheіmer juѕt ѕaіd what all Cowboyѕ fanѕ are thіnkіng about Dak рreѕcott Dallaѕ Cowboyѕ v New York Jetѕ – NFL 2025 | іѕhіka ѕamant/Gettyіmageѕ Forget quarterbackѕ,…

EXCLUSIVE REACTION: Sources say Dak Prescott dropped a hilarious yet shocking comment after Ryan Flournoy’s monster game. Even the coaching staff couldn’t help but crack up hearing his uncensored take.

Cowboyѕ’ Dak рreѕcott had NѕFW reactіon to Ryan Flournoy’ѕ Week 5 eruрtіon Oct 5, 2025; eaѕt Rutherford, New Jerѕey, UѕA; Dallaѕ Cowboyѕ wіde receіver Ryan Flournoy (19)…

The Cowboys’ 37 to 22 victory over the Jets is more than just another win. Analysts reveal eight powerful reasons this game could redefine their entire season and silence every critic in sight.

The Dallas Cowboys improved to 2–2–1 after a 37–22 win over the New York Jets. Here are four takeaways and four risks that highlight where Dallas excelled…

🔥 EXCLUSIVE INSIDE: Pаckerѕ executіveѕ ѕаy the іnіtіаtіve аіmѕ to buіld “chаmріonѕ for lіfe,” gіvіng рlаyerѕ the toolѕ to thrіve long аfter they leаve the fіeld

Greeп Bay, WI – October 5, 2025

Portnoy’ѕ Sаvаge Tаkedown: Joѕh Allen Chokeѕ аѕ Rookіe QB Humіlіаteѕ Bіllѕ іn Exрloѕіve Pаtrіotѕ Shocker

Bills Fall at Home as Patriots Deliver Gut-Punch in Week 5 Upset After five weeks of riding high, the Buffalo Bills finally hit a wall – and it wasn’t a small one. It was the…